Players logging in just for cookies

scotty12345

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
413
Reaction score
400
Hi all ,
Just a quick note.
I have noticed a few players seems to login just for cookies recently.
They join the round at the start then leave and come back just as the round is about to end.
This is alittle unfair on players that have played the entire round.
Is it possible that if a player joins 10min or less before the end of the round they get no or a reduced amount of cookies?

Cheers
Scotty
 

Butamou

Grandmason
Contributor
Joined
May 31, 2013
Messages
267
Reaction score
450
Hi all ,
Just a quick note.
I have noticed a few players seems to login just for cookies recently.
They join the round at the start then leave and come back just as the round is about to end.
This is alittle unfair on players that have played the entire round.
Is it possible that if a player joins 10min or less before the end of the round they get no or a reduced amount of cookies?

Cheers
Scotty
I would like to say don't do it! mainly because I do this. I'm busy doing other things and it's easier if you're in the middle of some build in progress; just so you don't have to sit there and lose potential ideas in the for your builds.
 

Lee_scar

Geezuslike
Donor
Joined
Aug 8, 2011
Messages
715
Reaction score
596
Hi all ,
Just a quick note.
I have noticed a few players seems to login just for cookies recently.
They join the round at the start then leave and come back just as the round is about to end.
This is alittle unfair on players that have played the entire round.
Is it possible that if a player joins 10min or less before the end of the round they get no or a reduced amount of cookies?

Cheers
Scotty
Eh, unfair how exactly?
Its only unfair in the sense that they are not enjoying themselves enough to remain the full amount of time.
You can argue its an abuse of the system, but really who is it hurting? Those who spend the round and enjoy themselves? Most certainly not.

It's only really a 'detriment' in the fact if your one of those people that feel as though having a certain rank or larger amount of something then another person is praise worthy.

So this is fair to the people that happen to log in five minutes left before the rounds end and they had not formerly logged in at round start?

I don't feel as though its right when people are reluctant to spend the time and are only after the cookie gain that others and everyone should be punished.

The proper solution would be a plugin, lets call it 'cookie-code'.
At a random time within the round each player is messaged a player specific 'passphrase' meaning its unique and different to each player. As well as the times would be random per player.
If they so happen to log off the 'code' no longer works, however an op can 'recode' a player that has crashed, other external circumstances with /recode playername reason.
The reason to prevent abuse as the 'code' would be a HUGE incentive.

At the end of the round all players get the standard set of cookies. The special case being if a player 'submits a code' to lets say the lava god for fun, with something like /submitcode codehere. Those who have submitted a code will then receive particular rewards, perchance more cookies, maybe ore or other shinies.

That would be the end all beat all to the problem you've stated
 

RaizzanX

Trash
Controller
Donor
Discord Staff
Joined
Oct 16, 2011
Messages
630
Reaction score
1,066
Hi all ,
Just a quick note.
I have noticed a few players seems to login just for cookies recently.
They join the round at the start then leave and come back just as the round is about to end.
This is alittle unfair on players that have played the entire round.
Is it possible that if a player joins 10min or less before the end of the round they get no or a reduced amount of cookies?

Cheers
Scotty
Reminds me of the "you joined too late" system back in classic lava.
 
W

Wimali

Guest
Meh, I never really liked that feature personally. What if someone crashes? Or they have to escape death by relogging? (then again, logging out to escape death is kinda frown upon anyway)

How about just making logging in for cookies illegal, but not change anything? So, if someone'd do it intentionally, staff would warn/punish them (potentially make sure the player doesn't get cookies), and players can report them. However, if someone has to relog for some reason, they'll still get cookies and everything will be fiiiiine.
 

Undefined User 7

Psychosomatic
Joined
Aug 7, 2011
Messages
1,134
Reaction score
4,083
It's suggested out of good intention, if a player is intentionally logging in just to get cookies at the end there are some obvious objections. I won't lie that I've done it in the past, and I can understand why players who work for their cookies would be mad. However, there's just no way to tell who genuinely does it and who's just getting in. Truthfully, it'd be unfair to the players who just logged in late unintentionally.
 
Top