The Pearled Bridge - Game Complete!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
why would it prove him town/not be a waste? if anything I think him possibly being immune is a mark of scum considering we had aqua

aqua AND someone else with lucky just doesn't make any sense in my book

however neither did aqua and a jailer so I probably shouldn't be making decisions based on this
I mean I don't see Mafia being bulletproof but you know I am a prime/ignite vigilante so it's not like it's impossible but it's kinda crazy. Anyways would you switch to Pink?
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
I mean I don't see Mafia being bulletproof but you know I am a prime/ignite vigilante so it's not like it's impossible but it's kinda crazy. Anyways would you switch to Pink?
I'd only switch to pink if it saved my life, which I don't see it doing because there isn't enough suspicion on pink I don't think

omni however, basically everyone has agreed for him to die, although the original plan was for you to kill him, that can't happen anymore

if we lynch a mafia and then sort you out tomorrow, that's not a bad outcome in my eyes, and I don't think you igniting him would prove him town and I think it'd be much more of a waste for you to do that
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
this would be hilarious if the two people headbutting this whole time suddenly turned around on omni and was like 'yknow what sure'
Can't do that I'm less convinced he's scum now that he says he can't die by nightkills. It would be hilarious if we just went onto an inactive aswell though! Maybe Pink is your Mafia buddy and my speech compulsion theory day 0 was correct!!!

I mean you have not that much reason not to switch besides not wanting Pink lynched. Matty could after all attempt prove me tonight and if you take out of the equation that not lynching me = lynching you it may actually be an appealing deal for you to give me a chance to be proven, if you were actually town which I still doubt highly.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
Can't do that I'm less convinced he's scum now that he says he can't die by nightkills. It would be hilarious if we just went onto an inactive aswell though! Maybe Pink is your Mafia buddy and my speech compulsion theory day 0 was correct!!!

I mean you have not that much reason not to switch besides not wanting Pink lynched. Matty could after all attempt prove me tonight and if you take out of the equation that not lynching me = lynching you it may actually be an appealing deal for you to give me a chance to be proven, if you were actually town which I still doubt highly.
why are you less convinced he's scum because he has immunity? could easily be mafia with 1-shot immunity from third party killers, something I'm already convinced is in the game, that doesn't sound crazy to me at all

sounds a lot less crazy than a townie with immunity + another townie who can give people immunity and is immune himself (+ a jailer but you don't necessarily believe that)

like I said I think omni has a way better chance of 1) getting a mafia and 2) ensuring our survival

like you said, hiding behind his memes - aqua said the same thing in fact. just now I call him out for his random certainty and he goes back into meme-mode, so I think the whole meme thing may have been onto something this whole time, and I think he's mafia
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
why are you less convinced he's scum because he has immunity? could easily be mafia with 1-shot immunity from third party killers, something I'm already convinced is in the game, that doesn't sound crazy to me at all

sounds a lot less crazy than a townie with immunity + another townie who can give people immunity and is immune himself (+ a jailer but you don't necessarily believe that)

like I said I think omni has a way better chance of 1) getting a mafia and 2) ensuring our survival

like you said, hiding behind his memes - aqua said the same thing in fact. just now I call him out for his random certainty and he goes back into meme-mode, so I think the whole meme thing may have been onto something this whole time, and I think he's mafia
Thats how I read him, if his immunity is true then I just feel he's not Mafia. I find bulletproof Mafia a weird concept, it could fit Third Party but eh I'm not sure.

if he bluffed he'd be committing suicide, he was rooting for your survival just to ignite him to prove he can't survive it, it makes no sense to do that regardless of his role, bluffing gets him nothing
Could be that he was hoping I wouldn't waste my 1-shot on someone who couldn't die during the night.


In a controversial move that might be my death and will most likely be undone soonTM unless it gains traction I'll vote Pink because I do town-read Matty/Roob now and voting an inactive is a whole lot better than the town vigilante being lynched. Sure I'd love to lynch Inf but people seem hesistant and I'm scared people will lynch me instead of giving me a night to be proven by Matty simply because they'd have to lynch Inf otherwise and they seem to trust him. I'll take a Pink lynch over my lynch any day so I'll switch to that for now and if people would still rather lynch me than giving me a night to be proven by Matty then I'll switch back on the Inf train.

Unvote
Vote Pink
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
He claims to be bulletproof so that I will reconsider igniting him. Bluffing to make me think that igniting him will be a waste
he didn't even claim it until we pushed it out of him though, pretty sure he was fine going into the night without even saying it until I kept going on at him for not voting you, so I don't think he was bluffing

like I said, I don't think pink will get enough traction, sure she's fairly inactive but pretty sure most people voting you would prefer you vs pink today

but omni is someone literally everyone has been fine killing off now, there's a huge reason to think he can't be killed at night anymore, so everyone should be fine lynching him today - if you're looking to make a deal of switching lynches I'll switch to omni and encourage others to join it since I think he's mafia but only pink if it becomes a big wagon on its own
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
like I said, I don't think pink will get enough traction, sure she's fairly inactive but pretty sure most people voting you would prefer you vs pink today
Most people voting me are doing so because they town-read you and don't want to lynch you.

They may scum-read me but the reason they won't give me a night to be proven by Matty is because to do that you would be lynched instead and they don't want you lynched. Taking you out of the equation should convince any town to atleast give me a chance to be proven. Bonus points since you're alive to argue for my lynch tomorrow so it's not like 'Notty won't be lynched after today' is still an argument.

You said it won't get enough traction, but it can and this starts with you. Change your vote now and it can easely happen. I've already changed mine so it's not like the train against me loses something since the train against you already lost 1 vote.
 

Nottykitten

Nomnomnom kitteh!
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
2,041
Reaction score
5,970
why doesn't a 1-shot immune mafia make sense to you?
I find it unlikely. Even if it's true I genuinly see Omni bluffing this, the entire day to make me re-think actually igniting him with my 1x ignite.

but only pink if it becomes a big wagon on its own
Like I said, this starts with you. I'd rather go Pink during the day and ignite Omni during the night since I feel he's bluffing. I can't really kill pink during the night so lynching Pink seems more optimal from my point of view.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top