Mafia: Saints & Sinners - GAME OVER MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter Stranger from Myst Island
- Start date
- Status
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
like i said earlier, either a) devil is 3p, or b) there are negative consequences for maf deals too and its only beneficial under certain circumstances, giving them motive for not always trying to make deals
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
Ok that was just me mindlessly following the formula my bad
if you read my actual text I don't say that I say I pick someone at day and bless them. In reality I pick someone atday then at the beginning of night I bless them.
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
I ASSUME since I can't quite remember as I am (wait for the best excuse ever) quite tired, I misread and thought you said day. As I truly don't really understand why I have to visit at day as I could just pick someone at night and it still work, but that's on stranger idk
if there are 2 'potential' town roles that cancel DWTD's, it just doesnt make sense for there to only be town sinners (unless stranger is memeing us all). i just cant wrap my head around the mechanic of this game yet, and most of it has to do with fog's deal being declined.
inf, does your role mention 'poor sinners' or simply DWTD's?
(on a side note, im starting to worry that if some of you 3 dont die soon this game is going to be impossible to follow for the more inactive among us.)
inf, does your role mention 'poor sinners' or simply DWTD's?
(on a side note, im starting to worry that if some of you 3 dont die soon this game is going to be impossible to follow for the more inactive among us.)
i think i already pinged twg earlier but ima throw him in the mix again
TheWeakGuy48_ Good Skele please claim, luv u
what could be the point of unu's role in this setup. dont rlly see a reason for the chat role to be scum, but it would be nice to get a name claim (afaik hasnt happend from him yet) Unusual_Dood (whenever you got time).
TheWeakGuy48_ Good Skele please claim, luv u
what could be the point of unu's role in this setup. dont rlly see a reason for the chat role to be scum, but it would be nice to get a name claim (afaik hasnt happend from him yet) Unusual_Dood (whenever you got time).
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
the only way aqua's role makes sense is to protect town from dealing but not scum actually
if maf have "Poor Sinner" roles too, and thus aqua can stop deals for both town and scum, then what would be the point of his ability to see whether someone is a sinner or not? maf arent gonna claim anything except sinner if theyre truly a sinner surely since that'd be stupid, so aqua's never realistically gonna be able to catch any scum through that ability. it only makes sense if only town are Poor Sinners, in which case, his ability only prevents town from making deals, not scum
but why would town have a role where they only prevent town from making deals, unless deals with the devil can be forced and he's the counter to it, but like he rightfully pointed out, it's likely we'd have seen that if it was the case (though, as i pointed out, not impossible)
my role makes sense regardless assuming maf can make deals since then i can try to stop them from doing that but aqua's i'm struggling to find a way to fit in the setup
but at the same time, how else do we explain the lack of nk n1, unless we assume maf hit devil or something like that, and we also have no reason to believe thats the case
but maybe that is what happened and aqua is just scum
im confused
if maf have "Poor Sinner" roles too, and thus aqua can stop deals for both town and scum, then what would be the point of his ability to see whether someone is a sinner or not? maf arent gonna claim anything except sinner if theyre truly a sinner surely since that'd be stupid, so aqua's never realistically gonna be able to catch any scum through that ability. it only makes sense if only town are Poor Sinners, in which case, his ability only prevents town from making deals, not scum
but why would town have a role where they only prevent town from making deals, unless deals with the devil can be forced and he's the counter to it, but like he rightfully pointed out, it's likely we'd have seen that if it was the case (though, as i pointed out, not impossible)
my role makes sense regardless assuming maf can make deals since then i can try to stop them from doing that but aqua's i'm struggling to find a way to fit in the setup
but at the same time, how else do we explain the lack of nk n1, unless we assume maf hit devil or something like that, and we also have no reason to believe thats the case
but maybe that is what happened and aqua is just scum
im confused
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
Saints or the Devil
I could support someones saint claim assuming no sinners had claimed and I was just choosing people at random.
Or if the devil claimed sinner I could have outed them.
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
I still don't understand your reasoning for suspecting I'm scum, is it because I select players during the day or is it because I messed up and misquoted my role and misread what you said?
I can understand the latter could be a slip but it seems fairly ambiguous and could easily be explained by what did happen - I misread.
What is youropinion on my your name isn't thatof a real saint, whereas mine and Hk's are?
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
you'd only be able to support a saint claim as being a saint if the devil was already dead though, otherwise anyone you know isnt a poor sinner could also be devil
but yeah you could out the devil through it i guess
it was originally for both those reasons, but i can believe you just misread stuff so i dropped that. now im just struggling to make sense of the point of your role
my opinion is that stranger probably chose random names just like she did with sinners, and yours and hks just so happen to be saint names, because there are over 10k saints in the bible according to my google search
- Status