Trouble in the West: Pirates vs Cowboys [Finished]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
srsly

That "contradiction" shows nothing. It's basically grasping at straws to make him look more suspicious.
May I ask how? He clearly says one thing at one moment then another at another moment in an attempt to possibly make Hype look more suspicious by making it seem strange that Hype received a message and he didn't. I honestly find that a scummy thing to do and don't think it's just 'grasping at straws'
 

Duffie

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,880
Reaction score
5,077
May I ask how? He clearly says one thing at one moment then another at another moment in an attempt to possibly make Hype look more suspicious by making it seem strange that Hype received a message and he didn't. I honestly find that a scummy thing to do and don't think it's just 'grasping at straws'
From what I see, Jivvi's stating that he didn't receive a message for being visited, but did receive a message that he armed a bomb, indicating based on his role that he has been visited.
 

HypeBurst

Just Fabulous
Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
450
Reaction score
1,165
I started typing that post when you only had those two posts posted. You didnt have your explanation at that time. I can "comprehend" things rather well, thank you very much but when someone says, they "didnt receive a message AT ALL", you can see why the blatant contradiction can be seen.

Even if that was explained, the rest of my post still applies in that you are constantly writing these passive aggressive posts against me, so seem like you arent attacking me, simply because I "attacked" you.

Actually please point out where my "relentless attacks" on you are? I count two posts, two posts where I reference you at all. Even in that item discussion, I looked towards fiesta more, even though now looking back you had an equal hand in that whole discussion.

Also, Hype, one so paranoid as to strap a bomb to themselves at the hinting of danger would probably notice who paid him a visit. Alas no.
No you wouldnt mate, if an investigative role came to visit you, you wouldnt know who visited you because they didnt affect you at all. Whereas I got dumped on with gasoline.
 

Jivvi

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
2,769
Reaction score
4,596
I started typing that post when you only had those two posts posted. You didnt have your explanation at that time. I can "comprehend" things rather well, thank you very much but when someone says, they "didnt receive a message AT ALL", you can see why the blatant contradiction can be seen.

Even if that was explained, the rest of my post still applies in that you are constantly writing these passive aggressive posts against me, so seem like you arent attacking me, simply because I "attacked" you.

Actually please point out where my "relentless attacks" on you are? I count two posts, two posts where I reference you at all. Even in that item discussion, I looked towards fiesta more, even though now looking back you had an equal hand in that whole discussion.


No you wouldnt mate, if an investigative role came to visit you, you wouldnt know who visited you because they didnt affect you at all. Whereas I got dumped on with gasoline.
Like I said, it's most probably that this quirk aplies either to all visits or none, and as the Arsonist revolves around remaining undiscovered, I'm not exactly trusting of your claim.

And anyway, what did you expect, me to go to my death tied to the front of the bandwagon you and Digi started?
 

HypeBurst

Just Fabulous
Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
450
Reaction score
1,165
Like I said, it's most probably that this quirk aplies either to all visits or none, and as the Arsonist revolves around remaining undiscovered, I'm not exactly trusting of your claim.

And anyway, what did you expect, me to go to my death tied to the front of the bandwagon you and Digi started?
All visits? "You got a pm from Prizyms, Btw you got visited by the cop last night". Im pretty sure the only visits that would be told would be the ones which you couldnt overlook realistically. I would have to be pretty out of it to not realise Im getting completely drowned in gasoline.

And the second pair of lines, "what did you expect?" I expected that I would express my opinion that no one in their right minds would warn the mafia about hitting you when you had the potential to blow one up. Thats why I voted you, now thats what seems strange to me. And how did I start a bandwagon against you at all? I was the last people to vote for you (other than ooglie who just unvoted).

Now, ill ask nicely, Please show me this relentless attack that supposedly I have orchestrated against you? I cant see it at all. My FoS has been Swate throughout this game, you never crossed my mind UNTIL your completely unneeded claim.
 

Enderfive

sarcasm incarnate
Mafia Host
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
2,039
Reaction score
4,802
All visits? "You got a pm from Prizyms, Btw you got visited by the cop last night". Im pretty sure the only visits that would be told would be the ones which you couldnt overlook realistically. I would have to be pretty out of it to not realise Im getting completely drowned in gasoline.
I'm gonna have to point out that he said that he would be notified when his bomb was armed, not who or how he was visited.

Actually, now that I think of it, how would he know exactly he was roleblocked in that case?
 

Mooglie

The Local Cow
Joined
Sep 23, 2011
Messages
1,195
Reaction score
5,772
@Ooglie101 are you even capable of not switching your votes around every 5 minutes :S
*votes you due to good evidence against you*
*unvotes you due to you giving good explanation*
*votes fiestaguy due to gut feeling*
*unvotes to vote jivvi*
*votes jivvi*
*unvotes since it was a misunderstanding*
*votes fiesta, my gut feeling again*

All of my votes have good reasoning behind them and I am actually rather suspicious of you calling this out when just a bit ago I said it was good someone finally had suspicion on me for jumping votes to Ender, possibly trying to win my trust, eh?

Finally I'm town and I'm not letting this win slide. c:
 

Oak Milk

Kill Hungry Thirsty Dead
Mafia Host
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
1,267
Reaction score
1,922
*votes you due to good evidence against you*
*unvotes you due to you giving good explanation*
*votes fiestaguy due to gut feeling*
*unvotes to vote jivvi*
*votes jivvi*
*unvotes since it was a misunderstanding*
*votes fiesta, my gut feeling again*

All of my votes have good reasoning behind them and I am actually rather suspicious of you calling this out when just a bit ago I said it was good someone finally had suspicion on me for jumping votes to Ender, possibly trying to win my trust, eh?

Finally I'm town and I'm not letting this win slide. c:
Just a flashback to quite a number of mafia games ago, when a particular person would not stop voting between two people, ended up getting themself lynched for poor reasoning at the end (this person was in fact mafia).

In my opinion it never hurts to point out you have been jumping around with your votes. Much like people did in Day 0 to me.

From then on I tend to
 

HypeBurst

Just Fabulous
Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
450
Reaction score
1,165
I'm gonna have to point out that he said that he would be notified when his bomb was armed, not who or how he was visited.

Actually, now that I think of it, how would he know exactly he was roleblocked in that case?
Yes I now understand that he would be notified when his bomb is armed, but he also said that if I was notified of my gasoline-ing, it would be that everyone who gets visited would know they got visited, which makes little to no sense.

He assumed that it was Notty who visited him because he didnt die. But theres so many other options that could have happened where he didnt die. But he used that assumption to continuously say that it was strange that I was told I got poured on by gasoline. I have this point in the post that you stated "didnt support anything". Can you see it from my point of view that that seems iffy?
 

Oak Milk

Kill Hungry Thirsty Dead
Mafia Host
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
1,267
Reaction score
1,922
Just a flashback to quite a number of mafia games ago, when a particular person would not stop voting between two people, ended up getting themself lynched for poor reasoning at the end (this person was in fact mafia).

In my opinion it never hurts to point out you have been jumping around with your votes. Much like people did in Day 0 to me.

From then on I tend to
Man posting can be a real pain sometimes, ignore the bolded part.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top