Blocktopia Mafia Season 3
- Thread starter Alisha
- Start date
- Status
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
I'm going to give some discussion and view on paceboys reveal of his doctor role as well, however I have the opposite idea of him as I do 77. So...
BEEEEEE PREPAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARED...... For a wall of text!
SHOULD BELIEVE
The doctor is important, like the cop, and is normally essential to the success of the town. If the cop can successfully block out attacks on our civilian and good power roles, the town has a greater chance of winning. Now paceboys is a good player in my opinion, and a hilarious one at that, and I feel he knows what he's doing, especially if he was the doctor. His examination that there was only ONE DEATH most likely means a doctor saved his target, OR, it was an iron golem / someone aloud 2 hits during the night. If paceboys was truly the doctor, he should in great honesty state whom he saved during the night, and that person can possibly prove or disprove his story, WITHOUT saying their role that is.
SHOULD NOT BELIEVE
Well... Is it just me... Or did pace state his role relatively fast and with no direct reason to stating it? I saw no direct attacks on Pace. There was no real discussion about the doctor and such, and was really only provoked because 77_is_the_best stated he was the c0p.
Also, did Pace really give an explanation when he revealed his possible role? I may be wrong, but I saw no comment about this from him when he stated it. The doctor, as well as the cop, are important power roles. When someone states they are in fact one of these roles, it is extremely hard to believe them, or, an extremely amount of trust is shown. I believe pace’s reveal makes him a bit obvious to be NOT the doctor, but NOT the mafia either.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
This is my opinion, it may not be as totally detailed as mine with 77’s and I hope I get my point across. That is… Pace is most likely NOT the doctor, but NOT the mafia either, in some sorts. Make sure to rub it in my face like a pie if I am wrong on this matter, for really there is no telling what is what, and whom is whom during the first day….
THIS IS A LOOOOONG FIRST DAY BY THE WAY.
The doctor is important, like the cop, and is normally essential to the success of the town. If the cop can successfully block out attacks on our civilian and good power roles, the town has a greater chance of winning. Now paceboys is a good player in my opinion, and a hilarious one at that, and I feel he knows what he's doing, especially if he was the doctor. His examination that there was only ONE DEATH most likely means a doctor saved his target, OR, it was an iron golem / someone aloud 2 hits during the night. If paceboys was truly the doctor, he should in great honesty state whom he saved during the night, and that person can possibly prove or disprove his story, WITHOUT saying their role that is.
SHOULD NOT BELIEVE
Well... Is it just me... Or did pace state his role relatively fast and with no direct reason to stating it? I saw no direct attacks on Pace. There was no real discussion about the doctor and such, and was really only provoked because 77_is_the_best stated he was the c0p.
Also, did Pace really give an explanation when he revealed his possible role? I may be wrong, but I saw no comment about this from him when he stated it. The doctor, as well as the cop, are important power roles. When someone states they are in fact one of these roles, it is extremely hard to believe them, or, an extremely amount of trust is shown. I believe pace’s reveal makes him a bit obvious to be NOT the doctor, but NOT the mafia either.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
This is my opinion, it may not be as totally detailed as mine with 77’s and I hope I get my point across. That is… Pace is most likely NOT the doctor, but NOT the mafia either, in some sorts. Make sure to rub it in my face like a pie if I am wrong on this matter, for really there is no telling what is what, and whom is whom during the first day….
THIS IS A LOOOOONG FIRST DAY BY THE WAY.
Gosh, this 77/Defiant situation could go either way.
If we lynch 77 today, and he's a cop, Defiant will be untrusted.
If we lynch 77 today, and he's mafia, there's a higher chance Defiant can be trusted, unless this is all a setup.
However...
If we lynch Defiant today, and he's not mafia, 77 is completely untrusted, and would either die tonight, or die tomorrow.
If we lynch Defiant today, and he is mafia, 77 will probably die tonight.
So.
MUCH.
DRAMA!
If we lynch 77 today, and he's a cop, Defiant will be untrusted.
If we lynch 77 today, and he's mafia, there's a higher chance Defiant can be trusted, unless this is all a setup.
However...
If we lynch Defiant today, and he's not mafia, 77 is completely untrusted, and would either die tonight, or die tomorrow.
If we lynch Defiant today, and he is mafia, 77 will probably die tonight.
So.
MUCH.
DRAMA!
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Trying to kill off one of the most experienced eh.... Well that actually led me to believe that 77 is LESS of the role of Mafia if you believe that.
Defiant_Blob is yes, an EXTREMELY experienced player in this. Looking at his posts since the game began, he is more skilled then I came to believe, mainly it seems he knows what goes on in professional Mafia. He's read pieces off of a Mafia website that gave us the Hooker and Slime (Town Drunk) roles to play as this round. What is it that doesn't lead us to believe he is NOT a possible Mafia / bad power role.
Prove me wrong if I am indeed backing up one of the Mafia since it is quite obvious 77 is going to die, but with 77_is_the_best post on Defiant, as well as HarmakPaul 's post on him being skilled, though I do not have enough evidence (WE CAN NEVER HAVE ENOUGH EVIDENCE IN MAFIA GAMES IT SEEMS >.<)
My vote is on Defiant_Blob
Agreed, my world has been flipped upside down, reflipped, flipped trice, and now my brain is like soup
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
I would prefer Jell-O or pudding thank you. Soup just doesn't work well with me.Agreed, my world has been flipped upside down, reflipped, flipped trice, and now my brain is like soup
If so, i shall die C:
WAIT A SECOND.
Doesn't this seem kinda... well, it seems like sploorky is trying to prove that i cant protect myself, and that i should be able to die... this makes me think that he is the mafia, or worse. Just, an opinion.
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
As Sploorky said, we don't know if the Doctor can save himself more then once a Game. This was discussed at the end of the last Mafia game, and I do not know if we came to the conclusion. If the fact that this is in fact true and you can only save yourself once a round of Mafia, and you are INDEED the doctor, you have just painted a giant target on yourself for the Mafia to kill tonight.
Another outcome-
Though you say you are the doctor, and is not possibly killed tonight (This is if you can only save yourself once as Doctor), then you have cast suspicion down on you that you are Mafia this round, because I don't think the Mafia would not leap at the chance to get rid of a dangerous power role against them.
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
I think I wrapped this up in the post I made that came RIGHT AFTER YOURS. xD
Always interesting how two posts near the same discussion can have totally different views!
- Status