TBD [Status: GAME OVER]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Look, Duffie, I understand that you want Alpha to live since your role requires it (as far as I've figured, if I'm wrong again on this, feel free to correct me), but the rest of us have to look at it from another perspective. You or Alpha are the town's safest bet and since we can't turn the votes around any more and since Alpha's claim was so much more suspicious than yours, the logical thing to do would be to lynch Alpha, and that's exactly what we're gonna do.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
inb4 GmK is a bastard mod
Holy shit would that be fun, GmK as a bastard mod
Lee, Ltin is correct. GmK did state that any Fool or Jester like roles aren't in the game. It's either in the OP or the sign up thread.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Guys you are obviously not seeing that hunter is manipulating all of you while being the scummies one himself.
Remember when we were all voting him and he had to claim? Yes I rememeber. Since I went to sleep when Alpha wasn't this close to being lynched. He claimed the townsman of information and then continued to tell everyone that this town sucks and we're making a horrible mistake and then throw around crazy theories as usual blablabla. I'm pretty sure he just tried to confuse everyone into unvoting and it worked for sure.
Then only a few pages later Hunter outright refused to lynch a possible Mafia over a Third Party. I got it right here:
If you think Duffie is paparazzi why are you not voting for her? By saying Duffie is Paparazzi you stated that she has a higher chance to be Mafia than Alpha. Yet you go for Alpha because... logic? No.
Then following to that as usual, Hunter is trying to stop discussion and mind-control people as he told Digitalmez to "Skip pages 18-48 and only read his post on what happened". On the subject of loaded questions how about loaded posts? Because Hunter is certainly trying to influence Digi here.
And not pages before saying this he is complaining that this town is terrible and blablablabla. Telling people to not read anything certainly results in a terrible town as nobody will know wtf is going on since they didnt read 30 pages. So again, Hunter is trying to stop the town from being useful.
And people's argument for voting even turned into this:
And then there is Lee saying that "it doesn't matter if Hunter is scummy we're not talking about Hunter we're talking about Alpha blablabla". It does matter. If Hunter is Mafia, which you obviously seem to think a bit since otherwise you would say we have to ignore Hunter being Mafia since this is about Alpha, then why would Hunter vote his own teammate? Alpha has such a low chance of being Mafia while Hunter has been acting scummy all game. And again your goal as town isn't to exterminate all Third Parties. Please tell me you're not all ignoring the fact that our goal is to hunt Mafia and not Third Parties.
If you want to talk about a safe option, go for a No-Lynch. Because lynching Alpha isn't safe as we'll still lose one of our numbers against the Mafia. Don't go telling everyone it's the safest option because it's not and Hunter is 90x times more likely to be Mafia than Alpha is.
unvote
vote Hunter27a1
Remember when we were all voting him and he had to claim? Yes I rememeber. Since I went to sleep when Alpha wasn't this close to being lynched. He claimed the townsman of information and then continued to tell everyone that this town sucks and we're making a horrible mistake and then throw around crazy theories as usual blablabla. I'm pretty sure he just tried to confuse everyone into unvoting and it worked for sure.
Then only a few pages later Hunter outright refused to lynch a possible Mafia over a Third Party. I got it right here:
Let me explain the role Paparazzi to you:
When lynched, can choose one person to reveal.
The person revealed will be visible only to the mafia.
Sided with the mafia.
The person revealed will be visible only to the mafia.
Sided with the mafia.
Then following to that as usual, Hunter is trying to stop discussion and mind-control people as he told Digitalmez to "Skip pages 18-48 and only read his post on what happened". On the subject of loaded questions how about loaded posts? Because Hunter is certainly trying to influence Digi here.
And not pages before saying this he is complaining that this town is terrible and blablablabla. Telling people to not read anything certainly results in a terrible town as nobody will know wtf is going on since they didnt read 30 pages. So again, Hunter is trying to stop the town from being useful.
And people's argument for voting even turned into this:
Yes, because the deadline is close we should ignore all evidence on Hunter and instead lynch someone that will have 0 benifit when it will turn out he was the Alien. Congratulations you all not using logic at this point at all.
And then there is Lee saying that "it doesn't matter if Hunter is scummy we're not talking about Hunter we're talking about Alpha blablabla". It does matter. If Hunter is Mafia, which you obviously seem to think a bit since otherwise you would say we have to ignore Hunter being Mafia since this is about Alpha, then why would Hunter vote his own teammate? Alpha has such a low chance of being Mafia while Hunter has been acting scummy all game. And again your goal as town isn't to exterminate all Third Parties. Please tell me you're not all ignoring the fact that our goal is to hunt Mafia and not Third Parties.
If you want to talk about a safe option, go for a No-Lynch. Because lynching Alpha isn't safe as we'll still lose one of our numbers against the Mafia. Don't go telling everyone it's the safest option because it's not and Hunter is 90x times more likely to be Mafia than Alpha is.
unvote
vote Hunter27a1
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Also should I mention that by lynching Alpha, you're also gonna have to lynch me and Duffie? And after you're done with lynching 3 Third Parties the Mafia will have greatly outnumbered you and you'll lose. Why? Because you didn't actually try to lynch any Mafia.
I know, but I was hoping someone, anyone, would vote me instead of Alpha. It still feels silly voting for either me or Alpha, as I still don't find Hunter believable one bit, but do what you must.
As I've stated, I'm still someone on the sidelines, simply watching the game. I'm just trying to rig the horse races in my favor, but alas, it's not as easy as people make it.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Also I'd like to point out that Coolio's vote seems like a total Mafia vote. She voted Hunter while he was almost on the brink of being Lynched probabily to look like town, and now that the bandwagon on Alpha is on she doesn't have to lynch her fellow Mafia member and can lynch someone else. Thus she voted Alpha.
That's a thing for another day I guess, but just pointing it out right now.
Also rip town.
That's a thing for another day I guess, but just pointing it out right now.
Also rip town.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Also notice how Hunter only has 3 Third Party votes on him and one JKangaroo? [also to point out JK is the man of logic and surely knows what hes doing].
Would a town member with these abilities really be left alone so easely by the Mafia? I think not. Everyone could of stayed on Hunter, not believing him, but instead they all went to Alpha because Hunter is Mafia himself.
Would a town member with these abilities really be left alone so easely by the Mafia? I think not. Everyone could of stayed on Hunter, not believing him, but instead they all went to Alpha because Hunter is Mafia himself.
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
Hunter is too erratic to be able to manipulate anyone. I don't think he thinks things through at all and because of this, ends up posting pages of worthless posts with very little insight into his own thinking. While I'm always hoping that it will one day change and he will start posting in a more calm and collected manner, and actually start expressing his own thoughts as well, instead of always asking others for theirs and jumping to a new question before the one before that one is answered, then we all know that it will not happen, at least not now.
Hunter has no evidence on him. None. Zero. 404, evidence not found. If you're the cop, why don't you visit him at night and get a read, huh? Then you can talk to me about evidence. Of course, considering how you claim third party, we can't really trust you to give us any valid evidence, since whatever Hunter is, he's clearly in your way, otherwise you wouldn't go after him, being the third party you are.
Speaking of you, Notty, considering how you claim third party cop, which is hella unlikely on it's own, what exactly is your win condition? And no, I don't want to hear "To eliminate all threats to the town", because then you wouldn't be third party, would you?
Going back to the subject of Hunter/Alpha, Hunter has a higher chance of being town than Alpha does. First off, he actually claimed town. An important town PR, no less. While the claim may be utter bullshit, then do you really wanna risk it because the way someone plays, the way someone has always played, is scummy to you? I'm not speaking to you, Notty, since you've made it clear you have other intentions than to help town in this game, but I'm speaking to all the others that either haven't voted yet, are voting No Lynch or Hunter. Let me make this very clear to all of you:
Would you rather lynch
a) Someone that has been playing in an annoying and contradicting way, because he doesn't think at all, but has a considerable chance of being a very important town PR
or
b) Someone that claimed in a suspicious manner, claimed third party of all the things and has himself admitted that his death wouldn't have much of an impact on the outcome of the game for the rest of us?
Or to make it even easier
Leaving aside everything else, would you rather lynch a town PR claim or an Alien claim? It's not that bloody hard, people.
Also, Notty, I'd like to ask you, are you more interested in getting Hunter lynched or preventing Alpha from being lynched?
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
What do you propose we do then?
No need to answer, I'll your answer for you.
->implying there is a vigilante.
Ofcourse you lynch the paparazzi. Thats one Mafia member down instead of wasting our lynch on a Third Party. Sigh nobody wants to lynch Mafia here >.<