TBD [Status: GAME OVER]
- Thread starter GmK
- Start date
Ooglie101 why did you select Coolio to use a knife on last night? I don't understand why the knife would do nothing, the fake investigation module gave a false report.. what would be the point of an item that only gave the illusion of a choice? Did you do a dance last night?
Okay, do you have anything to gain from more claims?
So discussion's not going anywhere I see. As a proposition, I suggest we ALL take Ender's lead in providing a bit of our own thoughts on the people that are currently alive in the game. Might not be the most productive discussion, but we may be able to see something in the way people think of others, or it will spark up some other discussion.
77 - Hard to know what roleclaims to believe, but 77 is not suspicious enough yet for me to risk loosing a valuable claim like his by lynching him. Actions do depict a somewhat typical "just trying to keep myself alive" vibe, so I can believe that he's the third-party he claims to be.
Coolio - "Classic Coolio" bugs me, but apparently noone else seems to find her suspicious, and I can't of anything other than just quiet...
Jolt - Nothing incredibly noticeable, but I wonder why he wants someone else to claim for no apparent reason, just so that he can claim for little to no apparent reason. Says it's for discussion, but I'm sure there's better ways to create discussions without forcing potential useful roles to out themselves
Ender - Notty was indeed a cop, so Ender is quite likely innocent (Godfather or Lawyers could come into question here, but I'm ignoring them for now). Seems more active than a lot of people, and playstyle does seem to indicate town-sided this game, so I'm mostly comfortable with saying that Notty's report wasn't messed with and that he is innocent.
Samlen - Hullos, I haven't been as active as I would have liked, but I'm trying.
Road - What he says and how he plays makes me think that either he knows more about the cult than we do(i.e. a cultist himself), or that he is making assumptions (dangerous for us since nothing is ever certain in mafia, especially in a game like this one). Keeping an eye on him for now, and though I am not sure if I would be willing to lynch him right now, I would certainly prefer if we could get some confirmation on him from 77
Ooglie - Claimed dancer and can dance a different dance each night, just not the same consecutively. Used a fake knife and is paralyzed for tonight. Also claims town-sided. His role has a bit of bleeder (Jazz dance), rough sleeper (Tango), and roleblocking (Ballet) which are all interesting. I can't say he's suspicious enough for me to want lynch him, but I do'nt have any grounds either to believe his claim yet.
Caffeina - I'm not completely sure on her roleclaim, was it strictly just doctor, or doctor and roleblock at the same time? My only interest is the fact that a doctor claim has not died yet, but I think I will look into this later instead of right now, for I would rather not lynch a possible doctor with so anti-town members dead.
Jkang - Interesting claim. Could be true, since we have a lot of third-party people and a cult that is third-party, but this also means he could quite easily side the cult since he wants third-parties alive. Will probably be dangerous once the cult gets larger since he could/probably would side with them, but I think the lack of dead mafia is slightly more concerning right now.
Fruit - Claimed "Sexy Survivor" I believe. Another third-party claim, though a simple one at least. Certainly is trying hard to not be noticed, but that could be indicative of anyone not strictly town-sided. If he is a survivor, could side with the cult or mafia in later game, so I'll be making note of what he does (if he does anything other than being quiet...)
Mad11gab - Lie detector claim, seems believable enough for now (especially since we haven't seemed to have a lot of investigative power on our side this game...). Claims town-sided and that her lie detecting has revealed someone likely to be town, though this person is currently a secret (unless likely to be lynched)
Defiant - I don't know why, but I feel like I'm drawing more of a blank here than most other people =S I guess he just has not stood out as suspicious to me, so I haven't really thought about him much at all... I'll need to remind myself to look at him a bit so I can get a better idea of what to think about him.
catgirl - The vague references to her claim sound similar to a rough sleeper, but hints at more to her claim. Seems a little sketchy, and has been pretty quiet this whole game, but not much else to say here.
77 - Hard to know what roleclaims to believe, but 77 is not suspicious enough yet for me to risk loosing a valuable claim like his by lynching him. Actions do depict a somewhat typical "just trying to keep myself alive" vibe, so I can believe that he's the third-party he claims to be.
Coolio - "Classic Coolio" bugs me, but apparently noone else seems to find her suspicious, and I can't of anything other than just quiet...
Jolt - Nothing incredibly noticeable, but I wonder why he wants someone else to claim for no apparent reason, just so that he can claim for little to no apparent reason. Says it's for discussion, but I'm sure there's better ways to create discussions without forcing potential useful roles to out themselves
Ender - Notty was indeed a cop, so Ender is quite likely innocent (Godfather or Lawyers could come into question here, but I'm ignoring them for now). Seems more active than a lot of people, and playstyle does seem to indicate town-sided this game, so I'm mostly comfortable with saying that Notty's report wasn't messed with and that he is innocent.
Samlen - Hullos, I haven't been as active as I would have liked, but I'm trying.
Road - What he says and how he plays makes me think that either he knows more about the cult than we do(i.e. a cultist himself), or that he is making assumptions (dangerous for us since nothing is ever certain in mafia, especially in a game like this one). Keeping an eye on him for now, and though I am not sure if I would be willing to lynch him right now, I would certainly prefer if we could get some confirmation on him from 77
Ooglie - Claimed dancer and can dance a different dance each night, just not the same consecutively. Used a fake knife and is paralyzed for tonight. Also claims town-sided. His role has a bit of bleeder (Jazz dance), rough sleeper (Tango), and roleblocking (Ballet) which are all interesting. I can't say he's suspicious enough for me to want lynch him, but I do'nt have any grounds either to believe his claim yet.
Caffeina - I'm not completely sure on her roleclaim, was it strictly just doctor, or doctor and roleblock at the same time? My only interest is the fact that a doctor claim has not died yet, but I think I will look into this later instead of right now, for I would rather not lynch a possible doctor with so anti-town members dead.
Jkang - Interesting claim. Could be true, since we have a lot of third-party people and a cult that is third-party, but this also means he could quite easily side the cult since he wants third-parties alive. Will probably be dangerous once the cult gets larger since he could/probably would side with them, but I think the lack of dead mafia is slightly more concerning right now.
Fruit - Claimed "Sexy Survivor" I believe. Another third-party claim, though a simple one at least. Certainly is trying hard to not be noticed, but that could be indicative of anyone not strictly town-sided. If he is a survivor, could side with the cult or mafia in later game, so I'll be making note of what he does (if he does anything other than being quiet...)
Mad11gab - Lie detector claim, seems believable enough for now (especially since we haven't seemed to have a lot of investigative power on our side this game...). Claims town-sided and that her lie detecting has revealed someone likely to be town, though this person is currently a secret (unless likely to be lynched)
Defiant - I don't know why, but I feel like I'm drawing more of a blank here than most other people =S I guess he just has not stood out as suspicious to me, so I haven't really thought about him much at all... I'll need to remind myself to look at him a bit so I can get a better idea of what to think about him.
catgirl - The vague references to her claim sound similar to a rough sleeper, but hints at more to her claim. Seems a little sketchy, and has been pretty quiet this whole game, but not much else to say here.
CaffeinatedKitty
Intoxicated Feline
I think the mafia don't want to go after me because they can't predict who I protect, and the night they did try to kill me they wasted it because I protected myself.
I don't roleblock people, I just keep any possible actions from affecting them(sorry to any cops if I protected someone on the same night that you tried to investigate them >~<).
I don't roleblock people, I just keep any possible actions from affecting them(sorry to any cops if I protected someone on the same night that you tried to investigate them >~<).
Well it's a happy middle ground between a full claim which as we saw last game can be devastating and simply allow mafia to pick us off at their convenience, not that I was "us" last game
. On the other hand as we've already seen totally mystery simply makes us lounge around until the dead line where we panic and try and figure out who to lynch based on little to no evidence.We could try out my idea =/ Half claiming doesn't tell us anything. Our Lie Detector can't effectively use half claims, and all it does is make you look shifty (from my point of view at least). If you are a useful role, then you probably shouldn't claim so you have no target on you. If you're third party, then why bother putting any sort of claim? I can't imagine any good reason for making part of a claim other than to 'pretend' that we are having a discussion. And Defiant, what happens if a Mafia member is smart enough to figure out your role but not most of the town? That's practically giving away information to the Mafia and keeping it away from *most* of the town. Like I said, I can see no practical reason to start claiming small parts of your role, since pretending to have a discussion is not going to get us anywhere.
Well I'm not really the sort to keep tabs on people. I will say I am finding defiant to be uncharacteristically quite. Usually he doesn't shy away from a more active role...
JKangaroo
Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Has far as I can tell, everyone has claimed at least something except for you and Sam.
- [BCOLOR=#ff6600]77_is_the_best[/BCOLOR] - Claimed Third-party; Can investigate if people are cult and prevent conversion
- Cooliorules - Unclaimed
- [BCOLOR=#ff6600]Jolteon42[/BCOLOR] - Claims third-party
- [BCOLOR=#ffff00]endersteve5[/BCOLOR] - Town or Third-party or Godfather, investigated by Notty's; is unclaimed otherwise; has one of Notty's bombs.
- Samlen - Unclaimed
- [BCOLOR=#ff6600]the road to ruins[/BCOLOR] - Claimed third-party with no night actions. Claims to be not associated with cult; used an investigation module on Notty.
- [BCOLOR=#00ff00]Ooglie101[/BCOLOR] - Claimed town; Dancer with 3 dances, alternates each night; used a "knife" last night(paralyzed)
- [BCOLOR=#00ff00]Caffeinatedkitten[/BCOLOR] - Claimed Town; prevents all night actions on X-person (like a jailer without the roleblock)
- [BCOLOR=#ff6600]JKangaroo[/BCOLOR] - Claimed Third party
- [BCOLOR=#ff6600]xXxFruitNinjaxXx[/BCOLOR] - Third party smexy Survivor
- [BCOLOR=#00ff00]Mad11gab8[/BCOLOR] - Town 3-shot Lie Detector, used twice (Notty and ___)
- [BCOLOR=#00ff00]Defiant_Blob[/BCOLOR] - Claims to be town-sided with a night power; had an investigation module used on Notty(claimed to be roleblocked)
- catgirl(numbers) - Vague claims; doesn't want townies to visit her at night. Hasn't claimed anything else as far as I know.