Actually....There is a reason :sAs a Tribunal member, I will discuss the (potential) execution of Sploorky at night with the other 2. If Sploorky is dead by morning, it's most likely our doing. Again, there's no reason that Sploorky doesn't have a town-sided 'true love' and becomes town-sided as a result of that, explaining his difference in alignment to Nottykitten after the mistletoe report.
When Jivvi claimed (On day 2), he had two reports. Misletoes only receive reports if the match fails. Sploorky was only in the second report (with Notty).