MEDIEVAL MAFIA: INTRUSION [DAY 8]
- Thread starter MarsKid
- Start date
- Status
Lets see if I can try to explain it differently.
My reluctancce took into account total toqn outnumbered scum.
However, one dezian isnt the end of the world, and it would have been more likely to lynch a scum or unimportant person than town power role.
My reluctancce took into account total toqn outnumbered scum.
However, one dezian isnt the end of the world, and it would have been more likely to lynch a scum or unimportant person than town power role.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Since I don't really have any suspicions other than Pim right now, who has been strangely quiet on D1, meaning that I can't really get any more evidence supporting my theory, let's look at who's been inactive and see if they could be suspicious just to get the discussion going again, because it's starting to die already.
cooliorules You have been very quiet this game, while in the previous game, where you were town, you were much more active. Possible scum hiding in shadows?
And then there's Joshua who has basically said nothing at all besides "Hi". Can't really judge him based on that, but it kinda seems strange to me.
Do you two have anything to say?
cooliorules You have been very quiet this game, while in the previous game, where you were town, you were much more active. Possible scum hiding in shadows?
And then there's Joshua who has basically said nothing at all besides "Hi". Can't really judge him based on that, but it kinda seems strange to me.
Do you two have anything to say?
HypeBurst
Just Fabulous
My FoS of User and Jivvi has kinda simmered down really, other than the jokes votes, I cant see a reason why they would be suspicious.
Imma start tagging bitches if they dont talk, like for realios. Dis aint cute and imma come down hard on some inactive asses digitalmez im looking at you hoe :m <3
Imma start tagging bitches if they dont talk, like for realios. Dis aint cute and imma come down hard on some inactive asses digitalmez im looking at you hoe :m <3
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
Firstly, last season and this season are different. Different people. Different roles. Last season was my first season, so I'm trying out some different strategies. I'm mostly not posting because I go to sleep and there's another 2 pages for me to read, but I don't have time to read them because of school, then I get home and have homework to do.
I apologise to all for this. It's coming to the end of the year and the teachers are trying to shove in that last little bit of work. I am trying my best to catch up, at the end of the week I should be back to normal activity.
Gameplay related though, my current fos is Ltin. He just seems scummy, to me. It's just a hunch at this point, although if more comes up I may be able to develop some sort of case agaisnt him. Not worth a lynch at this stage, but I'm just outting my opinion.
Da Jinks
Political Nerd
Weren't there quite a few people who suggested a no lynch? I believe I did at first, along with others. Don't see how this makes him all that suspicious
On the other hand...
What power struggle?
Seems GmK himself didn't even know about it! Just a possibility, could you be trying to subtly shove two of the games strongest players against each other? Not saying we lynch Jivvi, just pointing it out.
Joshua
Member
- Joined
- Nov 5, 2013
- Messages
- 0
- Reaction score
- 0
I am by no means a criminal. I wish to see the perpetrators brought to justice as much as anyone.
Da Jinks
Political Nerd
Honestly, I haven't posted much this game, but when I do I try and add something to the game. Can I suggest reading some and bringing forth your own suspicions? Else you will be thought of as suspicious in some peoples eyes.
Okay, got my mind into this again.
So Sploorky got lynched, SerialKiller didnt kill. (block, didnt shoot, shot protected person, etc)
People get suspicious on Ltin for stating the oppisite what everyone else said.
Im not sure how he is suspicious of saying SK didnt shoot, are you implying that he's Sk because of it? And if so, why?
Lets see if this post will help you get more evidence of your theory.
And your discussion might be good for also other players, but it keeps you very nicely out of the spotlight.
Not that I have anything against you as for the moment, but dont think I wont keep an eyes out for you too.
So Sploorky got lynched, SerialKiller didnt kill. (block, didnt shoot, shot protected person, etc)
People get suspicious on Ltin for stating the oppisite what everyone else said.
Im not sure how he is suspicious of saying SK didnt shoot, are you implying that he's Sk because of it? And if so, why?
Maybe you miswrote this, but you are saying a no-lynch is a disadvantage, though you Can gather information out of it?
Still suspicious of me because the things of D0?
Lets see if this post will help you get more evidence of your theory.
And your discussion might be good for also other players, but it keeps you very nicely out of the spotlight.
Not that I have anything against you as for the moment, but dont think I wont keep an eyes out for you too.
On my mind…
No Lynching
I hate lynching on the first day. I will never agree to it for as long as I play Mafia. I’ve always considered Lynching on D1, but the possibility of a mislynch makes me nervous. I would rather sacrifice 1-2 townies (including myself) to Mafia or to a third party role, rather than lose three. Don’t get me wrong, I will lynch on D1 if someone messes up or if there’s proof. Otherwise I strongly believe in No-Lynching on the first day.
Gut Feeling
What I advise, especially for those who are new, please read and re-read the Mafia thread and try to form an opinion of your own. Of course you’re going to be persuaded by different arguments, but if something doesn’t feel right to you, state it. Gut feelings are good. You don’t need to say, “I vote for so and so”, just post who you think feels suspicious to you. I don’t know about other people, but if someone says, “I have a strange feeling about such and such” I look back on the posts of that person who they’re accusing, but I also read the posts of the accuser. You’re bound to deduce a few points from either party.
Don’t feel inadequate. I could care less now about arguments against my gut feeling votes. As long as you have some substantial explanation to back up why you voted for that person, then be confident in sticking to that vote.
Two Cents
I’m not comfortable with The road to ruin's posts. To me he seems to be mirroring 77’s game style from The Doomed Cruise. He’ll give his opinion here and there but they’re not really valid. Which is strange to me because I’m use to Road posting all sorts of ideas. Right now he seems to pop in and out so to prove his presence and avoid being accused of lurking. The road’s looking a tad bit suspicious to me.
Anyway. Carry on. I have the weekend to no life Mafia until work starts up again on Monday.
;_;
No Lynching
I hate lynching on the first day. I will never agree to it for as long as I play Mafia. I’ve always considered Lynching on D1, but the possibility of a mislynch makes me nervous. I would rather sacrifice 1-2 townies (including myself) to Mafia or to a third party role, rather than lose three. Don’t get me wrong, I will lynch on D1 if someone messes up or if there’s proof. Otherwise I strongly believe in No-Lynching on the first day.
Gut Feeling
I think that Prizyms makes a good point here.
What I advise, especially for those who are new, please read and re-read the Mafia thread and try to form an opinion of your own. Of course you’re going to be persuaded by different arguments, but if something doesn’t feel right to you, state it. Gut feelings are good. You don’t need to say, “I vote for so and so”, just post who you think feels suspicious to you. I don’t know about other people, but if someone says, “I have a strange feeling about such and such” I look back on the posts of that person who they’re accusing, but I also read the posts of the accuser. You’re bound to deduce a few points from either party.
Don’t feel inadequate. I could care less now about arguments against my gut feeling votes. As long as you have some substantial explanation to back up why you voted for that person, then be confident in sticking to that vote.
Two Cents
I’m not comfortable with The road to ruin's posts. To me he seems to be mirroring 77’s game style from The Doomed Cruise. He’ll give his opinion here and there but they’re not really valid. Which is strange to me because I’m use to Road posting all sorts of ideas. Right now he seems to pop in and out so to prove his presence and avoid being accused of lurking. The road’s looking a tad bit suspicious to me.
Anyway. Carry on. I have the weekend to no life Mafia until work starts up again on Monday.
;_;
This is going way too slowly for day 1....
I feel like a no lynch would be a terrible thing to do on Day 1. A no lynch is only suitable on day 0 and sometimes on special circumstances imo. It would just give mafia and sk (if they decide to kill) another kill on the town without the town getting the opportunity to fight back (if that makes sense.)
So I guess it is a possibility that the serial killer didn't kill last night, but why not? I was thinking and maybe the sk is someone new which led me to this post:
I feel like a no lynch would be a terrible thing to do on Day 1. A no lynch is only suitable on day 0 and sometimes on special circumstances imo. It would just give mafia and sk (if they decide to kill) another kill on the town without the town getting the opportunity to fight back (if that makes sense.)
So I guess it is a possibility that the serial killer didn't kill last night, but why not? I was thinking and maybe the sk is someone new which led me to this post:
I believe Joshua is new. Correct? Maybe he is just not interested in the game because he is a towny, or maybe he is just busy. I just find this post suspicious. I feel like it would be something someone new would say if he or she was mafia/sk. But of course there are other people who could be deemed suspicious based on my reasoning. I would like to hear more from brownlee123 also.
cooliorules
That Awkward Noodle
Don't reaaaally have a fos, as of current. Will re-read most of this and post my fos (if there is one) in the morning when I can actually read and make sense of it.
I would like the people who haven't said anything/much to speak up, though.
I would like the people who haven't said anything/much to speak up, though.
storm886 wants to hear a little more from me, so here's a little run-through of my thoughts throughout the game so far.
Sign-Ups I'm new to the server (first played RoF in August, followed by BB then AoD) and signing up for the forums in Spetember. So I usually do things in the Server-related forum sections, but I see "forum games". Well, I like games, so I click on it. Oh, they have mafia! I love the IRL party game. Could it be the same thing? I see that Mafia Lite "Sign-Ups" are apparently over, so I click on the Medieval Mafia thread. Oh, this is exactly like mafia! Except there are waaaaay more roles. I sign up just to try it out.
Day 0 I see it's now Day 0! Yes, the game has started! But I severely underestimated how in-depth this game is. Jivvi voting, then un-voting? Oh, he must be just screwing around. But then Notty and Pim vote? Then Pim un-votes? What? I personally thought we would lynch based on logic, as in who seems to never be in the spotlight, and what groups of people seem to be getting killed off. I say, "Better Safe than Sorry!" and stay silent to prevent myself from saying some completely stupid thing.
Day 1 Well, it seems as though people are trying to get others out of the shadows. It's only a matter of time before I'm-
Yep, there goes storm886 asking me to talk. I want to keep the attention off of me, so I carefully write a longish post so no questions are left unanswered.
And that's what I've been thinking, guys.
Sign-Ups I'm new to the server (first played RoF in August, followed by BB then AoD) and signing up for the forums in Spetember. So I usually do things in the Server-related forum sections, but I see "forum games". Well, I like games, so I click on it. Oh, they have mafia! I love the IRL party game. Could it be the same thing? I see that Mafia Lite "Sign-Ups" are apparently over, so I click on the Medieval Mafia thread. Oh, this is exactly like mafia! Except there are waaaaay more roles. I sign up just to try it out.
Day 0 I see it's now Day 0! Yes, the game has started! But I severely underestimated how in-depth this game is. Jivvi voting, then un-voting? Oh, he must be just screwing around. But then Notty and Pim vote? Then Pim un-votes? What? I personally thought we would lynch based on logic, as in who seems to never be in the spotlight, and what groups of people seem to be getting killed off. I say, "Better Safe than Sorry!" and stay silent to prevent myself from saying some completely stupid thing.
Day 1 Well, it seems as though people are trying to get others out of the shadows. It's only a matter of time before I'm-
Yep, there goes storm886 asking me to talk. I want to keep the attention off of me, so I carefully write a longish post so no questions are left unanswered.
And that's what I've been thinking, guys.
- Status