TBD [Status: GAME OVER]

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,629
Reaction score
3,021
okay! I'm going to make a comment now that i've managed to catch up (seriously you guys wrote an entire page while i was trying to catch up) Right now i just want to facepalm while watching the entire Alpha situation go down. The way Alpha was pushed into a corner to claim on day1 really isn't fair to him. I'm not certain Alpha is an alien, but I'm not convinced that means he is anti-town either. From my perspective alpha really could be anything from vanilla towny to mafia godfather. Though, I don't really believe for a second that he's an alien. Hunters claims that he wants a day to live are absolutely rediculous because there are very few roles in existance (be it town, third-party, or mafia sided) roles that don't increase their chances of winning by living longer in the day (unless hunter would like to argue that alpha is a fool)
he literally says he "needs just one night"

also he wasnt backed into a corner at all. ltin is scummy too, probablyjust as much as alpha
 

Defiant_Blob

( ̄^ ̄)ゞ
Donor
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,631
Reaction score
2,051
okay! I'm going to make a comment now that i've managed to catch up (seriously you guys wrote an entire page while i was trying to catch up) Right now i just want to facepalm while watching the entire Alpha situation go down. The way Alpha was pushed into a corner to claim on day1 really isn't fair to him. I'm not certain Alpha is an alien, but I'm not convinced that means he is anti-town either. From my perspective alpha really could be anything from vanilla towny to mafia godfather. Though, I don't really believe for a second that he's an alien. Hunters claims that he wants a day to live are absolutely rediculous because there are very few roles in existance (be it town, third-party, or mafia sided) roles that don't increase their chances of winning by living longer in the day (unless hunter would like to argue that alpha is a fool)
Alpha102 put himself in the corner. You act like it's a bad thing that I made him claim.
Why would he claim alien if he wasn't alien? There are plenty of roles to claim that have a much higher chance of survival with a fake-claim.

As Alpha102 pointed out, you're defending him really hard.
 

myusername22

A username.
Donor
Joined
Dec 17, 2012
Messages
858
Reaction score
937
this is literally what town is supposed to do. it is called scumhunting
yes, but if everyone played like this we would have to come to an argument that all of their posts are irrelevant because each and every post they made was to bait someone into admitting they were mafia. you know very well it's risky for town-sided players to do too much baiting, their essentially putting themselves into suspicion and therefore making themselves a lynch target. I doubt you'd play like this if you were an important town powerrole so either you believe your role is disposable or you're third party/mafia.
 

GmK

International Man Of Cake
Joined
Jul 31, 2011
Messages
2,987
Reaction score
5,686
Votecount 1 - the one where the host got up at 5am to drive to his parents for christmas (and thus makes it unformatted since he is on a train)


Ooglie101 - 1 - endersteve5
Ltin - 1 - Defiant_Blob
Alpha102 - 1 - Hunter27a1
Hunter - 1 - CaffeinatedKitten


No-Lynch - - 77_is_the_best, catgirl(numbers)

It takes 13 to lynch and 12 to no-lynch
 

Defiant_Blob

( ̄^ ̄)ゞ
Donor
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,631
Reaction score
2,051
yes, but if everyone played like this we would have to come to an argument that all of their posts are irrelevant because each and every post they made was to bait someone into admitting they were mafia. you know very well it's risky for town-sided players to do too much baiting, their essentially putting themselves into suspicion and therefore making themselves a lynch target. I doubt you'd play like this if you were an important town powerrole so either you believe your role is disposable or you're third party/mafia.
Weren't you baiting though
 

myusername22

A username.
Donor
Joined
Dec 17, 2012
Messages
858
Reaction score
937
Hunter27a1 some follow up questions to my last post:

wouldn't you consider baiting too much and causing this much confusion (so as to actually possibly start a band wagon and kill someone) to be going a bit too far in the way of "scumhunting?"

Assuming you are town-sided, don't you feel making yourself this suspicious could end up hurting the town?
 

myusername22

A username.
Donor
Joined
Dec 17, 2012
Messages
858
Reaction score
937
Weren't you baiting though
yes, absolutely. It can be helpful to start getting the day going and help getting reads on people, but overbaiting can easily hurt the town. I don't buy Hunters arguments for a second, essentially he's just putting out as much there against alpha, or whoever he really can put arguments out against, and then when he's being called scummy for it just saying "I'm just trying to find scum" It can't really work that way with this much confusion if the town wants any chance of finding scum.
 

myusername22

A username.
Donor
Joined
Dec 17, 2012
Messages
858
Reaction score
937
i refuse to answer questions made in bold as you're pulling that role you claimed earlier again
also you could be a role based on people answering questions
alright so I don't believe any argument you've made for a second, nor do i necessarily believe you've believed all the arguments you've made. You're arguments are unfounded and you're essentially just trying to say "I'm just trying to find scum" after maliciously throwing the town into chaos. I'm confident you aren't a power role because you wouldn't play like this if you were and I don't really believe your town sided at this point.

the first time I placed my vote on you as a way of letting you know how suspicious I found you, but this time I'm more than prepared to lynch and I think you're the best lynch target today.

Vote Hunter27a1
 
Top