SCP - Secure, Contain, Mafia [GAME OVER]
- Thread starter Fiestaguy
- Start date
- Status
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
I can't really think of any reason for you to say this as a mafia or third party either, but I do feel like it's more plausible for a new mafia or 3rd party to say things like that rather than a new townie to say things like that, due to the fact that people tend to be more conscious about their level of suspicion and attention on them when they have something to hide. Townies don't usually worry about getting attention on them until they actually have it on them. You, on the other hand, went and said in your first post that you didn't want to attract any attention, which seems more like a thing that a scum would think about (although, yes, not outright state it in the thread).
Assuming we choose to lynch today I see several candidates at the moment
Notty
Oak
Caffeinated kitty
Iggy
The notty/ oak argument looks legitimate to me. Notty is known for purely hypothetical arguments placed exactly in the wrong situation and oaks concern looks legit. I don't feel there's enough to go on from either side everything looks normal to me.
The iggy /caff situation is a bit more interesting. Iggy's actions seem normal to me. Let's be honest, being in the spotlight can be bad no matter who you are , though Iggy's method basically was the equivalent of walking into a room screaming 'don't look at me' it does look like a method used by someone who isn't experienced enough to know how to react to situations and when to react in certain ways that is a new players mistake.
Caff on the other hand looks a tad more suspicious right now and is the only person I'd be willing to lynch. I can't explain it but something about caffs vote doesn't feel like it adds up.
Overall we can't limit ourselves to looking at only four people. My gut says there's a good chance all 4 could be innocent. We must look deeper at people not in the spotlight.
Notty
Oak
Caffeinated kitty
Iggy
The notty/ oak argument looks legitimate to me. Notty is known for purely hypothetical arguments placed exactly in the wrong situation and oaks concern looks legit. I don't feel there's enough to go on from either side everything looks normal to me.
The iggy /caff situation is a bit more interesting. Iggy's actions seem normal to me. Let's be honest, being in the spotlight can be bad no matter who you are , though Iggy's method basically was the equivalent of walking into a room screaming 'don't look at me' it does look like a method used by someone who isn't experienced enough to know how to react to situations and when to react in certain ways that is a new players mistake.
Caff on the other hand looks a tad more suspicious right now and is the only person I'd be willing to lynch. I can't explain it but something about caffs vote doesn't feel like it adds up.
Overall we can't limit ourselves to looking at only four people. My gut says there's a good chance all 4 could be innocent. We must look deeper at people not in the spotlight.
Fiestaguy
The man with 8 fingers.
Vote Count: More voting stuff for the voting god!
Nottykitten: 1 (Old_Man_Oak_63) [14 more]
Ltin: 1 (Ooglie101) [14 more]
Iggy234: 2 (Caffeinatedkitty, xXxFruitninjaxXx) [13 more]
No Lynch/Lunch?: 9 (Nottykitten, Midnightgirl24, Dessern5, Iggy234, Raxo2222, Naoh, Faliara, Brownlee123, Naoh) [5 more]
28 are present, 15 votes for a murder and 14 votes for a no lynch.
If there are any miscounts/formatting errors. Please let us know!
Nottykitten: 1 (Old_Man_Oak_63) [14 more]
Ltin: 1 (Ooglie101) [14 more]
Iggy234: 2 (Caffeinatedkitty, xXxFruitninjaxXx) [13 more]
No Lynch/Lunch?: 9 (Nottykitten, Midnightgirl24, Dessern5, Iggy234, Raxo2222, Naoh, Faliara, Brownlee123, Naoh) [5 more]
28 are present, 15 votes for a murder and 14 votes for a no lynch.
If there are any miscounts/formatting errors. Please let us know!
If Iggy wasn't new I'd probably say he was a mafia or a 3rd party but I've seen in a few of his other posts in other threads and (no offence) you don't seem to be the best at wording stuff or getting through what you want to say. I don't think CaffeinatedKitty's original vote right of the bat was too suspicious. I did it a few times in Retaking Rochester and for me it was just because for a moment I'd let my reasoning slip and just thought "THAT GUY'S EVIL!!!" and voted him. Caff's reaction to being accused to the vote was slighty suspicious but still not enough in my opinion for a vote so for now I'm going to stick with no vote but I may easily vote iggy if he digs his hole for himself any deeper.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
I think we get the idea that, after about 5 posts of the same thing (oh this and that and this and that and iggy and caff and blah blah blah) I think we get the idea that most people have a bit of a feeling towards caff/iggy due to their actions.
Okay so my 2 cents, I've always been of the opinion we should lynch D0/1. Today's FoS seems to be on iggy and caff and I not really super suspicious of either. If you'll notice in my last three games I often get a "gut" feeling and it turns out to be right (than I push super hard with no evidence randomly succeed and get killed by mafia that night) and I'm not really getting anything yet. Still if these are our options I'm curious to see who will fall where when it comes time to reveal who we wish to lynch (if we do).
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Uhm. You do realize that when everyone state their opinions about the questions at hand, that's when we really know what everyone thinks and that's when the discussion happens? I mean, you sound like you're angry at people for stating their opinions.
Oak Milk
Kill Hungry Thirsty Dead
Honestly, I think the most we have to worry about chicken is that he is 3rd party, mafia? Probably not, I have a feeling the mafia is in fact Caff I'm just right now struggling to put my thoughts into words (as per usual) so I'll be back when I have a somewhat decent explanation of my thoughts.
Oh okay.
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 244, 229)]
[/BCOLOR]iggy234 said:
Iggy if people start to think you're suspicious they'll keep on thinking your suspicious until you can provide a satisfactory explanation for your actions. Stop saying stuff that sound like your desperate for people to stop thinking your suspicious which just makes people think your more suspicious because your so desperate not to be noticed which is what an 3rd party or mafia member would sometimes try to do.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
What my arguments(which mostly aren't purely hypothetical) are never used in the wrong situation =O? I'm confused.
About the Caff/Iggy thing, I don't think caff is Mafia. Iggy is choosing really bad wording so he makes himself pretty suspicious. However I still stand by my No Lynch vote for now.
Finger of suspicion.
You just listed the 3 people who think you're most suspicious. Also the only person we're really 'putting suspicion on' is you because you're acting really suspiciously atm.iggy234 said:I am suspecting three people... Caff ender and chicken. Caff is being suspicious and chicken and ender are giving subtle clues that are putting the attention on other people. Very sly and clever.
- Status