Mafia Talk
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
- Status
GmK
International Man Of Cake
Night 1 Mafia Talk is no open.
- Please make sure that you as a group have one person at the end that you want killed. State it in bold.
- If you are a Mafia powerrole, I still need you to submit your action to me via PM
- You may talk about what powerroles and features each of you have, but never copy straight from your role PM
- If there is an uncertainty of whom to kill, the Godfather has the final word (until and if lynched)
I am the Mafia roleblocker. Simply speaking, I block night actions.
Well for the game so far, these are my suspicions:
1. grimmjowforever - Mafia Role Blocker
2. Alpha102 - Mafia
3. shinyshark - Possible Civilian
4. ansoro2112
5. Ooglie101
6. nottykitten - Possible non-lucky civ
7. Jivvi - Possible SK/Vig
8. Vatumok
9. Prizyms - Mafia
10. endersteve5 - Mafia
11. Dessern5
12. infernofox - Possible vig/cop
13.Sploorky
14. MarsKid
15.digitalmez
16. 77_is_the_best - Mafia
17. HypeBurst
18. balloon98
19. storm886
20. kraby1
21. nitasu987
22. mariosatr
23. One One Two - Mafia
24. Defiant_Blob - Possible vig/power role/lucky civ
25. Old_Man_Oak_63 - Possible Power Role
26. myusername22 - potential civ
27. K1ngHoward
28. hihihilolHI
29. Omar_Sales
30. cooliorules - Possible Cop/Vig/SK
Why I guess so:
Jivvi - "Kilarl Tepas Enjur" --> Kill all the passengers.
Shinyshark - The way he talks, you can tell he is ordinary. Nothing to hide, just a plain old civilian.
Notty - Afraid of dying. Definitely not a lucky civ here.
Oak - Not sure how to explain, but his posting style/vibe was definitely different from last season. I suspect he might be a power role, but just a hunch.
Inferno - "I am Ladd Russo and i will protect them..." Either a cop or a vig.
Defiant - "Would you believe me if I'm very lucky?" Could be pretending to be a lucky civ to prevent people from aiming at him. I say a potentially dangerous power role. Or just a normal civ.
Coolio - Dramatic, crafty a little. I say a possible SK.
Myusername - I say he just falls under the overly-suspicious civilian category. Like those who are aggressive and jump on every potentially-suspicious word you say and assume you are anti-town.
From what I have noticed, what a person posts can have some slip-offs or some trails leading to their role. In last season where The Road to Ruin died (as a Godfather), he posted, "Good luck my fellow mafia!" Jivvi indirectly replied, "Gee, thanks, that's awfully nice of you!" Jivvi came out as Mafia.
Some things I tips I thought of:
>Refrain from having internal jokes with one another.
>Refrain from aggressiveness, Hype was unusually aggressive last season, calling the SK "evil". It backfired on him and he was found out to be SK. (What I'm saying is that Ender your usage of "mafia scum" is a little...aggressive.)
>If anyone accuses you to be Mafia, avoid telling them your role. This would be dangerous if you were investigated and found out to be lying. Just beat around the bush, but not too obvious. Put your emotions on your sleeves, but not too exaggerated. Try to put yourself into the shoes of a townie.
>When talking about townies, avoid "them". Use "us" instead.
>Don't use the "jumping of bandwagon" excuse to vote to lynch someone. It raises a few eyebrows. Unless youhave a plan.
>Don't necessarily follow what your fellow Mafia members are doing. Be different. This reduces the chances of people thinking you are teaming up with them.
>A nice coverup. If majority votes for one of us, and it seems very very very definite that the person will be lynched, vote for that Mafia member about to be lynched as well. Not necessarily all the time, but do that sometimes.
I think it would be our highest priority right now to aim for the cop. While a vig can kill us, the chances of the vig hitting us is around 1/5. 20%. Not to mention the factor is highly dependent on how the vig suspicious views us as. However, if the cop survives, it would be very dangerous in the last stage since he/she can reveal our roles freely. If the cop is sharp enough, he/she might even find out the remaining Mafia members.
Oh yeah, I think it would be best to leave Defiant for the night. The doctor could be protecting him/Vig/SK aiming for him.
Lastly, 77. Your post about "Remember: Mafia can only talk during the night and since there hasn't been a night stage, the mafia have had no way of strategizing. They may not even know who the other mafia are!" is very very revealing. I checked, there are no posts by GmK that reveal such a thing. In the worst case scenario, act surprised that no one knows and pretend that you pmed GmK. People might ask you why you pmed GmK about it in the possible future, make up a convincing excuse.
That's all for Day 0. I'm sorry if I sounded a little commanding or something
Well for the game so far, these are my suspicions:
1. grimmjowforever - Mafia Role Blocker
2. Alpha102 - Mafia
3. shinyshark - Possible Civilian
4. ansoro2112
5. Ooglie101
6. nottykitten - Possible non-lucky civ
7. Jivvi - Possible SK/Vig
8. Vatumok
9. Prizyms - Mafia
10. endersteve5 - Mafia
11. Dessern5
12. infernofox - Possible vig/cop
13.Sploorky
14. MarsKid
15.digitalmez
16. 77_is_the_best - Mafia
17. HypeBurst
18. balloon98
19. storm886
20. kraby1
21. nitasu987
22. mariosatr
23. One One Two - Mafia
24. Defiant_Blob - Possible vig/power role/lucky civ
25. Old_Man_Oak_63 - Possible Power Role
26. myusername22 - potential civ
27. K1ngHoward
28. hihihilolHI
29. Omar_Sales
30. cooliorules - Possible Cop/Vig/SK
Why I guess so:
Jivvi - "Kilarl Tepas Enjur" --> Kill all the passengers.
Shinyshark - The way he talks, you can tell he is ordinary. Nothing to hide, just a plain old civilian.
Notty - Afraid of dying. Definitely not a lucky civ here.
Oak - Not sure how to explain, but his posting style/vibe was definitely different from last season. I suspect he might be a power role, but just a hunch.
Inferno - "I am Ladd Russo and i will protect them..." Either a cop or a vig.
Defiant - "Would you believe me if I'm very lucky?" Could be pretending to be a lucky civ to prevent people from aiming at him. I say a potentially dangerous power role. Or just a normal civ.
Coolio - Dramatic, crafty a little. I say a possible SK.
Myusername - I say he just falls under the overly-suspicious civilian category. Like those who are aggressive and jump on every potentially-suspicious word you say and assume you are anti-town.
From what I have noticed, what a person posts can have some slip-offs or some trails leading to their role. In last season where The Road to Ruin died (as a Godfather), he posted, "Good luck my fellow mafia!" Jivvi indirectly replied, "Gee, thanks, that's awfully nice of you!" Jivvi came out as Mafia.
Some things I tips I thought of:
>Refrain from having internal jokes with one another.
>Refrain from aggressiveness, Hype was unusually aggressive last season, calling the SK "evil". It backfired on him and he was found out to be SK. (What I'm saying is that Ender your usage of "mafia scum" is a little...aggressive.)
>If anyone accuses you to be Mafia, avoid telling them your role. This would be dangerous if you were investigated and found out to be lying. Just beat around the bush, but not too obvious. Put your emotions on your sleeves, but not too exaggerated. Try to put yourself into the shoes of a townie.
>When talking about townies, avoid "them". Use "us" instead.
>Don't use the "jumping of bandwagon" excuse to vote to lynch someone. It raises a few eyebrows. Unless youhave a plan.
>Don't necessarily follow what your fellow Mafia members are doing. Be different. This reduces the chances of people thinking you are teaming up with them.
>A nice coverup. If majority votes for one of us, and it seems very very very definite that the person will be lynched, vote for that Mafia member about to be lynched as well. Not necessarily all the time, but do that sometimes.
I think it would be our highest priority right now to aim for the cop. While a vig can kill us, the chances of the vig hitting us is around 1/5. 20%. Not to mention the factor is highly dependent on how the vig suspicious views us as. However, if the cop survives, it would be very dangerous in the last stage since he/she can reveal our roles freely. If the cop is sharp enough, he/she might even find out the remaining Mafia members.
Oh yeah, I think it would be best to leave Defiant for the night. The doctor could be protecting him/Vig/SK aiming for him.
Lastly, 77. Your post about "Remember: Mafia can only talk during the night and since there hasn't been a night stage, the mafia have had no way of strategizing. They may not even know who the other mafia are!" is very very revealing. I checked, there are no posts by GmK that reveal such a thing. In the worst case scenario, act surprised that no one knows and pretend that you pmed GmK. People might ask you why you pmed GmK about it in the possible future, make up a convincing excuse.
That's all for Day 0. I'm sorry if I sounded a little commanding or something
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Alrighty then. Hai fellow mafia c:
I guess it would be useful for you guys to know my role, I'm a two-shot Janitor, meaning that twice per whole game I can make it so whoever we kill, only their name will be mentioned in the main thread, so they (and possibly we) don't know their role or anything besides their name.
I think that we would be better off killing off someone more experienced, like Sploorky or notty or defiant. I'd choose Sploorky from that list, because defiant is acting suspicious already to some and has a chance of getting lynched anyway, and notty can add reliability to me if he dies and turns out to be a townie (which I think he may just be), or vice versa, I can add suspicion to him if I die.
I guess it would be useful for you guys to know my role, I'm a two-shot Janitor, meaning that twice per whole game I can make it so whoever we kill, only their name will be mentioned in the main thread, so they (and possibly we) don't know their role or anything besides their name.
I think that we would be better off killing off someone more experienced, like Sploorky or notty or defiant. I'd choose Sploorky from that list, because defiant is acting suspicious already to some and has a chance of getting lynched anyway, and notty can add reliability to me if he dies and turns out to be a townie (which I think he may just be), or vice versa, I can add suspicion to him if I die.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Oh wow, that thing you found about Jivvi was nice. Anyway, I'm not gonna change my game plan anymore, because it would probably look a bit suspicious (behaviour changed overnight) and also, this is me playing just like I was a townie, only avoiding pointing fingers at you guys unless absolutely necessary, so while it may rise a few eyebrows as to why I'm so aggressive, then that's just my style. Also, many of the active players have said that they think I'm a townie role, so I'm just gonna keep going.
But this is my first game playing as mafia, so I may get lynched at some point.
Also, agree about what you said about that we should all play differently.
But this is my first game playing as mafia, so I may get lynched at some point.
Also, agree about what you said about that we should all play differently.
So basically you can hide the identity of the person killed? That great :D
Though I must say, Defiant is the top priority of the person we have to kill. However, I do not believe that it is time yet. As for notty, her theories are sometimes flawed so it might lead to townies killed one after another, so I say keep her and see for a while. Lastly for sploorkly, I have no idea if his playing style. I'll research on the previous seasons of mafia to see if he is indeed a big threat or not, but I doubt so.
Though I must say, Defiant is the top priority of the person we have to kill. However, I do not believe that it is time yet. As for notty, her theories are sometimes flawed so it might lead to townies killed one after another, so I say keep her and see for a while. Lastly for sploorkly, I have no idea if his playing style. I'll research on the previous seasons of mafia to see if he is indeed a big threat or not, but I doubt so.
I am the One-shot poisoner.
One time, I get to poison somebody. That person will die the following night. (If I poison someone tonight, they will die on night 2)
I am also a roommate with three other people. Not quite sure how to take advantage of it, I think i'll just waste their time by roleplaying.
One time, I get to poison somebody. That person will die the following night. (If I poison someone tonight, they will die on night 2)
I am also a roommate with three other people. Not quite sure how to take advantage of it, I think i'll just waste their time by roleplaying.
I am a Mafia Roomate.
So what's interesting here is that I'm in a conversation with Defiant, infrrnifox and k1ng Howard. I'm interested to see if Defiant drops his roleplaying tonight.
Also with what you said Grimm, it's always been that you can talk to fellow mafia on nights and I made it seem that I didn't know everything to know about this game so 'they might not even know who eachother are', I was faking ignorance there.
Also, wow we have a SUPER strong mafia team here. We're all fairly experienced
Strategy wise, I think we did well fanning out our votes, the only one with a bit of suspicion was Ender, so watch out a bit.
Night abilities
Alpha: Im not sure whether to use your poison tonight or tomorrow but we have make sure that we dont leave it too late.
Endersteve: Your ability COULD be useful if we some how know the persons role already. I'm just hoping that we have a contact.
grimmMafia roleblocker is a good role to have, all you can do is try to block the cop or some other power role. At a later stage, with reveals it will come in handy.
So what's interesting here is that I'm in a conversation with Defiant, infrrnifox and k1ng Howard. I'm interested to see if Defiant drops his roleplaying tonight.
Also with what you said Grimm, it's always been that you can talk to fellow mafia on nights and I made it seem that I didn't know everything to know about this game so 'they might not even know who eachother are', I was faking ignorance there.
Also, wow we have a SUPER strong mafia team here. We're all fairly experienced
Strategy wise, I think we did well fanning out our votes, the only one with a bit of suspicion was Ender, so watch out a bit.
Night abilities
Alpha: Im not sure whether to use your poison tonight or tomorrow but we have make sure that we dont leave it too late.
Endersteve: Your ability COULD be useful if we some how know the persons role already. I'm just hoping that we have a contact.
grimmMafia roleblocker is a good role to have, all you can do is try to block the cop or some other power role. At a later stage, with reveals it will come in handy.
.- Status