i really dont see how this small bit of information about our vices is going to harm town. if theres VID killer or whatever they still wont know our vice, plus mafia already get extra info if im remembering correctly so i wouldnt be suprised if they know some things about our vices in the first place
The Happy Vice Institute - Game Complete!
- Thread starter Alisha
- Start date
- Status
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
This is an assumption you're making based on how useful you think it would be to share your vice but you can't reasonably assume that all other people have vices that aren't worth talking about either.
Those only exist in fairytales
that's a fair point but i could see it being the opposite too, this isn't really enough to rule out anything yet
awww come back, i was joking
I don't see how it would help
Explain how sharing info about my vice would be beneficial then, since the only thing you've offered is the 'whats the harm' argument over and over.
I'm uneasy about sharing information about my vice or others sharing because I'm unsure of the information mafia could gain from that and the way you guys are asking isn't encouraging me. I wouldn't mind sharing information if i knew it would be beneficial to town but other than that I'm not interested
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
wow rude
no but seriously though, unless tim is literally doc or something, i don't think any benefits the town might potentially get from keeping his role a secret at this point outweigh the benefit of having clarity over this fairly controversial topic because right now tim's entire claim is a mess, he gives just enough info to intrigue us and then keeps everything deliberately vague so that we can't actually do anything with the info he has given
if he's town, that's a bad move imo, since it
a) gives the maf, who already have an information advantage over the town, possibly enough that they would be able to at least make somewhat accurate guesses as to how his role or vice works, and thus gives them an even further information advantage, or failing that, makes himself at least somewhat of a target
b) keeps precisely enough info from the town to prevent any of what he has already disclosed being actually useful to us
i'm not gonna push for him to claim any more, because he's obviously not gonna do it and i think that discussing it further leads nowhere right now, but i still don't understand why he would even divulge the information he did without being prompted, if he was town
nobody should answer those questions for you because if they did, we'd have no info regarding how you feel about the current state of affairs
What makes you say that?
It be like that sometime.
I disagree with this. I don't see how his claiming would give us any actual information other than helping mafia, not to mention that tim's role could be a PR role.
him being vague gives maf less information than him actually claiming
i don't think his claim would give us any information tbh.
i don't think pushing is a good idea anyway so do you boo
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Information is the key to winning Mafia games. You never know what potential benefits it has in a closed setup you need to take a leap of faith. And your reason not to talk about it is mostly being scared that non-town are going to do ???? with that information
Have you ever seen one with your own eyes? They're not real
I'm not sharing my vice just for the hell of it when i might come back to bite town in the ass later. you've made no argument as to why i actually should, just said 'theres no harm' which i already told you i disagreed with. and now youre throwing shade just because i don't think its a good idea??
No Execution - 4 (Mooglie, hipmeow, Comp, Nottykitten) [E-6]
Stranger from Planet 9 - 3 (PokeSvorlds, enderfive, TheWeakGuy48) [E-7]
Ltin - 1 (Stranger from Planet 9) [E-9]
Mooglie - 1 (JurgenVW) [E-9]
(from the signup thread)
This says that every player has a vice, and it's either bad, good or somewhere in between. I thought about it, and I think a vice-massclaim would be bad, because it would reveal the roles with negative vices (and their vices too specifically). Maybe something in between where those with positive vices would claim but not those with bad ones?
It's hard to know what roles Alisha might've put in the game, anything from a VID-killer to some crazy mafia faction roles. Alisha has a vivid imagination - I think it's a bad idea to be so naive/in denial of there being a role which could deal a great deal of damage knowing our vices.
PokeSvorlds
Member
yeah inffy you can't expect people to read your messages
that said i completely stumbled across it so here
that said i completely stumbled across it so here
why is everyone thinking i want to know what ur vice is, i just want to know if it benefits you positively or negatively.
im pretty sure it doesnt say that a vice can be good, rather it is either negative or just inconsequential.
I know you are always a big advocate for claiming/massclaiming early, but you shouldn't deny that the mafia also gains valuable information about who to target (ie who has what vice, maybe they can counter some of the vices?).
fair enough (was mostly a reply towards notty)
Yes, upon re-reading I agree with you.
yes i do mind so I'm not gonna share it
- Status