Ok, discussion started moving fast in the middle of what I was typing so down the drain goes that post. IN ORDER.
I do not have a name, nor do I have anything else relevant to share. I don't think the name thing was meant to be taken seriously. The cop thing, however...
I don't understand this Notty business with claiming cop as a joke, then retracting the joke and claiming it's for some sort of plan. I think some more interrogation is at hand, with less obtuse answers.
I'm not leading the discussion, Hunter, I can barely lead my own post in a non-rambly direction. All this wild speculation is not my thing. Also 1:40am as of writing.
This discussion going on right now seems to be between Ltin and Hunter, so I'm gonna stay out of that... And I don't have any comments on the doctor claim except wtf at the moment.
CAN I GO TO BED NOW PLEASE?
Also where I'm from egging and edging both work for that expression.
Not a doc claim, just a chance for a bad pun. Patients? Patience? Eh? Flew right over all your heads. Probably gonna be killed this night for it. Eh. Let 'em waste their time.
Can you tell I'm tired?
I just waded through pages of back and forth strange conversations.
Something something eggs and patience, usernames and hunters.
What even is going on anymore. Will type out an actual response soon.~
(This is the first comment about the loaded questions I saw so I just grabbed it, so I'm just referring to the topic in general here)
I frankly don't really see the big deal about the loaded questions or whether they're biased or not. Who cares? A lot of the time questions are biased(though not always, though they tend to be more generalized), I mean a lot of them so far seem to be so. They're asking a question for a certain situation, and thus an agenda to see what people think on the matter, and thus myuser wanted to know what people were thinking in terms of what he wanted to know about.
I... basically agreed through my ratings with what Notty said:
It didn't influence my answer, and I doubt it influenced yours. Only someone that hasn't been paying attention to whats going on at all will get influenced. And that's their own fault for not reading about the events themselves I guess.
(Here's my answers by way since I guess I haven't done those yet):
Is Hunter changing his playstyle in favour of a No Lynch? I don't know. Isn't this always his playstyle? From my experience Hunter posts a lot, certainly in a bit of a confusing manner, though they don't necessarily have any substance (all in my opinion of course). Just because someone No Lynches doesn't necessarily mean their "playstyle" is changed. This question doesn't really ask what my opinions are on Hunter though. Was myusername defending Alpha and if he was, what of it? I don't recal much of that since I read it on mobile. I'll have to read back on that. From what I can recall however, sure, I guess you could say user was sort of defending Alpha. But then again, I've never necessarily put much weight in arguments involving "scumbuddies" unless there was good/obvious evidence, so I didn't put much thought into this situation.
Who is the most suspicious person to you right now? Shouldn't everyone be the most suspicious? And when I say that, isn't everyone NOT suspicious?
It's Day Zero, still slightly around X-Mas/Boxing Day/New Years/All the other holidays, and we haven't made that much progress outside of somewhat dubious claims, and a bunch of back-and-forth arguing.
I could say I'm watching those who have claimed, as anyone should, and I guess those would be the most suspicious.
I could also say I don't necessarily like how Hunter's playing, which could lead to me being suspicious, but that's really not a good reason. Who is the least suspicious person to you right now? How should I know, it's the first game day. Nothing's "really"(night actions I mean) happened, and outside of those who have claimed, everyone else has still remained somewhat in the same stance frankly. Why are these people least/most suspicious? Well the reasons have already been brought up, right?
-Alpha and Notty both could be deemed suspicious due to their claims, and in my opinion, how fake they appeared, but so far we have no evidence to prove either of their claims validity, and so it's best we simply be wary of them for now.
-Duffie "kinda" claimed, Hunter's basically trying to randomly force out the claim (despite saying we're just giving the Mafia more stuff against us, which is a tad weird in my opinion), so I guess for now Duffie's "kind-of-but-not-really-but-also-possibly Survivor-esq mechanic role or something because it hasn't really been explained. Same situation as Notty/Alpha.
-Yada Yada etc.
Your arguments have strawmen all over. What he said wasn't that we should keep liars alive because they are liars, what he said (or at least that's the impression I'm getting, and that's definitely the way I see things), was that we don't really have any idea whether Alpha is scum or not, since his claim felt so off that it seemed like it was intentionally made to be very flawed. That would mean that we have almost no way of telling if he's Alien or townie or mafia or whatever in this game, for all we know.
Uh I don't know what to think in terms of Ltin.
I know he said the doctor claim was to make a pun but it's really random at the same time. Plus, you are kind of getting a bit crazy when talking to Hunter, so I'm not sure what to think of you. x)
Uh I'm going to reread cause that's all I remember~
TTFN, Tata for now~