Mafia Season 6

[mariosatr]

First off, I would like to point out that both Vati and I were asked to defend ourselves. You choose to lynch the one who actually defended themselves over the one who "too busy playing League of Legends and Team Fortress 2"? What a great reason c: ... no. I defended myself and Vati has yet to do so. For all we know, he could be covering it up and procrastinating to protect himself because he knows he could be in trouble if he slips up. Vote who you wish, I'm just stating that it is an ignorant decision to vote off the person who actually spoke up instead of being "too busy" to write one or two sentences on why they shouldn't be lynched and if they aren't mafia. Who knows! Vati could be anyone. The least he could do is say if he is or isn't mafia, the same as I did. This goes for everyone. Being in jeopardy of being voted off, It's tough to say this, but how about let's be smart about our decisions and think a little bit before making a mistake.

I think it's more of because the only time you've really spoken is when we've discussed voting you off, which DOES seem suspicious. But you're right, this isn't too smart a choice. I think we should just get this over with, though. We have no leads. I'm sick of this just getting nowhere because people are too reluctant to do anything.

People talking more when they're getting voted is natural and not suspicious at all.

No, the fact that he only talked when he was being voted on just seems a bit suspicious to me. But again, I'm not basing this off much evidence... I'm just trying to get the game moving, at the least, or make a lynch happen at the most.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

Yeah, it happens a lot.
Player lurks all game, is called out for not talking, player decides to talk.
You wouldn't expect him to not talk upon being put up as a potential lynch, would you?

 

[mariosatr]

Yeah, it happens a lot.
Player lurks all game, is called out for not talking, player decides to talk.
You wouldn't expect him to not talk upon being put up as a potential lynch, would you?

No, but I'd expect him to talk at other times too.
Again, I'm not basing this off too much logic. I just think we should make something happen. We have no leads, and we're not getting anywhere.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

Yeah, it happens a lot.
Player lurks all game, is called out for not talking, player decides to talk.
You wouldn't expect him to not talk upon being put up as a potential lynch, would you?

No, but I'd expect him to talk at other times too.
Again, I'm not basing this off too much logic. I just think we should make something happen. We have no leads, and we're not getting anywhere.

Him talking here still doesn't mean anything, regardless if he didn't speak elsewhere.
There's a good bit of other players that hardly talk. Why Dillon?

 

[mariosatr]

Yeah, it happens a lot.
Player lurks all game, is called out for not talking, player decides to talk.
You wouldn't expect him to not talk upon being put up as a potential lynch, would you?

No, but I'd expect him to talk at other times too.
Again, I'm not basing this off too much logic. I just think we should make something happen. We have no leads, and we're not getting anywhere.

Him talking here still doesn't mean anything, regardless if he didn't speak elsewhere.
There's a good bit of other players that hardly talk. Why Dillon?

No reason in particular, I just had to pick one and I did. Could've been Jeff, could've been Musta, could've been Vati. Maybe I'll change my vote? I don't know, but I feel like we should do something. We still have the Vigilante, right?

 

[Vatowski]

To be honest, I think lynching Dillon would be a bad idea. We pretty much have little to none evidence that he is mafia or serial killer. People are panicking because they no one to vote for so they vote for the quiet ones saying to themselves: "OMG HES ONLY TALKING WHEN HES IN DANGER HE MUST BE MAFIA HURDURRR". That is not a valid reason. The bandwagon of DillonSaysRawr started because of this:

You know what? I am sick of this. No more.
I am voting for DillonSaysRawr, straight off the bat.

Did mariosatr actually expalin why he voted to lynch off Dillon? Nope. Then people started to vote for him with actually no damn evidence.

I am gonna be honest, I have not been replying to this thread because I do not have the heart to do so. I am seriously thinking to have me replaced cause of my inactivity, but that is another story.

Returning to the game, I think we should remove the votes on Dillon and ask the cop all the roles he investigated up to now so we could eliminate suspects.

 

[mariosatr]

To be honest, I think lynching Dillon would be a bad idea. We pretty much have little to none evidence that he is mafia or serial killer. People are panicking because they no one to vote for so they vote for the quiet ones saying to themselves: "OMG HES ONLY TALKING WHEN HES IN DANGER HE MUST BE MAFIA HURDURRR". That is not a valid reason. The bandwagon of DillonSaysRawr started because of this:

You know what? I am sick of this. No more.
I am voting for DillonSaysRawr, straight off the bat.

Did mariosatr actually expalin why he voted to lynch off Dillon? Nope. Then people started to vote for him with actually no damn evidence.

I am gonna be honest, I have not been replying to this thread because I do not have the heart to do so. I am seriously thinking to have me replaced cause of my inactivity, but that is another story.

Returning to the game, I think we should remove the votes on Dillon and ask the cop all the roles he investigated up to now so we could eliminate suspects.

We actually have very little leads. Again, I don't really have any evidence, and I'm not basing it off much. I'm basing it off what we have to make do with, and I'm trying to make something actually happen instead of a long day that accomplishes nothing. Is it a rash move? Yes. But is it the wrong choice? I don't think it is.

 

[Vatowski]

To be honest, I think lynching Dillon would be a bad idea. We pretty much have little to none evidence that he is mafia or serial killer. People are panicking because they no one to vote for so they vote for the quiet ones saying to themselves: "OMG HES ONLY TALKING WHEN HES IN DANGER HE MUST BE MAFIA HURDURRR". That is not a valid reason. The bandwagon of DillonSaysRawr started because of this:

You know what? I am sick of this. No more.
I am voting for DillonSaysRawr, straight off the bat.

Did mariosatr actually expalin why he voted to lynch off Dillon? Nope. Then people started to vote for him with actually no damn evidence.

I am gonna be honest, I have not been replying to this thread because I do not have the heart to do so. I am seriously thinking to have me replaced cause of my inactivity, but that is another story.

Returning to the game, I think we should remove the votes on Dillon and ask the cop all the roles he investigated up to now so we could eliminate suspects.

We actually have very little leads. Again, I don't really have any evidence, and I'm not basing it off much. I'm basing it off what we have to make do with, and I'm trying to make something actually happen instead of a long day that accomplishes nothing. Is it a rash move? Yes. But is it the wrong choice? I don't think it is.

Like I said, you are probably panicking because we have no actual leads and thinking that lynching someone that is a bit suspicious will help. But what happens if Dillon is a civilian? We're in big doo doo if he is.

 

[mariosatr]

To be honest, I think lynching Dillon would be a bad idea. We pretty much have little to none evidence that he is mafia or serial killer. People are panicking because they no one to vote for so they vote for the quiet ones saying to themselves: "OMG HES ONLY TALKING WHEN HES IN DANGER HE MUST BE MAFIA HURDURRR". That is not a valid reason. The bandwagon of DillonSaysRawr started because of this:
Did mariosatr actually expalin why he voted to lynch off Dillon? Nope. Then people started to vote for him with actually no damn evidence.

I am gonna be honest, I have not been replying to this thread because I do not have the heart to do so. I am seriously thinking to have me replaced cause of my inactivity, but that is another story.

Returning to the game, I think we should remove the votes on Dillon and ask the cop all the roles he investigated up to now so we could eliminate suspects.

We actually have very little leads. Again, I don't really have any evidence, and I'm not basing it off much. I'm basing it off what we have to make do with, and I'm trying to make something actually happen instead of a long day that accomplishes nothing. Is it a rash move? Yes. But is it the wrong choice? I don't think it is.

Like I said, you are probably panicking because we have no actual leads and thinking that lynching someone that is a bit suspicious will help. But what happens if Dillon is a civilian? We're in big doo doo if he is.

We are, but I still think it's better than nothing. I'm considering changing my vote, but we have NO leads. The last time we did have a lead, it didn't work (Storm).

 

[Vatowski]

We actually have very little leads. Again, I don't really have any evidence, and I'm not basing it off much. I'm basing it off what we have to make do with, and I'm trying to make something actually happen instead of a long day that accomplishes nothing. Is it a rash move? Yes. But is it the wrong choice? I don't think it is.

Like I said, you are probably panicking because we have no actual leads and thinking that lynching someone that is a bit suspicious will help. But what happens if Dillon is a civilian? We're in big doo doo if he is.

We are, but I still think it's better than nothing. I'm considering changing my vote, but we have NO leads. The last time we did have a lead, it didn't work (Storm).

So your doing a random lynch? That is one of the worst things you could do in mafia especially in a time like this when if we lose one or two town members we lose.

 

[mariosatr]

Actually... I just give up. We're getting nowhere. I withdraw my vote. We're not going to get anywhere, for a long time, though, unless we actually get a lynch going. We have to be prepared to take risks.

 

[The Road to Ruin]

I'm am setting a 24 hour sudden death in effect.

 

[The Road to Ruin]

Vote count
Defiant_blob 1 - JKangaroo
Dillon 2 - Dessern Balloon
Mariosatr 1 - Defiant_blob

 

[Alisha]

I have been trying to eliminate roles, but the best I can do is remove a lot of suspicion, not all of it.

-Night 1: Investigated HarmakPaul. Turned up as civilian. Slim chance of godfather.
-Night 2: Investigated Hockeyfan1852. Turned up as civilian and lyncher target. Hockeyfan dies. On Day 2, Defiant_Blob immediately claims lyncher and names hockeyfan as his target.
-Night 3: Investigated JKangaroo. Turned up as civilian. Slim chance of godfather.

 

[Alisha]

The road to ruin Defiant voted for mariosatr, not me.

Please be really careful with vote tallies.

 

[mariosatr]

So, Alpha, what are your thoughts? I'm not even sure who to trust anymore... maybe I should rely on your verdict.

 

[Alisha]

Well, I hope dillon's not the doctor, because I rely on the doctor to stay alive myself.

As long as the doctor doesn't die I'm happy. I am in school atm, so I don't have time to make a huge post.(If I make a big post, I promise to actually think it out this time).

Honestly I'm a bit confused on why you depend on my verdict, because I've been wrong before. Anyone can look back through these 20ish pages, pick a name to track, and provide reasons on why they are very suspicious.

 

[mariosatr]

Well, I just feel I can trust you and JKangaroo more than anyone else at the minute. I'd like to see his opinion too.

 

[The Road to Ruin]

The road to ruin Defiant voted for mariosatr, not me.

Please be really careful with vote tallies.

I was going to edit that after going back and checking votes

 

[Vatowski]

Alpha your also off the list of suspects since you are the cop

 

[Defiant_Blob]

Mario is still my main suspect.

 

[balloon98]

I don't know why mario is but I am almost certain that I think I know what role he has that he said was townsided but not helpful before but the role is VERY helpful. I feel like people had their chance to talk and if they are about to get lynched and just try saying "lets just use evidence and pick someone else" that shouldn't be enough. Let's be honest the only evidence in mafia games is slip-ups and Cop investigations for the most part and neither of those are helping to point to someone right now. I am keeping my vote and hoping to god we chose the right person to lynch.

 

[Jeff0521]

Well then. I also haven't talked unless I've been called out. Why choose Dillon when there are at least 4 people here doing it? Why not just vote me? Doesn't bother me really.

 

[mariosatr]

Well then. I also haven't talked unless I've been called out. Why choose Dillon when there are at least 4 people here doing it? Why not just vote me? Doesn't bother me really.

It was really just a random pick out of four. At the time, I don't know what was going through my head... I just wanted to make progress. Now that I look back on it, at least it gets the game moving a bit more than it was prior to this.
But it was more of a one out of four pick, since you were all equal in terms of evidence.

 

[Dess]

No I am not going to retract. He honestly is contributing nothing to this.

And before you all start "omg he's mafia he lynched a townie". We have no proof of him being town, I am going to go with the safest bet I have right now and lynch him.

Also fun side note: Notice how vati became active once Dillon started getting into a close to lynch experience? That doesn't sit well with me.