SCP - Secure, Contain, Mafia [GAME OVER]

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
148
Reaction score
263
Question: How have you helped town?
My answer: Keeping the day active, actually voting, giving potential leads to go on, etc.
Couple things about that

Day activity =/= Town sided behavior; I seem to remember JKangaroo was once very active and turned out to be a scum (and won)
Voting =/= Town sided behavior
Potential leads to go on... like trying to kill samlen? Outing every power role resulting in the death of the cop?

Counter questions -
How do you think that you have helped the town by calling for mass role reveal?
How you proven well enough that you aren't mafia?
How have you do respond to your claim matching up with a desire and intent to kill any cops and doctors?
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,630
Reaction score
3,023
Couple things about that

Day activity =/= Town sided behavior; I seem to remember JKangaroo was once very active and turned out to be a scum (and won)
Voting =/= Town sided behavior
Potential leads to go on... like trying to kill samlen? Outing every power role resulting in the death of the cop?

Counter questions -
How do you think that you have helped the town by calling for mass role reveal?
How you proven well enough that you aren't mafia?
How have you do respond to your claim matching up with a desire and intent to kill any cops and doctors?
1. that was notty's idea not mine
2. i haven't but jolt was supposed to off samlen, potentially proving my claim
3. i literally do not care what happens to them either way
4. i made up a roleclaim earlier did you even read it, also i wanted the cardkey because who wouldn't want that
 
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
148
Reaction score
263
I don't know who would request a key card "just because" so it seems to me you want it because you can use it. Again it seems to me that you aren't telling us everything. If you willing to be so bold and say you don't care about doc's and cops I cannot trust you to remain in the game, either your a dangerous influence during the day willing to mislead the town and put us on a "road to ruin" or dangerous at night, someone who would request intel matches a profile of a leader... like the godfather.
 

Oak Milk

Kill Hungry Thirsty Dead
Mafia Host
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
1,267
Reaction score
1,922
There's a difference between driving the town to hang anyone who doesn't role claim for third party causes and calling for a demonstrably dangerous person to hang.
Wait wait wait wait, what on earth was your claim again? Also people continually seem to forget that it was GmK who worked out that Hunter was 3rd party (in a most stunning style I might also add), hunter didn't actually claim 3rd party he was simply caught out.
 

GmK

International Man Of Cake
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
2,987
Reaction score
5,686
Am on a course all weekend so will reply longer in monday, but let me just say:

I thought I'd help the town by not letting Fiesta (and/or Samlen) win, but if I had known how that now turns into a Hunter hunt (heh) I am not sure how helpful that was.

In my opinion we have a 50/50 chance of either Jivvi or OMO being scum sided, I'd much more hunt in that direction, why is everyone forgetting that?

And of those two, OMO seems confirmed item giver, whilst Jivvi can doublevote but always votes yes on O5 kills and used a knife on a cop claim. I want to think they're both town, but it so much looks like one was lying?

(And also, we still have too many blue claims, and now suddenly raxo is also an O5?)
 
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
148
Reaction score
263
Wait wait wait wait, what on earth was your claim again? Also people continually seem to forget that it was GmK who worked out that Hunter was 3rd party (in a most stunning style I might also add), hunter didn't actually claim 3rd party he was simply caught out.
That's my point. He engaged the town in a behavior (roleclaiming) which has ultimately been negative for us, though we didn't know this at the time the only reason he did this was to smoke out Samlen. He effectively ruined us and yet people don't see a reason to see him hang.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top