SCP - Secure, Contain, Mafia [GAME OVER]

Status
Not open for further replies.
The Road to Ruin

The Road to Ruin

Member
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
148
Reaction score
263
10 5 10 2 1
I kinda want to vote for lee in a "If he's lying he's probably got something to hide" way. I don't know if fool is the best claim to get people to not lynch you since it seems like an obvious choice to not lynch. It's also making me suspicous when you have two completely separate win conditions one of which is really hard and the other which was only dashed by your role claim. What are you hiding damn you?!

That being said I've not been on the hottest of streaks and this reminds me too much of what went down with hunter. I wanted to wait and see if anyone else could present a better case, just in case I was missing something but it seems Jivvi has noticed something, just not anything that gets us anywhere. I don't think we should vote for him as of now but at the same time I'm absolutely clueless on where to go from here. I was really banking on hunter being scum, I was certain that was all that was needed to tug at the thread enough to unravel the mystery.

Looking back though it seems I voted on Erik to pressure a role reveal. My curiosity sated for now-

Unvote.
 
Jivvi

Jivvi

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
2,769
Reaction score
4,596
25 20 30 20 15 10 10 5 2 1
The road to ruin said:
I kinda want to vote for lee in a "If he's lying he's probably got something to hide" way. I don't know if fool is the best claim to get people to not lynch you since it seems like an obvious choice to not lynch. It's also making me suspicous when you have two completely separate win conditions one of which is really hard and the other which was only dashed by your role claim. What are you hiding damn you?!

That being said I've not been on the hottest of streaks and this reminds me too much of what went down with hunter. I wanted to wait and see if anyone else could present a better case, just in case I was missing something but it seems Jivvi has noticed something, just not anything that gets us anywhere. I don't think we should vote for him as of now but at the same time I'm absolutely clueless on where to go from here. I was really banking on hunter being scum, I was certain that was all that was needed to tug at the thread enough to unravel the mystery.

Looking back though it seems I voted on Erik to pressure a role reveal. My curiosity sated for now-

Unvote.
Click to expand...
except this did get us somewhere because we are now aware of the possibility of another third party victory slipping past us

thkuvymch
 
Samlen

Samlen

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Messages
187
Reaction score
353
20 15 10 5 10 1 2
Bugger it all, you guys can't get anywhere if you don't talk more. There are FIFTEEN of us here and this is about only the fifteenth post within the past 24 hours. Standing around like this will only create a deadline and panic, better to talk now than panic when the timer starts ticking. Part of this problem is that people seem insistent on focusing only on Lee/Erik, which they can't even decide on. There ARE other people with claims that are up for scrutinizing, and if I was actually part of the town, I'd probably find them and say what's wrong with them right now instead of later >,> Though I did do this with Lee's claim, which Jivvi did very nicely picking it apart even more, and I would greatly enjoy hearing from Lee_scar what his defense will be. Can't think of what else to say right now, so I'll post this for now and check up tomorrow.
 
GmK

GmK

International Man Of Cake
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
2,987
Reaction score
5,686
25 150 50 20 30 20 15 10 10 5 2 1
Sorry, still on holidays, so this will be quick&dirty:

I think that Lee's claim is utter bullcrap somehow. No fool like role would ever ever claim to be one, it just makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. It would only lead to a town being scared of trying to lynch/kill that role (something scum would love to have town think) but goes against any win conditions of such a role, so again: The claim makes no sense.

Combined with the fact of him not dying to the O5s makes me think there is way more in play here, maybe a bulletproof scumster (seeing how we also seem to have a town bulletproof) or a deflecting role. In any case, this is currently my only lead, so:

vote Lee_Scar
 
GmK

GmK

International Man Of Cake
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
2,987
Reaction score
5,686
25 150 50 20 30 20 15 10 10 5 2 1
Let me just add: If Lee was a fool like role, he should have simply not claimed since we were already so close to lynching him. This tight there makes the least sense: If the town is bent on lynching you due to not claiming, why claim the one thing that would actually benefit from the town lynching you!?

Like I said, it makes - in my mind - nooo sense.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top