Post before I head off to sleep:
I'm still hoping fantome will actually give us a hardclaim moving forward. I'm starting to run out of patience at this point in time and I'm happy lynching Ernie given how suspicious his responses with him not getting killed are as Inffy pointed out.
The only redeeming point I really see for Ernie as of now is the initial post he made regarding Alisha, but him not cooperating with questions and what not even more gives me the vibe that he's really afraid of saying something and potentially slipping.
If Les doesn't hardclaim though I would still very much consider lynching him.
Anyway onto all my reads:
Positive
1. Fog - by far my strongest Town read. That post with the masons using what was later deemed as metagame tactics is something which I just don't see as being done by Mafia. Reasoning-wise he's completely logical and it runs through perfectly.
2. Infected_alien8 - he seems genuinely curious in what other people's opinions, asking questions and forming arguments with a strong flow to them. I would be very surprised if he wasn't Town.
3. Timdood3 - I have a slight Town read on Tim - though I initially suspected his scumhunting to be false due to excessive eagerness and my misinterpretation of his post being overly defensive. I think this is how he plays though.
Neutral positive
1. Okx - the way how he acted with his few posts and generally cracking a joke in one of them makes me want to trust him, but I have nothing concrete, so I'll leave the read here for now.
2. MoltenAshes (Wyatt) - mostly meta and references to previous games, I think he's pretty proactive and trying to scumhunt and help the Town, whilst being cooperative.
3. Shadow_Hunter3 - as Inffy pointed out I get the idea that he's the kind who'd try to follow and confront less.
Neutral
1. Alisha - flip-flop beep boop. What puzzled me this round regarding Alisha's behaviour was that she didn't jump on people immediately but seemed to wait a bit before pointing fingers. Again I would suppose this is how she plays so, I don't exactly have a remark on this.
2. TheWeakGuy48_ (Jobbiis) - I somehow want to trust him given his no-lynch reasoning was logically sound but besides that he really hasn't given much an opinion outside of Fantome and how no-lynching usually hurts the Town more statistically.
3. Unusual_dude - his long post from before didn't seem scummy and the silence that came after didn't sit exactly right with me but given he's suggested in making a long post later I'm inclined to give a neutral read.
4. catgirl12466 - hardly any read here - the first post she made seemed helpful to the Town but I don't really have anything concrete to trust or to suspect as of now.
Neutral negative
1. Fantome (Les) - him calling us "bloodthirsty" as I had pointed out before, his post regarding the SK... and I would say his almost 180 degree turn in scumhunting behaviour after I called out how uncharacteristically he was acting and a slight turn back again after Inffy started doubting his theory doesn't exactly sit right. Though to his merit I feel like he could just have been trying to make an effort to defend himself, and was actively involved in a scumhunt with Shadow_Hunter3, which seemed somewhat genuine.
Negative
1. Ernie138 - his initial post regarding Alisha actually made me not want to suspect him but the subsequent posts and him generally not being too cooperative is making me scumread him. Furthermore, he seemed to be more invested in actually surviving than helping the Town as Inffy had pointed out. That "yep" post and saying he was trying to observe us without elaborating much doesn't go well with me.
I'm still hoping fantome will actually give us a hardclaim moving forward. I'm starting to run out of patience at this point in time and I'm happy lynching Ernie given how suspicious his responses with him not getting killed are as Inffy pointed out.
The only redeeming point I really see for Ernie as of now is the initial post he made regarding Alisha, but him not cooperating with questions and what not even more gives me the vibe that he's really afraid of saying something and potentially slipping.
If Les doesn't hardclaim though I would still very much consider lynching him.
I agree with the reasoning here - I think this is how Shadow plays in general and I have a slight Townread on him but that's about it.
Thanks you're my role model uwu.
Anyway onto all my reads:
Positive
1. Fog - by far my strongest Town read. That post with the masons using what was later deemed as metagame tactics is something which I just don't see as being done by Mafia. Reasoning-wise he's completely logical and it runs through perfectly.
2. Infected_alien8 - he seems genuinely curious in what other people's opinions, asking questions and forming arguments with a strong flow to them. I would be very surprised if he wasn't Town.
3. Timdood3 - I have a slight Town read on Tim - though I initially suspected his scumhunting to be false due to excessive eagerness and my misinterpretation of his post being overly defensive. I think this is how he plays though.
Neutral positive
1. Okx - the way how he acted with his few posts and generally cracking a joke in one of them makes me want to trust him, but I have nothing concrete, so I'll leave the read here for now.
2. MoltenAshes (Wyatt) - mostly meta and references to previous games, I think he's pretty proactive and trying to scumhunt and help the Town, whilst being cooperative.
3. Shadow_Hunter3 - as Inffy pointed out I get the idea that he's the kind who'd try to follow and confront less.
Neutral
1. Alisha - flip-flop beep boop. What puzzled me this round regarding Alisha's behaviour was that she didn't jump on people immediately but seemed to wait a bit before pointing fingers. Again I would suppose this is how she plays so, I don't exactly have a remark on this.
2. TheWeakGuy48_ (Jobbiis) - I somehow want to trust him given his no-lynch reasoning was logically sound but besides that he really hasn't given much an opinion outside of Fantome and how no-lynching usually hurts the Town more statistically.
3. Unusual_dude - his long post from before didn't seem scummy and the silence that came after didn't sit exactly right with me but given he's suggested in making a long post later I'm inclined to give a neutral read.
4. catgirl12466 - hardly any read here - the first post she made seemed helpful to the Town but I don't really have anything concrete to trust or to suspect as of now.
Neutral negative
1. Fantome (Les) - him calling us "bloodthirsty" as I had pointed out before, his post regarding the SK... and I would say his almost 180 degree turn in scumhunting behaviour after I called out how uncharacteristically he was acting and a slight turn back again after Inffy started doubting his theory doesn't exactly sit right. Though to his merit I feel like he could just have been trying to make an effort to defend himself, and was actively involved in a scumhunt with Shadow_Hunter3, which seemed somewhat genuine.
Negative
1. Ernie138 - his initial post regarding Alisha actually made me not want to suspect him but the subsequent posts and him generally not being too cooperative is making me scumread him. Furthermore, he seemed to be more invested in actually surviving than helping the Town as Inffy had pointed out. That "yep" post and saying he was trying to observe us without elaborating much doesn't go well with me.
