TBD [Status: GAME OVER]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
judging by the claims so far this game is heavily night-action based.
i want to see what happens. regardless of our feelings, this is most likely going to be dragged out to the deadline.
and that will result in a no lynch.
may as well speed up the process and let these people use their actions (if they have any.)
unvote
vote no lynch
i want to see what happens. regardless of our feelings, this is most likely going to be dragged out to the deadline.
and that will result in a no lynch.
may as well speed up the process and let these people use their actions (if they have any.)
unvote
vote no lynch
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
And desert is ready, so I'll be eating cake for the next fifteen minutes or so.
But first let me say that voting No Lynch now is the stupidest decision, seriously. If you want a No Lynch, you can just wait until the deadline and have some discussion before that happens, doesn't matter if meaningless or not, every bit of discussion can be used in some way.
But first let me say that voting No Lynch now is the stupidest decision, seriously. If you want a No Lynch, you can just wait until the deadline and have some discussion before that happens, doesn't matter if meaningless or not, every bit of discussion can be used in some way.
yakuza converts a player to mafsided and results in the yakuza's death, unless it is saved by a doctor.
this brings up the possibility of a mason/cult game.
i do not wish to be part of a mason/cult group
this brings up the possibility of a mason/cult game.
i do not wish to be part of a mason/cult group
every bit of discussion is knowledge given to the mafia. this should not be hard to understand. it's basic game strategy: end a useless noninformational day as quickly as possible in order to minimize maf planning and give cops extra investigations.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Haven't any of you gotten a name with your role? Must be that only Mafia get names with their roles then igue- wait I mean what? Mafia? No I'm not Mafia I'm just a simple cop named Hercules that can investigate one person every night.
If you don't believe me wait till the Mafia kills me at night and you'll find out.
If you don't believe me wait till the Mafia kills me at night and you'll find out.
You gave it an hour.......
He isn't a hunter. HE IS A POACHER!
GmK isn't an idiot, but he could claim mafia.
And I was never in a team with caf or myuser, and you still proposed it.
If we're going to rush, let's atleast take the statistical chance of a lynch.
I don't like hunter. He is always to aggressive. And I think it was alpha that mentioned he had never actually been townsided in a forum game?
Anyway
vote hunter27a1
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Well it's not a game with Notty if I'm not on the brink of being lynched right? Although this game I'm more worried about Mafia wanting to kill me during the night. I did claim cop after all ^_^Damn, you're really pushing the limits on how much you can safely play this up.
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
Tim, I've been stating my opinions and actively opposing Hunter, so idk where you're getting the passive part from o-o
Notty: What?!
Ooookay, this is really getting messed up now o-o
Notty: What?!
Ooookay, this is really getting messed up now o-o
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
From the quotes you... well, quoted, I don't really see what you're trying to say.
From what I'm interpreting is that Caff disagree's with Defiant's opinion on "who is most likely Mafia" mold, and so disagrees with that and thinks that more risky players are more likely to be town, while more passive-players are more likely anti-town hiding in the shadows, and she's glad that (from what I'm reading) they are the opposite of Defiant's mold... so either a more talkative player (opinions wise), or likes her mold better than Defiants.
So frankly I'm not sure the problem, but then again, I'm still confused on what you wanted from this even with the added explanation in a later post. >.<
Did you even say that it was fake? I don't recall you even /really/ bringing it up as a joke/real until now. o .o
Anyways...
Don't know what to think of this really, frankly it seems rather weird.
And that name: Hercules. Are there hidden implications you aren't telling us? Are you possibly immune to death a night with your mythical strength? Do you have a special power outside of cop claims?
And then the name again. From the sign-up thread alone GmK said this wasn't necessarily a flavoured game, and thus there would be no need for a name like Hercules unless you came up with it yourself. But then again that's just an observation. (seeing as Alpha claimed Alien, a very generic name, which whether or not it was a false-claim or there is more to it, we don't know at this present moment)
And then the second part:
>Implying this game has watchers like previous games. A tad specific frankly.
It's all a bit... unbelievable. I'll slot this into position alongside my thoughts on Alpha's roleclaim and say that it's somewhat unbelievable and you are probably some other role.
Well frankly seeing as this is a Day start and we have literally straws to go on... keeping "possible third-parties" around (if they are even the role they claim they are) it really doesn't make a lot of sense to simply lop people off for claiming, especially when it'll be such a shot in the dark that the information we're basing it on cannot be supported, it seems like a better idea to let people slide for the first day (until the game really gets underway as it usually does during the first Night).
There are a lot of obvious cons, but that's mostly because you can't really "trust" anyone at this point in the game (unless you're on teams like Mafia or Assassins back in Masq or something). Obviously role claiming this early is rather dangerous, and thus it may lead to us wanting to lynch quickly out of fear of the future.
Of course, that hasn't come yet, so at the moment we can wait and see how things play out and decide with some good information on how to lynch this day.
Like I won't lynch Alpha off the basis of his "possible third-party affiliations," because I feel the claim is fake, and thus I feel we don't truly know his affiliations (like practically everyone here), so I wouldn't vote him until we had more information to go off of.
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
I this was said earlier as well?
More knowledge is information to all sides: Mafia, Town, and Third-party.
We can't escape that, and one of the main goals of town is to scum hunt, which time is needed for. Anything can be information, and if we push for it, we can get more.
We don't know if there are any cops in this (if you don't believe Notty, if you do then there is a cop so far).
We don't know if we have any other investigative roles.
We don't know a lot of things at this point in time.
Best to make the most of it until we have actual information to pull together and making reasonable decisions with.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
You never know with Notty, she can be sneaky is she likes. Mafia Season 5 comes to mind.Damn, you're really pushing the limits on how much you can safely play this up.
In any case, I don't know what to think of the Hercules thing. I can (with some doubt) say that I don't find it unusual that she has a flavour name, but the name itself is, of course, intriguing. Hercules was, as already pointed out, known mostly for his superhuman strength, so my guess is that if Notty's telling the truth, she's got some kind of a bulletproof (or otherwise regarding physical strength) modifier on her. Again, I'm not trusting anything she says at this point, but a theory is better when it's out there and up for discussion, so let's post it anyway.
As for all the proposals for a lynch or a no lynch: omfg is it really that hard to understand that more discussion is better? Yes, the mafia will get info, yes, the third parties will get info and we'll get all the same, so what's the deal? They're gonna move on us anyway, better make the most out of it while we can. I support a lynch, sure, and at this point maybe Hunter is indeed the best candidate, but we have people who haven't even been able to post anything meaningful at all, hell, some of them are still waking up from a Christmas coma, so why not delay the day's end as much as possible to get as much theories out there as possible and then ponder about them at night?
