Anvil Base [GAME OVER]

[Samlen]

... I suppose some activity is better than none, but still, the little activity around doesn't seem to be putting much more thought into their voting than earlier. My first thoughts is that Naoh's voting pattern is interesting enough to look at, but hopefully not our largest lead for today since it's not much of a lead either. The votes on raxo feel like an excuse... we all know raxo acts like this each game, regardless of how much we pester him about it =/ There are other people that have been much less active than raxo *cough aika *cough*. To be honest, it feels like most of the votes right now are just struggling to show that they are doing 'something', which certainly does not fell very pro-town whatsoever.

Now MarsKid I don't feel like you answered me satisfactorily: Why? Why go vote yourself, why start a bandwagon on yourself, and why didn't you even try to stop it? If you are town, can you at least try not giving up that completely =D?

Anyone have any ideas right now? Any idea is better than none, considering how much people are posting right now =S

 

[Notme]

Err Unvote Marskid
So we were voting on him for lulz?

 

[cooliorules]

My fos for raxo dropped for the time being. Thinking back, he does act like this is every other game I've read.

I still have a fos for Naoh and slightly Mars. I wouldn't have joined the BW on Mars even if I knew he was town (I don't, I'm just stating that I wouldn't have) because for god sake, there has to be a reason that he voted for himself and didn't try to stop the forming bandwagon.

It could have been a clever ploy to see who would just jump on and vote with no questions asked, especially after the first one or two people. That could show people who want to just jump on and get a town person lynched?

I guess in the end we won't know until there is a reply.

Anyway the reasons for my fos's:

Naoh: He jumped on the bandwagon late on with no reasoning what so ever. Seemed more as if he just wanted Mars to be gone (implying that Naoh could be mafia and Mars town).

Mars: I guess he has to have a back story as to why he voted himself. Any sane town wouldn't do that unless they knew that they had some sort of safety barrier or something of the sorts.

Both are just light fos's and not hard enough evidence, imo, to vote for either.

Ltin, any indication as to when this day is going to end? I would like a little more discussion than what we've had in the past 24 hours or so.

 

[Ltin]

A deadline has been set for 52 hours and 30 minutes from now.

 

[Enderfive]

So we were voting on him for lulz?

Look, raxo, I don't think you're mafia- because you do play like this every game- but if you don't start thinking for yourself in Mafia, you can start counting on me voting you every single game to get you out purely because your actions do the town more harm than good. I mean absolutely no insult by saying this, but I feel like I have to be blunt to get the point across - you're not being smart at all, in fact, you're quite the opposite. Mafia is a game where you have to think to succeed, and if you don't think, it may not only screw with your own chances of winning, it might also do so with the chances of your teammates. Right now, I don't see a lot of thinking on your end.

Again, I mean no harm by saying this, but I do urge you to think about what I said.


Now, onto the actual game.

I think that at the moment, the best lead we have is Naoh's reaction to my post and the ones that followed it, the posts that point him out as a possible FoS.

First he says he thought Mars was innocent anyway and didn't really have any reason for voting him, and then promptly unvotes. Uh, okay, why'd you vote him in the first place, then? To me this seemed like a weak (in fact, too weak) attempt to find a way out of the weak accusation I had thrown in the air. I also feel that he was too quick to change his vote.

And then the next thing he does is vote the only other person (besides Mars, but he already burned that bridge) that the rest of us are finding even slightly suspicious. I have to ask here, is Naoh incapable of coming up with suspicions himself or is it just that he doesn't want to say them out loud before someone else does? Everything about Naoh is pointing to him being scum at the moment, from his bandwagoning and indecisiveness to his relative inactivity. The only thing making me question this theory is the fact that I'd expect a stronger defense from him, because at the moment, it looks way too weak, almost like he wants us to vote him out, but I don't feel like this is enough to make me unvote, especially when considering that Mars is innocent in my opinion and raxo hasn't exactly shown anything out of the ordinary (even though I wish he would).

 

[cooliorules]

You point out the fact that he has little retaliation; Mars had very little to no retaliation as well. Maybe if a couple of votes were put on he may defend?

I'm off to class so sorry if that made no sense.

 

[Naoh]

I just can't gather enough evidence to get anyone. I want to feel like someone is pushing too hard, but that may just be for activity. :I

 

[YouWould]

Well if nothing's going to happen may as well
Vote No Lyncherado

 

[Jivvi]

whatever mars did worked though.

 

[Samlen]

I'm going to point out that we can't let this inactivity continue for long... Keep in mind with our cop dead, we will need to sleuth things out ourselves, and the most we can hope for investigative-wise is maybe a soldier with a one-time use investigation. We certainly can't wait to be lucky and hope that the pirate/terrorists kill each other off, so we will need to find a good way of making everyone become a bit more active.

 

[Jivvi]

Inactivity: Yes, I'm being a hypocrite of sorts, but with school slamming me repeatedly in the last few weeks of term, I'm having trouble finding time for a lot of things. I will keep read up though, and make sure to point out things i find important or shifty.

 

[Enderfive]

Well if nothing's going to happen may as well

You want to No Lynch again?

I would somehow understand it if it was Day 0, but no lynching on the second day? How long do you plan to keep no lynching?

 

[Ltin]

VOTECOUNT ERROR: Pi.
Marskid [2] - Jivvi, Marskid [8 left to lynch]
Naoh [3] - Enderfive, The Road to Ruin, Fruit [7 left to lynch]
Raxo2222 [1] - Naoh [9 left to lynch]
No lynch [1] katman [8 left to no lynch]

With 18 players it takes 10 to lynch and 9 to no lynch.

 

[Naoh]

You want to No Lynch again?

I would somehow understand it if it was Day 0, but no lynching on the second day? How long do you plan to keep no lynching?

Why are you so eager for a lynch? We don't have much to go on besides some people's inactivity and Mars' bandwagoning. I just don't see the point in lynching someone right now, besides shooting in the dark and hoping to hit scum.

 

[Naoh]

I'm going to unvote.

 

[Enderfive]

Why are you so eager for a lynch? We don't have much to go on besides some people's inactivity and Mars' bandwagoning. I just don't see the point in lynching someone right now, besides shooting in the dark and hoping to hit scum.

We have to start lynching to have any chance of winning. You can't expect the officer council to do everything for us, can you?

 

[Naoh]

We have to start lynching to have any chance of winning. You can't expect the officer council to do everything for us, can you?

...you have a point. But who could we lynch?

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

If we could actually start some discussion we'd know ;-;

 

[Ltin]

There are 24 hours untill the deadline. The person with the most votes (or most no lynch votes) will be lynched at the end of the deadline.

 

[SparklyMuffinz]

1.)

Well if nothing's going to happen may as well
Vote No Lyncherado

You think no lynching is our best option today? Why?

2.) We've tagged MarsKid numerous times at still no response to defend himself. Sounds like he wants to just be voted out ... but maybe that's why we shouldn't do it.

3.)

Just to get some attention off Mars and onto someone who seems scummier based on voting patterns (since that's all I have time to analyze atm),

vote Naoh

I don't know if I'd necessarily vote someone to take the attention off someone else. And to vote Naoh too, who - in my opinion - has been playing the game the same as raxo. I don't know if Naoh is town or mafia or 3P but I think this is how he plays mafia too. Not to mention, he's not the only that jumped on the bandwagon to then unvote.

Well, fine.

Vote Marskid

Err Unvote Marskid
So we were voting on him for lulz?

Let's be honest, both these players just "go with the crowd". They've done it for every vote. I find both of them suspicious enough to watch but I'm not sure to actually vote yet.

4.)

I'm tempted to make another prediction but I don't want to ruin my streak, even if it is only 1.

I'd love to hear one though. ;D

 

[Mooglie]

so my motivation for this game is kinda dedded but the way raxo is behaving i find it moar suspicious than naoh so
vote raxo2222

 

[Enderfive]

...you have a point. But who could we lynch?

Well, I have an idea in that department, although I'm pretty sure you're not a fan of it.

I don't know if I'd necessarily vote someone to take the attention off someone else. And to vote Naoh too, who - in my opinion - has been playing the game the same as raxo. I don't know if Naoh is town or mafia or 3P but I think this is how he plays mafia too. Not to mention, he's not the only that jumped on the bandwagon to then unvote.

Ah, but that's the thing. I don't remember Naoh ever being like this in a mafia game. Raxo is excused for now, since I expect that from him, but not from Naoh, and I don't like that.

 

[Nottykitten]

I wouldn't have joined the BW on Mars even if I knew he was town (I don't, I'm just stating that I wouldn't have) because for god sake, there has to be a reason that he voted for himself and didn't try to stop the forming bandwagon.

I don't like the way this is worded. You wouldn't join even if you knew he was town? The wording of this is very peculiar. Sounds like a Mafia saying they didn't bandwagon Mars because they would be suspicious for it.

Vote Cooliorules

 

[SparklyMuffinz]

I don't like the way this is worded. You wouldn't join even if you knew he was town? The wording of this is very peculiar. Sounds like a Mafia saying they didn't bandwagon Mars because they would be suspicious for it.

Vote Cooliorules

I didn't even notice that the first read. After going back and rereading and understanding... that is very strange wording. Time to pull a Sparkly and find of all coolio's posts to requote!

Spoiler: cooliorules

I'll catch up in a bit, sorrryyyyyyy

English is boring so hi

Hunter can you explain why no lynch is only beneficial if we have an even number? >->
Also you should try to have everything you have to say in one post, not 100 this time

In response to Lee's RP:
'a promotion'

Tbh to me it's sounding, at the moment, that you're the agent(?) (I think that's the role)

It's just something I picked up and hey, as my job to help the town (can't be bothered to use roleplay names sorry) I may as well let all my thoughts out.

Massclaim on d0..?
Eh, not a fan to say the least

A TIMDOOD?
Idek if he's in the game but that was supposed to be a pun

And I feel as if Sparkly is trying to just help out, don't see anything suspicious there.

Hunter said: ↑
if we want to be mean we could lynch cooliorules since she's either vanilla townie or mafia 100% of the time

The sad truth..
(is it true this time though? WE'LL NEVER KNOOOWWWW)

Ehhhh I'm honestly not going to lynch anyone today most likely. I mean it's day 0 and everyone is still settling in.
I have a test at 7:55am tomorrow so don't expect me to reply until this time or a couple hours or so earlier tomorrow. o/

(Finally caught up hi)
<insert weird moment that I forgot my role>

OKAY YEP JUST READ MY PM AGAIN OOPS

Err not much input really :/

Anyway yeah I've not got enough suspicion upon anyone to vote and I don't want to vote no lynch because a lynch would be more beneficial (I can see where people come from with that, tbh)
Sooooo... I'm not gonna be voting.

My fos for raxo dropped for the time being. Thinking back, he does act like this is every other game I've read.

I still have a fos for Naoh and slightly Mars. I wouldn't have joined the BW on Mars even if I knew he was town (I don't, I'm just stating that I wouldn't have) because for god sake, there has to be a reason that he voted for himself and didn't try to stop the forming bandwagon.

It could have been a clever ploy to see who would just jump on and vote with no questions asked, especially after the first one or two people. That could show people who want to just jump on and get a town person lynched?

I guess in the end we won't know until there is a reply.

Anyway the reasons for my fos's:

Naoh: He jumped on the bandwagon late on with no reasoning what so ever. Seemed more as if he just wanted Mars to be gone (implying that Naoh could be mafia and Mars town).

Mars: I guess he has to have a back story as to why he voted himself. Any sane town wouldn't do that unless they knew that they had some sort of safety barrier or something of the sorts.

Both are just light fos's and not hard enough evidence, imo, to vote for either.

Ltin, any indication as to when this day is going to end? I would like a little more discussion than what we've had in the past 24 hours or so.

ou point out the fact that he has little retaliation; Mars had very little to no retaliation as well. Maybe if a couple of votes were put on he may defend?

I'm off to class so sorry if that made no sense.

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

...how did I miss that
Yeah, finding Coolio a bit fishy now. And from what I'm gathering she did basically claim either vanilla town or mafia, so
Vote Cooliorules