midnightgirl24
You're gonna have a bad time.
Yeah, but it just randomly stops notifying me. It did that on the last Mafia game I played in
Retaking Rochester (Concluded)
- Thread starter Jivvi
- Start date
- Status
Okay got my role now... although I guess it didn't really matter if I had it or not. Oh well! I've read most of the thread. I don't see any votes today, except those on me (aka theweakguy's replacement). So with that, I will bring out my FoS. Ever since I started reading this thread, Mad11gab8 has caught my attention. His first post is example 1:
" He did turn out to be mafia... ironically. Now, you may say, "Well GmK just came out and said he was mafia like that; that emoticon has nothing to do with it." There was another more recent game where timdood used a seemingly friendly emoticon in his first post; he was scum. However, this game is a bit different from the rest in regards to mafia having the majority so I couldn't be completely sure what Mad11gad8 is, but I am sure it is sinister (possibly Illusionist).
Example 2:
This analysis has led me to believe that lynching Mad11gab8 would benefit the majority of the players including myself.
vote Mad11gab8
Although this may seem like a kind gesture to the other players playing the game, it seems sinister to me. Notice the :3 after the all. Believe it or not, emoticons can tell you a lot. Especially when they're in the first post. I remember in a mafia game about 4 games ago, GmK's first post was something like, "I'm mafia. Kill me.
" He did turn out to be mafia... ironically. Now, you may say, "Well GmK just came out and said he was mafia like that; that emoticon has nothing to do with it." There was another more recent game where timdood used a seemingly friendly emoticon in his first post; he was scum. However, this game is a bit different from the rest in regards to mafia having the majority so I couldn't be completely sure what Mad11gad8 is, but I am sure it is sinister (possibly Illusionist).Example 2:
Now, this is just one example of the point I'm about to make. There are many other posts that show this. Mad11gab8 is often seen asking people to answer questions about their thoughts of the game, and he often places suspicion on the lurkers. He doesn't give much analysis. This sends up a red flag for me. He is giving us the "illusion" that he actually contributing, but he really isn't doing that much. I am more likely to trust a "lurker" who doesn't try to act like their helping.
This analysis has led me to believe that lynching Mad11gab8 would benefit the majority of the players including myself.
vote Mad11gab8
midnightgirl24
You're gonna have a bad time.
I never thought of it that way..after going back and reading that, I have decided who to vote. (Though it could change)Okay got my role now... although I guess it didn't really matter if I had it or not. Oh well! I've read most of the thread. I don't see any votes today, except those on me (aka theweakguy's replacement). So with that, I will bring out my FoS. Ever since I started reading this thread, Mad11gab8 has caught my attention. His first post is example 1:
Although this may seem like a kind gesture to the other players playing the game, it seems sinister to me. Notice the :3 after the all. Believe it or not, emoticons can tell you a lot. Especially when they're in the first post. I remember in a mafia game about 4 games ago, GmK's first post was something like, "I'm mafia. Kill me.
Example 2:
Now, this is just one example of the point I'm about to make. There are many other posts that show this. Mad11gab8 is often seen asking people to answer questions about their thoughts of the game, and he often places suspicion on the lurkers. He doesn't give much analysis. This sends up a red flag for me. He is giving us the "illusion" that he actually contributing, but he really isn't doing that much. I am more likely to trust a "lurker" who doesn't try to act like their helping.
This analysis has led me to believe that lynching Mad11gab8 would benefit the majority of the players including myself.
vote Mad11gab8
Vote Mad11gab8
I find your first point invalid, yes, I am a bubbly person and I have been trying to cut down on my emoticons but I believe people may take it the wrong way without it there... Look sorry for being me, I can't really help being who I am. It was simply a cheerful gesture trying to get people in the swing of things, I thought it would just be a nice way to start this day but obviously you think not. I do find this point quite irrelevent to this game.Okay got my role now... although I guess it didn't really matter if I had it or not. Oh well! I've read most of the thread. I don't see any votes today, except those on me (aka theweakguy's replacement). So with that, I will bring out my FoS. Ever since I started reading this thread, Mad11gab8 has caught my attention. His first post is example 1:
Although this may seem like a kind gesture to the other players playing the game, it seems sinister to me. Notice the :3 after the all. Believe it or not, emoticons can tell you a lot. Especially when they're in the first post. I remember in a mafia game about 4 games ago, GmK's first post was something like, "I'm mafia. Kill me.
Example 2:
Now, this is just one example of the point I'm about to make. There are many other posts that show this. Mad11gab8 is often seen asking people to answer questions about their thoughts of the game, and he often places suspicion on the lurkers. He doesn't give much analysis. This sends up a red flag for me. He is giving us the "illusion" that he actually contributing, but he really isn't doing that much. I am more likely to trust a "lurker" who doesn't try to act like their helping.
This analysis has led me to believe that lynching Mad11gab8 would benefit the majority of the players including myself.
vote Mad11gab8
As for your point about the lurkers, it is not only me who has suspected them. This game has not given us many great leads so we have had to try and grab on to small things. Therefore many of us suspecting people who lurk. I believe they wouldn't be hiding without something they are trying to keep secret, why would they put suspicion on themselves if they were innocent? This is why I didnt havenmich analysis, because there was mothing to do it on. I find it odd that you would pick on me about this point as it is not only myself who has brought suspicion up about the lurkers. Yes, I may do it often but we didn't have anything better to go off therefore my suspicion on them.
And yes, I ask questions and may I point out many others have. This is only an oppertunity to help everybody out. Everyone wants someone from their opposing allignment to slip and usually asking questions can favor anyone. This is not helping? Again it is odd why you would pick on me about this as I am not the only person who has been asking questions, lee recently asked a question but no suspicion on him from you? Funny that.
I do find most of your points very sketchy and you don't have much evidence. Although your points may be relevant I can tell you I am not Illusionist. I believe you are just trying to throw suspicion off you because you are illusionist. I will see what you have to say before voting.
Oh I forgot to say that during the first page Raxo, Erik, Jinks and Sephh all included at least once or more an emoticon in their post BUT of course you have decided to only pick on me to try and throw votes off you. After taking another look at this. (I am very sorry if this comes out hostile but I didn't want to use emoticons..
Vote storm886
Vote storm886
Population - 14
To Lynch - 8
To No-Lynch - 7
Voted - 5
(1) - Lee_Scar - std1997
(2) - Mad11gab8 - storm886, midnightgirl24
(1) - storm886 - Mad11gab8, raxo222
(1) - Da Jinks - Sephhh
(9) - No vote
To Lynch - 8
To No-Lynch - 7
Voted - 5
(1) - Lee_Scar - std1997
(2) - Mad11gab8 - storm886, midnightgirl24
(1) - storm886 - Mad11gab8, raxo222
(1) - Da Jinks - Sephhh
(9) - No vote
Last edited:
Well, I still have that gut felling about Mad11gab and I still don't know why.It might be some of the stuff storm said. In fairness though the lurkers are getting annoying and honestly if this is going towards a no-vote we might as well lynch one of the lurkers or else they'll just remain lurking for the whole game.
Actually given how Raxo222 knows names and he refuses to give us names when he says he can prove seph isn't the illusionist + a 'few people' where sephh has not confirmed anything raxo has said.
Considering he says she shares a night chat and none of his supposed night chat comrade(s) have confirmed I believe raxo is the illusionist.
unvote
vote raxo2222
Considering he says she shares a night chat and none of his supposed night chat comrade(s) have confirmed I believe raxo is the illusionist.
unvote
vote raxo2222
Oh I'm still here don't worry. I'm just tired and honestly don't know why to do. Although raxo when you say you can confirm Sephh isn't the illusionist and you won't share your role with us, it does honestly seem like you are a mason. Care to explain? Because if you're so sure you're not the illusionist and Sephh isn't either then you guys would both be masons in the end. Also since when do emoticons suddenly mean something? Like quite honestly I have had my suspicions on mad11gab8 but apparently emoticons suddenly mean you're the illusionist? By that logic whoever used the most emoticons would be illusionist. Also storm why did you state your role didn't matter? By that logic you're saying you're not a power role.
I'm still exhausted so this most probably was phrased terribly but these are some of my suspicions and thoughts and the current situation
I'm still exhausted so this most probably was phrased terribly but these are some of my suspicions and thoughts and the current situation
I actually voted for Da Jinks if you didn't see Jivvi.
Also Lee, I decided to kept silent about that matter.
For now,
unvote
vote midnightgirl24
If your reason for voting is Mad11gab8 looking "sinister" and you're assuming that being sinister is most likely being an Illusionist, then I don't think that's a strong argument. For your second argument, people other than Mad11gab8 has been suspecting the lurkers and made them options for a lynch tonight and that actually includes me and some other peeps. I don't think how lynching him will benefit the majority. Care to explain? With my saying that the points are weak, I don't know how midnight just came up straight and voted for him as well.Although this may seem like a kind gesture to the other players playing the game, it seems sinister to me. Notice the :3 after the all. Believe it or not, emoticons can tell you a lot. Especially when they're in the first post. I remember in a mafia game about 4 games ago, GmK's first post was something like, "I'm mafia. Kill me.
Also Lee, I decided to kept silent about that matter.
For now,
unvote
vote midnightgirl24
I still think that storm is illusionist his arguments seemed quite weak and I believe he was just trying to pick on me to throw suspicion off himself. As for mid I find it quite odd that she would come straight up without much hesitation at all, and not much regarding her decision. My vote still sticks. (Also I am female, sorry just getting annoying with everyone saying he )
)I'll let that matter slide only for the sake of actually getting the game rolling.
Id like to see why the vote for midnightgirl is there so I'm joining in a vote against her as she always has availability when she is targeted.
unvote
vote midnightgirl
Id like to see why the vote for midnightgirl is there so I'm joining in a vote against her as she always has availability when she is targeted.
unvote
vote midnightgirl
If one vote is needed I will change to vote for mid. Reasons being, you quickly agreed with storm without much to tell us why. There were many odd points in his argument but you didn't even mention them. Quickly agreeing with someone most people think has been suspicious throughout this game is quite odd. Your vote was suspicious so if needed I would vote for you unless you have something to say.
I agreed with storm? When? About lurkers? They are a huge issue to me as I see some of them read the thread but not reply, but were not supposed to use that as leverage in a vote. Also my vote was on storm -jivvi missed my vote in the official count- until I changed it to raxo, but just now sephh said that voting raxo to pressure seph is a dead lead. So I'm actually thinking my vote on midnight was a bit too soon. However my main FOS are erik and jinks.
unvote
unvote
Notme
Self-Aware Forum AI
Well if I was illusionist I would reduce my posting to minimum like Storm - when you are lurker, there is low chance of slip 
So Storm and other lurkers is FOS.
Are erik and dajinks lurkers too?
So Storm and other lurkers is FOS.
Are erik and dajinks lurkers too?
Alright 2 things. First is that I'm still in Europe and still have limited access cuz most of the time I'm on mobile reading but have lots of trouble replying. Second is that at this point in the game I'd personally think we'd be going off of slips rather then suspicions. For that reason I'm not exactly contributing too much. Also Lee would you like to share why I am an FOS? Is it because I haven't been replying recently cuz if so then
Continuing from last post cuz derp on my part. If so then by that logic std would also be an FOS. To be fully honest my major suspicions on pikmon. Although they've clarified why he/she hadn't replied it still seems weird. They also said that it seemed like raxo was suspicious but added that they weren't calling him mafia. This makes me think that pikmon could in fact be doctor or even illusionist since they weren't calling raxo mafia nor townie.
midnightgirl24
You're gonna have a bad time.
I wasn't agreeing to the emoticons. I was agreeing to the part about the lurkers. And all my posts have been right after I've woken up, so I barely feel like typing a very long explanation.
- Status