[GAME OVER] Formula Mafia

[HKCaper]

i know hk lurks sometimes but it feels he's trying to stay off the radar for now

sometimes is an understatment. alisha you say this every game, think of a new line! i know i lurk, i know its not a good look, but i aint changing.

 

[HKCaper]

I'm trying to get a read on people, but with zero history on everyone, and everyone referencing previous games, it's a little difficult.

day 0 is hard if all you've got to go off is the current game. i think the referencing to previous games was mostly nostalgic though.

 

[Mooglie]

yes you said you were watching the show crazy ex girlfriend and after you stopped watching the next day you realized the direction i was coming from

i wouldnt call that being wrong!
just both of us were right!

 

[Duffie]

At least Stranger, Notty, Duffie. HK implied I was panicking. Looked like a rapid consensus FMPOV, including your demeanor towards me at the time.

I have only ever voted for myself and No Lynch, and I only wanted to intervene about a few of your posts. :<

 

[Mooglie]

but if most people voted you, oog wouldnt have to be anywhere near you anymore, since for example the votecount might be mars - 6, oog - 3, so why do you think theyd remain closer, who do you think would vote oog with you?

bold of you to assume id have 3 votes rather than 0 since im the perfect picture of innocence

 

[Duffie]

Skel's posting pinged me the most b/c of how it came off as fencesitting/just observing. Same route took me towards HK and Duff.

What do I have in common with Skel and HK??? o 3o

 

[Alisha]

sometimes is an understatment. alisha you say this every game, think of a new line! i know i lurk, i know its not a good look, but i aint changing.

the first part was different!

 

[HKCaper]

the first part was different!

i guess you added the opportunistic part

 

[hipmeow]

perfect picture of innocence

one rank lower than being a shining beacon of innocence if you ask me

 

[Duffie]

Re: earlier posting about being emotional, I really don't know where the panic read comes from. I was frustrated, and I don't understand why that's unrealistic in the context of the wagon at the time. If I was taking these personally it'd be an AtE showcase up in here.

I got Boo to make a heel turn, Duff runs up for defense, Skel and HK only respond when voted = they've been observing but have decided not to participate. All pinged anti-town for me all at that time so I half-jokingly said things were wrapped.

I think you're not quite understanding the difference between your posts now, and your posts then-- You are definitely much less panicky than before.

Also, when did I get defensive? xD

 

[Infected_alien8_]

MOO - town - actually admitted to being wrong about the vibes thing long after the argument, at worst got sarcastic about it but has been a consistent voice of reason

dont underestimate oogs maf game, this shouldnt deserve a townread on him tbh!!

STR - town - voice of reason for
INF - neutral - seems to be tunneling a lot but trying to back off of mars, feels genuine but at the moment im holding out for

did these get cut

SKO - town - feels like a new person trying to fit in but not knowing how

why does that make you think hes town (assuming thats the reason)

bold of you to assume id have 3 votes rather than 0 since im the perfect picture of innocence

you had 2 at the time iirc and mars said hed have voted you to self prez!

 

[Mooglie]

dont underestimate oogs maf game, this shouldnt deserve a townread on him tbh!!

o3o what do you mean
but ya im a great mafia thats pretty easy to fake i guess
but im not mafia you gotta believe me!!

 

[MarsKid]

are you trying to get in a fight with every single person in the game

You're going to have to pull up where I've been fighting anyone. I've only been arguing to stop a misguided tunnel, not trying to be hostile at all. Your post implied I had bad intentions/behavior so I pointed it out.

My responses are branded as emotional, but this snippet here is just as much imo.

 

[Alisha]

did these get cut

shit ok i saved the rest for the sequel

STR - voice of reason for a lot of stuff, im finding myself agreeing with everything she says, and nothing she's said has felt awkward/out of place (town)
INF - at the moment im holding out for a flip on someone related to the scenario

 

[Alisha]

the scenario is the game and anyone related to the mars tunnel

 

[Infected_alien8_]

thanks for the reads list btw

i was gonna rate your post thank you but the use of the three letter names made me rate it funny instead

 

[Alisha]

thanks for the reads list btw

i was gonna rate your post thank you but the use of the three letter names made me rate it funny instead

aw that was nice of you

 

[HKCaper]

cute interaction

 

[Mooglie]

aw that was nice of you

hes sucking up to you since hes scum and wants town-friends!!!!

 

[Infected_alien8_]

aw that was nice of you

yeah so can you townread me now

 

[Alisha]

am i being unfair to mars

 

[hipmeow]

excuse me i dont come to mafia for positivity, i come to mafia for brutal murderings

 

[HKCaper]

am i being unfair to mars

depends

did you mean that thing about 'mars wanting to start a fight with everyone' or was that a joke?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

excuse me i dont come to mafia for positivity, i come to mafia for brutal murderings

why dont you volunteer as tribute then

 

[MarsKid]

what do you mean by lock-in lynch then? since duffie was never advocating for your lynch, or any lynch, you wanted a NL. notty voted you without a reason, presumably a reaction test if shes town, but gave no indication she was locked in on lynching only you. stranger i dont remember. hk implying youre panicking doesnt mean they want to lynch you though? i can understand my demeanor seeming like i wanted you dead and had made up my mind though

Lock-in as in my lynch was certain, if not today then later. That is the demeanor I interpreted. HK and Duff both made posts that acted as a soft-prep for a push, esp. the weakest link comment.

but why do you lean towards me purposefully misrepresenting it instead of genuinely misremembering?

Because it slices both ways tbh. As scum, you took a narrow window to bring a push on me and were able to gain traction on it based upon misinterpretation. As town, you saw a pattern and confirmation-biased your way through it. I don't think someone of your experience and demonstrated memory loses track of past games but I concede it's possible.

but if most people voted you, oog wouldnt have to be anywhere near you anymore, since for example the votecount might be mars - 6, oog - 3, so why do you think theyd remain closer, who do you think would vote oog with you?

Implies I wanted to self-prez on Oog, which I never said I'd commit to; I mentioned it as my only option in this case, and all it leads to there is knowingly putting myself to what I think is another mislynch. Having two or more wagons allows scum to stay spread in voting rather than consolidating, which protects members from bad flips. Ideally scum want multiple wagon options or very spread out voting with a small wagon.

how though

Indicate potential power roles, show what happens during the night, NK option highlights the demeanor/goals of the scumteam, makes previous-day votes/pushes appear in a different context.

im still confused - you said that she contradicted herself since she sussed hip on vibes but took issue with hip calling her scum because she vibed him as scum, why was that, and what does that have to do with her opinion on alisha or anything (tbh you dont need to answer this since i dont think it will be relevant to your alignment i was just confused what you were saying)

It read to me that Boo didn't think vibes were enough for a scumread, when they themselves had called scumreads based on vibes. That includes the Alisha push, which came from a vibe off the reaction test.

Basically the contradiction comes from saying vibe scrum reads are poor, but they simultaneously commit to vibes for their own reads to scumhunt.