SCP - Secure, Contain, Mafia [GAME OVER]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Timdood3

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
2,339
Reaction score
2,824
Why would myusername say caff was mafia if he knew she was not?

He's probably paranoid, because to claim cop the first day on a guilty investigation is weird, but at least now he knows he is probably paranoid. And why would the mafia try to take out a vanilla townie with a cop claim. It's illogical.

What about Dess?

If Dess were mafia trying to get myusername, then why wouldn't he have a report? It's like, "HEY GUYS, MYUSER NAME IS LYING, I'M THE COP... but I... I don't have any proof." What I'm saying is that if Dess was mafia, he would have a report on caff, saying she's town.

In conclusion:
My opinion is, they're both town.


Now, I don't know how the discussion has been going so far, as I type this while it is still night, so hopefully, nothing much has been said in the first hour.
Good point out by notty about ender's death, because I think a lot of the actions are after a certain amount of time during the day.
For example, I'm sending this message 1 hour after the day starts.
Last night, in my inn there was a similar anonymous message.

I think it's the same player because both posts share the same thoughts.

I do NOT think we should be trying to figure out the identity of this player, though and I'm pretty sure it's town.

As for my own opinions:
I'm convinced that Dess is town. What mafia member would cc cop without a report? I mean, I just can't wrap my head around why they would do such a thing. It would draw far too much attention.

I'm still not sure about myu. I think he's either paranoid (the one that makes ALL investigations mafia) or mafia. It's my personal opinion that Notty is mafia. I'll explain why at a later point in time.

Someone mentioned having "an abundance of medical roles." I disagree. Simply because a flavor name implied being part of a group, does NOT mean we have an abundance. Two maybe, any more? Nah. I think one insane and one sane. Perhaps there is a larger medical team, but that doesn't mean they are necessarily involved in the game.
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
more improvisation than anything, but I would like to find a pattern within the inns if possible
which would also involve finding out the other inmates
a secondary goal would be to find out the cause of the long nights and eliminate the offenders
So absolutely no followup about caff's death?

You seemed so eager to Lynch caff[who as innocent] without any good reasoning at all. The only reasoning I could possibly imagine you having for lynching caff was to prove or disprove Myusers cop claim. But you haven't said a word about it.

So to me it seems like you lynched caff for no reason at all, making us waste our lynch and gaining us absolutely nothing. While the Mafia just gained an advantage. Very, very anti-town like play. Or am I seeing things wrong here? If so please explain what you were thinking lynching caff.
 
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
148
Reaction score
263
Last night, in my inn there was a similar anonymous message.

I think it's the same player because both posts share the same thoughts.

I do NOT think we should be trying to figure out the identity of this player, though and I'm pretty sure it's town.

As for my own opinions:
I'm convinced that Dess is town. What mafia member would cc cop without a report? I mean, I just can't wrap my head around why they would do such a thing. It would draw far too much attention.

I'm still not sure about myu. I think he's either paranoid (the one that makes ALL investigations mafia) or mafia. It's my personal opinion that Notty is mafia. I'll explain why at a later point in time.

Someone mentioned having "an abundance of medical roles." I disagree. Simply because a flavor name implied being part of a group, does NOT mean we have an abundance. Two maybe, any more? Nah. I think one insane and one sane. Perhaps there is a larger medical team, but that doesn't mean they are necessarily involved in the game.
If you ask me, the mafia probably has an investigative role. Madgab certainly wasn't on my radar and yet the mafia just so happen to kill a doc role; that doesn't sit right with me. Now we have two claimed investigators, for user we lynched caff yesterday just to see if his claim was right and today we all just randomly drop it? Dess on the other hand claims to have been role blocked when investigating caff but this could be a cover for investigating Mad, who then probably protected himself (thus the lack of kills N1) and with a cop and the council claiming they figured the doc wouldn't be so selfish as to protect himself again; a decision which proved fatal.
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,630
Reaction score
3,023
So absolutely no followup about caff's death?

You seemed so eager to Lynch caff[who as innocent] without any good reasoning at all. The only reasoning I could possibly imagine you having for lynching caff was to prove or disprove Myusers cop claim. But you haven't said a word about it.

So to me it seems like you lynched caff for no reason at all, making us waste our lynch and gaining us absolutely nothing. While the Mafia just gained an advantage. Very, very anti-town like play. Or am I seeing things wrong here? If so please explain what you were thinking lynching caff.
caff was a blue in an inn with oak, an o5, which supports my hypothesis of inns containing at least one blue
myuser heavily questions his sanity, and got guilty on both you and caff
caff was confirmed to be innocent, unless we have a tailor role in play
for reference: https://epicmafia.com/role/182
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
I'm not sure what universe you are living in, but lynching a confirmed innocent is a terrible idea.

caff was a blue in an inn with oak, an o5, which supports my hypothesis of inns containing at least one blue
-Lynching confirmed innocent to support some crazy theory you pulled out of this air *terrible idea*
myuser heavily questions his sanity, and got guilty on both you and caff
-This investigation was today, not relevant to why you would possibly lynch caff yesterday.
caff was confirmed to be innocent, unless we have a tailor role in play
for reference: https://epicmafia.com/role/182
-Yes lets lynch the confirmed innocent how could this possibly result in the town losing one of their own and help the Mafia.

Just to express my annoyance by the terrible reasoning behind caff's lynch, I'll vote you again.
unvote
Vote hunter27a1
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,630
Reaction score
3,023
I'm not sure what universe you are living in, but lynching a confirmed innocent is a terrible idea.


-Lynching confirmed innocent to support some crazy theory you pulled out of this air *terrible idea*

-This investigation was today, not relevant to why you would possibly lynch caff yesterday.

-Yes lets lynch the confirmed innocent how could this possibly result in the town losing one of their own and help the Mafia.

Just to express my annoyance by the terrible reasoning behind caff's lynch, I'll vote you again.
unvote
Vote hunter27a1
...caff wasn't confirmed innocent until she was lynched, notty.
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
...caff wasn't confirmed innocent until she was lynched, notty.
Considering she knew that a vanilla towny was called an employee, which proved to be true when Ender died, it was pretty clear she was. While saying that might have been pm mechanics of some sorts, she was pretty much confirmed. I can't imagine a player like you missing this.

And still if your entire post was about after she died, then you still haven't provided any reasoning whatsovever to why you lynched caff. So explain?
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,630
Reaction score
3,023
notty, even if the blatant rulebreaking regarding caff's flavor name was applicable as eveidence, it still wouldn't have proved her claim

while i appreciate notty's enthusiastic tunnel vision in trying to lynch me, it seems as if this is retaliation for the post yesterday, quoted here:
this is a possible foreshadowing of endersteve's death
interestingly, it was notty who pointed out the 24 hour thing and accused raxo
noting this for potential discussion on day 2
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
First of all, I'm not ignoring other people, I still think Raxo is Mafia, but I'm going after you since you obviously were "tunneling" yesterday on Caff. I mean you can't even provide a reason for lynching her.

Second of all, it's not pushing, it's asking a simple question which you refuse to answer. And yes I am focussing on you being maf since all you are doing is scumtelling. You know this right=

Third of all:
Dodging questions: To not answer a question and avoid answering it by changing the subject or simply ignoring the person asking the question.
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
Yesterday people trusted Myusers investigation look how that turned out.

If there is one thing we know, it's that in this game investigations and more are not what they seem to be. With a paranoid cop, I find it highly likely the other cop is insane. In which case you are Mafia. Which is what I suspected all along since you lynched an innocent.
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,630
Reaction score
3,023
Lynching caffeina confirms or denies Myuser's cop claim. win-win situation but unfortunately requires caffeina's sacrifice.

Vote CaffeinatedKitty
caff was a mislynch, notty, even you should be able to understand that
others were pushing for the lynch, too
if there's some sort of plan you have, that's nice and all
notty, even if the blatant rulebreaking regarding caff's flavor name was applicable as eveidence, it still wouldn't have proved her claim
The road to ruin midnightgirl24 anything new with you two?
would like the thread to be more active than just me&notty

also, i neither confirm nor deny dessern's report
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top