[GAME OVER - TOWN WIN] The Comedy Club

[hipmeow]

How is your double loot ability useful then? Are you gonna build something? Perhaps give your items away? So far there have been 0 claims about people being able to do anything with these items and nothing about being able to give them away/others in a room being able to use your items. I'm sure there is probably one or more roles like that not just for town but also for Mafia.

this looks like alot of dodging, and who knows maybe my ability is useless, atleast its not actively detrimental for town

 

[Alisha]

If the servants 'channel' the kill or direct the darkness to do the kill then why would there be flavour text saying that the servants can survive kills by the darkness? It makes no real sense unless either the servants don't know who other servants are or the darkness is a seperate entity.

Could be a third party that can survive an attack by the darkness I guess, but I see what you mean and I'm a bit unsure what that text is referring to as well.

 

[Alisha]

How is your double loot ability useful then? Are you gonna build something? Perhaps give your items away? So far there have been 0 claims about people being able to do anything with these items and nothing about being able to give them away/others in a room being able to use your items. I'm sure there is probably one or more roles like that not just for town but also for Mafia.

If you would have targeted Omni with your ability that would have harmed him, so your ability does have the potential to harm town

 

[sessybessy]

SessybessyUnknown??????

Btw my item is a cog

 

[Mooglie]

this looks like alot of dodging, and who knows maybe my ability is useless, atleast its not actively detrimental for town

i mean if mafia have a use for an item as well and you give it to them thinking theyre innocent then thats detrimental!

i get what notty is saying but if they are town then they cant like deny the fact that their role can be both good and bad its sort of a hard argument to counter!

 

[Mooglie]

why am i defending notty when i think theyre not town
idk its like my HEART tells me to defend them but my BRAIN tells me to not yknow

 

[Nottykitten]

If you would have targeted Omni with your ability that would have harmed him, so your ability does have the potential to harm town

Yes and a roleblocker 'harms' town people too.

i get what notty is saying but if they are town then they cant like deny the fact that their role can be both good and bad its sort of a hard argument to counter!

I'm not denying it but people are focussing on 'wow you can take towns items away' and ignore the fact I can do the same against the Mafia. It's like throwing suspicion on a vigilante because they can murder a town.

 

[Alisha]

i mean if mafia have a use for an item as well and you give it to them thinking theyre innocent then thats detrimental!

i get what notty is saying but if they are town then they cant like deny the fact that their role can be both good and bad its sort of a hard argument to counter!

Can you give people items?

On a semi related note
What happens to items someone is carrying when they die?

 

[Mooglie]

Can you give people items?

On a semi related note
What happens to items someone is carrying when they die?

i assume you can give items since otherwise what is the point of comedians having an ability if they cant do anything with it

 

[Alisha]

Yes and a roleblocker 'harms' town people too.

I know, but that was in response to the claim that your ability doesn't harm town where it does have the potential to do so.

 

[hipmeow]

I'm not denying it but people are focussing on 'wow you can take towns items away' and ignore the fact I can do the same against the Mafia.

we dont know if mafia need items or can use them
if you can take away items from a known mafia why dont we just lynch them instead

 

[Alisha]

i assume you can give items since otherwise what is the point of comedians having an ability if they cant do anything with it

I think we need someone that is carrying an item to clear this up for us

 

[Alisha]

we dont know if mafia need items or can use them
if you can take away items from a known mafia why dont we just lynch them instead

Maybe when you die, people can take whatever items you were carrying?

 

[Mooglie]

we dont know if mafia need items or can use them

i mean lets be real they 100% are gonna have a use for items
+ like i said the key & the library paper

 

[Alisha]

I think it's realistic for mafia to be able to use items for bad things

 

[hipmeow]

I think it's realistic for mafia to be able to use items for bad things

still if we know someone is mafia why dont we lynch them rather than get notty to take their stuff away

 

[Mooglie]

if you can take away items from a known mafia why dont we just lynch them instead

also 'if you can just block a known mafia why dont we just lynch them instead'
its assuming that we know someone is 100% mafia which is unlikely since yes we will just lynch them (noone call me out using 'we' a lot i see it too and its unintentional!)
blockers can block people that arent 100% confirmed mafia as a precaution, and (assuming nottys true) notty can take away items from people that arent 100% confirmed mafia as a precaution

 

[Nottykitten]

Can you give people items?

On a semi related note
What happens to items someone is carrying when they die?

I can't give items as far as I know and my ability does not steal the items. And uhm maybe they get dropped in a room if they die at night?

we dont know if mafia need items or can use them
if you can take away items from a known mafia why dont we just lynch them instead

Apply this question to a vigilante/roleblocker. Ofcourse lynching them is better but there are plenty situations where you want to use your action on a suspected person.

Hip could you paraphrase the text for when you found wire in your room?

 

[Mooglie]

why am i doing this ive literally said in previous mafia games that i think that arguing on behalf of someone else is bad
make me stop!

 

[Nottykitten]

Maybe when you die, people can take whatever items you were carrying?

Dibs on Oog's shoes when he dies

 

[Mooglie]

Dibs on Oog's shoes when he dies

but theyre a size 20
they fit me because im a clown

 

[Alisha]

still if we know someone is mafia why dont we lynch them rather than get notty to take their stuff away

I would prefer lynching before simply relying on Notty, but if scum take items when they kill someone then there is a valid point that Notty's ability is able to be useful.

 

[Mooglie]

maybe you can only give someone items if theyre in the same room as you, and so the possibility to do so wont present itself until tonight (as im writing this it sounds stupid since obviously you can only give someone items if theyre in the same room)

i mean i guess we could just ask inf but i assume he wont answer since it would have been made obvious instantly if you could give them away

 

[hipmeow]

Hip could you paraphrase the text for when you found wire in your room?

i was using my flashlight around the room and i spot some wire on top of
a bar which held cooking utensils

while perhaps my argument about nottys role is a bit flimsy i still think they are top susp so im keeping my vote

 

[Nottykitten]

I just want to point out how it is extremely weird that Oog is the only one that gained 0 items last night (excluding Alisha because of me).