TBD [Status: GAME OVER]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Your heart's telling you strange things. From all we've learned about her role, I'd say it's pretty damn safe to say she's not a Survivor, since it's either a) a role that wins by interacting with another role somehow, b) a unique role devised specifically for this game or c) both of those options.
Another thing caught my eye regarding Duffie, by the way.
You say there's no fun in hardclaiming a role right now. Is that really why you're not hardclaiming, or is there really some other reason? We already know with some certainty that you're a third-party with no direct harm intended towards town, so claiming your role now would not harm you... right?Honestly, Endersteve's on the right track. I mean no harm to anyone, and I'd tell you all my role... But, where's the fun in that?
My question to you is: do you lose when your win condition goes public?
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Been aching over this myself, but my conclusion is that she has some kind of a power or a certain thing she needs to do in order to win that doesn't influence the outcome of the game for other players.
Evidence will probably come in bursts
Constant fishing for info
Basically every quote I found in some way relevant
Constant fishing for info
Basically every quote I found in some way relevant
When in control you get info.
And you ask all these questions having said this? You encourage not taking and you ask
Not in a huge mafia mood right now, so this'll be short and sweet:
Keeping my vote. You say you can trust me at one point and appear to even believe my claim at times; for instance, telling me to probe myself or to use a probe on you.
Then you suddenly change your opinion to voting me multiple times, and it even surpasses what Ltin did in the early game with backtracking, which you did call Ltin out for. You give the reasoning as me being a third party therefore automatically being untrustworthy.
Just recently you seem to believe Duffie is third party and you give that a passing mention compared to me. Suddenly, another third party is okay to have around.
Keeping my vote. You say you can trust me at one point and appear to even believe my claim at times; for instance, telling me to probe myself or to use a probe on you.
Then you suddenly change your opinion to voting me multiple times, and it even surpasses what Ltin did in the early game with backtracking, which you did call Ltin out for. You give the reasoning as me being a third party therefore automatically being untrustworthy.
Just recently you seem to believe Duffie is third party and you give that a passing mention compared to me. Suddenly, another third party is okay to have around.
duffie's fun though, and I want her alive at least a few days. :c
i'm not exactly obligated to stick with whatever i'm voting. placing a vote isn't really dramatic or permanent.
not much else has come up, and you're the safest lynch so far. you have no useful powers. you cannot help the town with information gathering. you cannot kill people, and you cannot do anything useful for the town.
you can vote, though, and you can die. you are not even townsided winwise.
name one way your life helps anyone but yourself. lynching anyone else allows for the possibility of killing a town power role.
i'm not exactly obligated to stick with whatever i'm voting. placing a vote isn't really dramatic or permanent.
not much else has come up, and you're the safest lynch so far. you have no useful powers. you cannot help the town with information gathering. you cannot kill people, and you cannot do anything useful for the town.
you can vote, though, and you can die. you are not even townsided winwise.
name one way your life helps anyone but yourself. lynching anyone else allows for the possibility of killing a town power role.
this isn't a public speaking class.
other people have better roles and can provide useful information. like notty. even though i do not believe he is a cop, he has a chance of being town. however small that chance may be. there is no such chance for you.
you cannot investigate. you are worthless to the town.
other people have better roles and can provide useful information. like notty. even though i do not believe he is a cop, he has a chance of being town. however small that chance may be. there is no such chance for you.
you cannot investigate. you are worthless to the town.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
I'VE CAUGHT UP IT'S A MIRACLE
Am I still needed to answer the questions or have we moved on from that now?
Anywho I have a fos on hunter honestly. He seems far too jumpy with his votes, changing his vote what seems like at least once a page. His fishing for information and continuous leader approach is a danger to have - unless you are a 100% confirmed townie you shouldn't be trusted to take the lead.
Not lynch worthy in my eyes yet, though.
Alpha: I can see why people want to lynch him. His claim so early on, as an extremely experienced player is worrying and makes me believe that he isn't what he says he is and that he doesn't want to have people on his back. I'm not really fosing him yet however.
myuser: Those questions had bias in them yeah but it's nothing for people to flip about, imo. I believe that it's an easy mistake to make. When you first think of a question it generally has bias in it and that's simply what he did and didn't take time to look over it and think of a better version of said question.
Notty: I feel the claim is complete bullshit. That is all.
I think that's all for now. General thoughts on what pops to mind \o/ woooo
Am I still needed to answer the questions or have we moved on from that now?
Anywho I have a fos on hunter honestly. He seems far too jumpy with his votes, changing his vote what seems like at least once a page. His fishing for information and continuous leader approach is a danger to have - unless you are a 100% confirmed townie you shouldn't be trusted to take the lead.
Not lynch worthy in my eyes yet, though.
Alpha: I can see why people want to lynch him. His claim so early on, as an extremely experienced player is worrying and makes me believe that he isn't what he says he is and that he doesn't want to have people on his back. I'm not really fosing him yet however.
myuser: Those questions had bias in them yeah but it's nothing for people to flip about, imo. I believe that it's an easy mistake to make. When you first think of a question it generally has bias in it and that's simply what he did and didn't take time to look over it and think of a better version of said question.
Notty: I feel the claim is complete bullshit. That is all.
I think that's all for now. General thoughts on what pops to mind \o/ woooo
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
People that are good at explaining suspicions and such are quite useful, if they're townsided/choose to help the town. If they happen to call out the right person on a slip or something, they might actually end up killing off a mafia member without any special powers. And, like Alpha said, we don't even know what Duffie does--why are you automatically trusting him, as in, not bothering to push for details?
Really, public speaking is what you compare this to? Calling me worthless doesn't even encourage me to keep talking. You don't even want my help.
Which is strange, considering the town needs all the help it can get. Even if I turn mafia you can get help from me by looking at how people react to my posts. I don't appreciate being told to stop talking.
Which is strange, considering the town needs all the help it can get. Even if I turn mafia you can get help from me by looking at how people react to my posts. I don't appreciate being told to stop talking.