TBD [Status: GAME OVER]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
Very well, this is a valid argument. I still don't like the fact you aren't even trying to read into the people agreeing with you so far.
To be honest, I agree that Ltin naturally sounds scummy. The way he joined In after my first vote on you with only a tiny bit of suspicion was very suspect. Not to mention it does look like he was a bit too fast to agree with me. Often times mafia will try to "team" with innocents to give them a false sense of security. Ltins first vote makes it look like a possible first time mafia.
Why would they know a mafiaoso from the beginning? Wouldn't they be kept in the dark until the target dies along with the town?
It really depends on how the lyncher works, and I'm less inclined to agree with anybody being a cookie-cutter epicmafia role. Even I don't have to get all of the players probed to win, and the players don't know they were probed. There's also the amnesia aspect at play that I want Notty to shed some light on...
What you said about Duffie appearing out of nowhere does give you some credibility to that theory, Hunter. But I won't go along with assuming you're automatically pro-town because of it.
I'm a bit concerned with the name+role theory, it may be PM mechanics but I'm not sure.
this sounds like a pyro type role in which half+ of town must be doused in gasoline. my policy is to never let third party role (whether claimed or proven) be alive as it's not good strategy.
considering this particular forums lax attitude regarding third party roles, anyone can hide behind that.
e.g. duffie in hawaii, notty in masquerade, road in SCP, and probably more
The idea was never to let me live to the end of the game. I'm well aware of the stigma against third parties.
However taking advantage of the no lynch and killing me the next day instead of random lynching a possible towny is the safe option, which you seem to be going back and forth on whether you want to follow through on that or not.
I can't really comment on the pyro thing since I've already made my case that it's only half, and it's pretty clear you won't ever completely trust me, as you keep bringing up new ways that I'm possibly a huge threat.
I'm also pretty sure anti-town considers me a threat, so you might get lucky and I'll be dealt with in the night. If I live, great, you're still able to lynch me. If I don't live, then you still win as a towny didn't die and can focus on other leads. Either way town benefits from this deal.
However taking advantage of the no lynch and killing me the next day instead of random lynching a possible towny is the safe option, which you seem to be going back and forth on whether you want to follow through on that or not.
I can't really comment on the pyro thing since I've already made my case that it's only half, and it's pretty clear you won't ever completely trust me, as you keep bringing up new ways that I'm possibly a huge threat.
I'm also pretty sure anti-town considers me a threat, so you might get lucky and I'll be dealt with in the night. If I live, great, you're still able to lynch me. If I don't live, then you still win as a towny didn't die and can focus on other leads. Either way town benefits from this deal.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
*In response to Alpha since quoting on phone takes too long*
Do note that i said Amnesia and not amnesiac. And yes the rest of the claim was obviously fake. The Amnesia part was *what I assume* the same as what you meant when you said it.
Do note that i said Amnesia and not amnesiac. And yes the rest of the claim was obviously fake. The Amnesia part was *what I assume* the same as what you meant when you said it.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Plsnolynchme.That means you're as dangerous as I am
I still think we should lynch Hunter. Because of the lie-detector thing and also because he's being inconsistend with his words. He said his "policy" is to never let a third party role live and one post later he decodes to let Alpha live and vote no-lynch with a bad argument.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
So... out of all the suspicions you've had so far and have voiced very loudly, there's actually not a single one you feel like lynching? Seems a little peculiar to me.
As for Duffie being a possible Lyncher, I don't think it's the right time yet to make such a conclusion. Yes, he's playing differently from what he's usually been doing, and I agree that the role that he has might be unusual, if not completely new and something that GmK came up with specifically for this game, but assuming that he's a Lyncher when he's made like... four or five posts in total, and all those posts have been discussing a person that has been very loud and confusing so far... I don't know, seems to me like you're seeing ghosts where there aren't any.
The point about most of your suspicions being against people that have disagreed with you also holds some merit, although with the way you've played, that means almost everyone who has made more than two posts at all and your playstyle does also make you see a suspect in everyone that catches your eye, so I'm not sure if we should read into that too much.
What's done is done at this point, so there are no unfair advantages at play. However it means I have a few questions for GmK when I arrive at the Dead People's Club.Plsnolynchme.
I still think we should lynch Hunter. Because of the lie-detector thing and also because he's being inconsistend with his words. He said his "policy" is to never let a third party role live and one post later he decodes to let Alpha live and vote no-lynch with a bad argument.
Hunter is really surprising me this game, with a flip flop between thinking I'm okay and not wanting any third parties around as loose ends. It's borderline tunneling at this point. I didn't expect such vast changes in opinion from him so early in the game.
Fruit
Brrraaaaaiiiinnnnsss
Finally... Caught... Up...
I'm not going to post much right now. Need to still take all of this in. Plus I have stuff to do for the Holidays.
Alright, now, I am... very... confused. But I'm not sure confused is that right word. Surprised might be a little better.
To answer some older questions:
I'm not in a room nor do I have any items.
Alright, because this appears to be a thing:
Do you have Amnesia?
I for one don't.
And notty:
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 244, 229)]*In response to Alpha since quoting on phone takes too long*[/BCOLOR]
Let me rephrase that. Obviously, I don't think you claimed cop. So I mean I guess that counts as being fake. But, what I'm trying to say is that, it's odd. A lot of people's play styles are odd this game.
Like I said, right now, I'm confused/surprised (idk... surfused?) I still need to take this all in.
Now onto this whole Alpha situation:
It seems very odd for Alpha to claim so early on. I feel like he could have explained better that he said amnesia, not amnesiac, instead of hastily jumping to claim. Sure, he was pressured by Defiant, but claiming third party like that on the first day, again, seems very odd.
Argh, more posts as I type this.
After the Holidays, I should be able to come up with more. As of right now, I have three FoS's:
Hunter
Notty
Alpha
Please answer that Amnesia question. It's confusing, and I don't know what it is.
and it makes me pair Notty and Alpha together.
I'm not going to post much right now. Need to still take all of this in. Plus I have stuff to do for the Holidays.
Alright, now, I am... very... confused. But I'm not sure confused is that right word. Surprised might be a little better.
To answer some older questions:
I'm not in a room nor do I have any items.
Alright, because this appears to be a thing:
Do you have Amnesia?
I for one don't.
And notty:
[BCOLOR=rgb(255, 244, 229)]*In response to Alpha since quoting on phone takes too long*[/BCOLOR]
I didn't get fake from that at all. I think 14 pages of discussion is enough to tell that maybe jokes are not really a good idea right now. All that claim did was throw me even more off track than I already was.
Let me rephrase that. Obviously, I don't think you claimed cop. So I mean I guess that counts as being fake. But, what I'm trying to say is that, it's odd. A lot of people's play styles are odd this game.
Like I said, right now, I'm confused/surprised (idk... surfused?) I still need to take this all in.
Now onto this whole Alpha situation:
It seems very odd for Alpha to claim so early on. I feel like he could have explained better that he said amnesia, not amnesiac, instead of hastily jumping to claim. Sure, he was pressured by Defiant, but claiming third party like that on the first day, again, seems very odd.
Argh, more posts as I type this.
I did notice that. Some of the things he's done before this, I've come to... expect with his play style. But this was off.Plsnolynchme.
I still think we should lynch Hunter. Because of the lie-detector thing and also because he's being inconsistend with his words. He said his "policy" is to never let a third party role live and one post later he decodes to let Alpha live and vote no-lynch with a bad argument.
After the Holidays, I should be able to come up with more. As of right now, I have three FoS's:
Hunter
Notty
Alpha
Please answer that Amnesia question. It's confusing, and I don't know what it is.
and it makes me pair Notty and Alpha together.
I don't know entirely what's going on with the amnesia thing either, but I have an idea and don't want to share all of it in case of PM mechanics or giving too much away.
However, just like I look incredibly dangerous right now, we need to watch Notty very closely as well. Please don't forget this if I die.
However, just like I look incredibly dangerous right now, we need to watch Notty very closely as well. Please don't forget this if I die.
nah i just doubt town will actually end up lynching you. still would rather you be dead, if only for the third party claim. i don't want you to use an action that may affect the rest of the game in a detrimental way, as you might be a one-shot thing
also how can people not understand that third party claims are only useful to use near endgame when town is forced to prioritize mafia lynches over thirdparty lynches
and the nolynch vote was due to "leaving soon" and not wanting the day to drag on when my vote could end it earlier
also what inhuman thing is this another hint because one entire post for a joke is not necessary
watch there be a group or faction consisting of extraterrestrials
unvote
vote alpha102
It's an 'unnecessary' comic book joke, and I won't let your reaction dictate how I post.
I would say it's quite the opposite actually, we shouldn't be forced into prioritizing mafia lynches over third party lynches. Why not get a head start and not end up in that sad situation?
I would say it's quite the opposite actually, we shouldn't be forced into prioritizing mafia lynches over third party lynches. Why not get a head start and not end up in that sad situation?
I do indeed have amnesia. Or at least, did.
FINALLY CAUGHT UP.
My biggest FoS is Hunter.
I don't see or feel the need to get rid of Alpha.
Other people exist, too.
I'm going to do Christmas stuff now. I'll be checking throughout the day, but don't expect me to post.
Before anyone [/size=1]Hunter >->[/size] says "ELABORATE YOU FUCK" ...I'll elaborate later I just read 14 pages of crap.
FINALLY CAUGHT UP.
My biggest FoS is Hunter.
I don't see or feel the need to get rid of Alpha.
Other people exist, too.
I'm going to do Christmas stuff now. I'll be checking throughout the day, but don't expect me to post.
Before anyone [/size=1]Hunter >->[/size] says "ELABORATE YOU FUCK" ...I'll elaborate later I just read 14 pages of crap.
Because you're arguments are pretty unreasonable and your scummy as heck?