TBD [Status: GAME OVER]

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
well you hardclaimed alien, which was...unexpected.
Which is why I don't believe Alpha's claim one second!
I imagine we're all some sort of pr.
Ltin says we may all be a power role? He must be a power role! Lynch him quickly before he gets to use whatever power he has!

Oh and I'm not in a room or have a weapon/item/something or other trinket.
But what if I'm lying? o3o

Duffie so snazzy and fashionable that picture. Very crisp. I approve.

...
Anyways!
I do agree on the Hunter blowing things up and causing a bit of a ruckus. It's a bit much, hard to follow (I basically just went through basically 5 pages of just Hunter/Defiant back and forth over whether or not Alpha was alien which was a random hard-claim anyways, and was even done rather nonchalantly at that! Now how are we supposed to believe something on the first day now?)

From all the back and forth I don't know whether to believe Hunter was serious that voting Alpha is the best option. Or whether to believe anything Defiant's saying. I'm certainly not believing anything Alpha's saying at the moment.

Everything everyone's said for the last 8 pages (maybe except for Caff and the people who havent really posted much) I don't trust. Everyone seems to have an agenda they're vying for and pushing for, and so it seems like people are already putting whatever plans they have this game into motion.

Who's to say this giant ruckus over Aloha just some giant conspiracy between Hunts,Defs, and Alphs? Maybe its just a random bandwagon and Alpha really is evil and they'll seem like heroes in the end. But then again everyone seems to be changing their minds constantly these last few pages so probably not...
Maybe myuser is the mastermind!
No one would suspect it! A sentient username! Scheming to rule the world!
...

But seriously my only concrete opinion at the moment is I feel that Hunter, Defiant, and Aloha all seem to have some kind of plan or agenda they're trying to push from these last few pages, and at the moment the chaos being thrown around is probably the only thing to be really suspicious about.
Because of that I'm voting Hunt--
No I still think No Lynching is the best case scenario day zero.
So...
Vote No Lynch.
(This was totally a coherent post, I swear)
 

Alisha

Member
Mafia Host
Mafia Mod
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
805
Reaction score
2,829
I'm still being consistent, so you can trust me to be consistently honest/dishonest.

Right now I'm seriously thinking someone doesn't like my probes, the votes happened after I told Defiant I had probes. Sounds like someone is here to counteract me.

I'm also calling out Hunter/Defiant as the most prominent/consistent pairing, no matter how much they may not like it. They've been on the same side almost this entire time. What worries me is that they're also directing the show, too.

NOT ALOHA AGAIN I CANNOT ESCAPE THE NICKNAME, HALP
 

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
where did ltin say that? :o and why do you trust Caff in particular?

hawaii illumnati confirmed
Page 5 if you must know. I was mostly making a joke of it though.

And I never said Caff in particular, I said:
maybe except for Caff and the people who havent really posted much)
Which really isn't much considering this is the first day and not very many people have weighed anything.
 

Duffie

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,880
Reaction score
5,077
So, I'll just throw in some hypotheticals, for the sake of science.

What if Alpha102 is a Jester?

What if Alpha102 is a role similar to that of an Alien, but not quite one?

What if none of the roles are official roles, not pertaining to qualities to that which we are used to?

What if Alpha102 actually isn't an Alien, and Hunter27a1 or Defiant_Blob are actually the real Alien?

What if Hunter27a1 and/or Defiant_Blob knows something we don't?

Also, just a heads up for people still using wikis and such for support, remember;




And now, let's just question some things all together.

Why did Alpha102 claim so quickly?

Why has Hunter74a1 made little to no accusations toward Defiant_Blob?

Are there really no items or hotel rooms in this match?

Aaaaand I can't think of anything else, and I'm tired, so I'll just stay mysterious and questionable for absolutely no reason whatsoever.

Have fuuuun.
(>Expects triple the current pages when I get back.)
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,629
Reaction score
3,021
So, I'll just throw in some hypotheticals, for the sake of science.

What if Alpha102 is a Jester?

What if Alpha102 is a role similar to that of an Alien, but not quite one?

What if none of the roles are official roles, not pertaining to qualities to that which we are used to?

What if Alpha102 actually isn't an Alien, and Hunter27a1 or Defiant_Blob are actually the real Alien?

What if Hunter27a1 and/or Defiant_Blob knows something we don't?

Also, just a heads up for people still using wikis and such for support, remember;




And now, let's just question some things all together.

Why did Alpha102 claim so quickly?

Why has Hunter74a1 made little to no accusations toward Defiant_Blob?

Are there really no items or hotel rooms in this match?

Aaaaand I can't think of anything else, and I'm tired, so I'll just stay mysterious and questionable for absolutely no reason whatsoever.

Have fuuuun.
(>Expects triple the current pages when I get back.)
gmk said no jesters allowed
 

Samlen

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Nov 1, 2012
Messages
187
Reaction score
353
I haven't seen much of anything that feels like much of an incredible lead, only to note that there a few considerably more vocal people so far, so they're probably have some goal they actively want to pursue... or they are just slightly more active. That alien claim felt... too sudden imo. I'll try more thoughts later.
 

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
so this confirms duffie as having an "unusual role"
thoughts
No real thoughts.
We know this is a possibility that this could happen in any Mafia game.
GmK even stated this(somewhat, I feel like it's implied) in the sign-up thread:
You should be aware of the potential roles that can come up during a game (from prior knowledge of playing Mafia), and still be open to the possibility of roles you have never heard of.
Although it doesn't necessarily confirm anything mind you.
Just like the quote i pointed out with Ltin
 

Duffie

Member
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,880
Reaction score
5,077
gmk said no jesters allowed
Maybe he lied.

so this confirms duffie as having an "unusual role"
thoughts
I think it's rather unusual.

the general conclusion seems to be alpha is suspicious either way
may as well get it over with and lynch him
If Alpha is suspicious, then I'd say you fit the bill nicely.

you made a post about how we were suspect. lynching him could confirm or deny your suspicions
So could lynching you.
 

Hunter

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
2,629
Reaction score
3,021
Maybe he lied.


I think it's rather unusual.


If Alpha is suspicious, then I'd say you fit the bill nicely.


So could lynching you.
why would the host lie. if anything, duffie is causing the most chaos with these implications.
is there a reason you are tunneling me in particular over an alien claim

and now your role is said to be unusual by yourself. interesting. unusual in a good way?
 

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
you made a post about how we were suspect. lynching him could confirm or deny your suspicions
Not really, since you were only addressing Alpha in particular.
Why only Alpha. Why not Defiant, the other person partaking in that lengthy discussion with you and Alpha?

Lynching Alpha doesn't really prove anything.
Sure it could hint of possible involvement between you 3, but frankly that's hardly anything to go on at this point.
Really pairing anyone into groups at this point is a tad silly.
But in the end lynching Alpha only proves whether or not his claims of Alien were true or not, and whether we shouldve trusted you and Defiant in possibly lynching him off, which at the moment feels weak.
 
Top