General Quarters [Game Over]
- Thread starter Ltin
- Start date
still waiting on K1ngHoward
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Oh.
Well in that case I guess I'll place my vote on who I find most likely to be mafia right now, to move the day in some kind of direction hopefully. I might unvote depending on how myuser's theory thing develops because I'm pretty interested in what he's thinking, but for now:
vote myusername22
I was with HKCaper and Unusual_dood in the general quarters, but understanding where you are going with this theory of yours myuser seems more dangerous to the town then any of the mafia who come to claim ranks. If I am coming to the same page as your theory, only town members would come out to oust their ranks and it could lead to more danger to those who do if they themselves understand your theory, myuser.
Also, we did talk about (well HK and Unusual_dood talked about) townreads and guessing each other's roles while pointing metaphorical knives at each other from separate corners as to thinking someone was a mafia. It was definitely easy to see that HKCaper was going to be the big target from the mafia with how much hype surrounded his role. I am wondering how the doctor didn't see him as the most likely candidate to be lynched in all of this. HK didn't really leave too many clues as to his role or who he was gunning for in the night or previous nights, so I can't say for certain what he was trying to do with his role block ability that could have proven Notty was mafia yesterday.
I did pose the question as to how Foggy was able to double-vote yesterday and wonder if they is just another part of his abilities with his almost jack-of-all-trades ability as being the captain.
Also, we did talk about (well HK and Unusual_dood talked about) townreads and guessing each other's roles while pointing metaphorical knives at each other from separate corners as to thinking someone was a mafia. It was definitely easy to see that HKCaper was going to be the big target from the mafia with how much hype surrounded his role. I am wondering how the doctor didn't see him as the most likely candidate to be lynched in all of this. HK didn't really leave too many clues as to his role or who he was gunning for in the night or previous nights, so I can't say for certain what he was trying to do with his role block ability that could have proven Notty was mafia yesterday.
I did pose the question as to how Foggy was able to double-vote yesterday and wonder if they is just another part of his abilities with his almost jack-of-all-trades ability as being the captain.
The simple answer: knowing who is a power role or not doesn't help us see who is mafia. The theory was a lie in hopes of getting unusual to claim information that conflicts with knowledge I already know. I have some information about his role, and I was hoping he would claim conflicting information so that I could prove he is mafia, but sadly this plan seems to have backfired as it brought all the suspicion onto me.
To some extent I've agreed with you that he's been acting slightly different, but I have mixed feelings on this because it's felt like you started calling him out on it before he even had a chance, and I feel like he's only acting slightly differently to a point where it could also just be that he's been busy and not as focused on this game.
I really don't even know where to go from here. I believe it's likely there would be at least one mafia in each room, I'm willing to guess there are 4-5 mafia, but it's hard to tell if their room is an exception because it only has 3 people. If this is the case then there are probably 2 mafia in the officers room (I am operating under the assumption he would've been in the officer room because his role was 'Executive officer' and he was ranked Commander.
I feel that with us trying to be super secretive in terms of revealing information we've also ended up in a situation that nobody is talking because they feel like they have nothing to add. I feel like the only people who are being active have a decent shot of being town (I do find unusual_dood to be slightly suspicious, but I feel that his actions haven't been crazy out of the ordinary.)
It's important that people stay active and talking, even if you have to repeat points don't just not post things because you feel others have said them or hinted at them.
Mulbery
Ooglie101
JKangaroo
Notme
Arelic
Can you guys please try to contribute a bit more? some of you I see posts from occasionally, but I'd just like to see that you guys are trying to figure things out, and I'd like to see where you stand on the issues. Anything would be appreciated, thanks.
Also, to try to keep up activity here are some questions for everyone to answer:
On a scale of 1 to 10 how suspicious is myusername22:
On a scale of 1 to 10 how suspicious is unusual_dood:
on a scale of 1 to 10 how suspicious is Infected_alien8_:
who else besides these three would you rank as suspicious?
what things did you find strange about the voting pattern in yesterday's lynch of Notty?
why?
which people are the least suspicious?
what do you think the best plans of action are for today?
who do you think we should lynch?
Who do you think the biggest lurkers are? (please put them in order of biggest lurker to smallest lurker)
who do you think are the most active right now? (please put in order of most active to people who barely post)
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
6.5/10
5.5/10
0/10 because I'm amazing and totally town!
Notme for his silence, although he's not the only one being very quiet, Mulbery for seemingly being so certain about the number of mafia we had.
The fact that there was so much resistance in the form of silence/lack of contribution. There was a guilty report on someone, and only 2 people (me and myuser) seemed to consider her claim and think about all the possibilities of it (but perhaps for different reasons), everyone else either simply voted without any more thought or just refused to speak. Now that she's turned out mafia it's very likely some of her buddies bussed her or didn't want to get involved.
Foggy, Oog. Neutral towards everyone else.
Lynch someone we find most suspicious collectively, use the information for tomorrow. If anyone has any concrete information they should come forward, unless it's too risky for whatever reason, I guess they'll be the judge of that.
Not sure. Thing is, the most suspicious person at this moment in time in my opinion is myuser, so I'm voting him, but at the same time there's a chance he's town and if he is then he's one of the more active ones so it'd suck to lynch him but I don't really see any other options other than unu, which is basically just a gut feeling, but if others are suspicious of unu too then I'd happily lynch him.
Ltin (such a lurker!)
Notme
Jkangaroo (correct me if I'm wrong but he's only made two posts - one saying how he's confused, the other voting notty right near the end of the day, which could have been a bus I guess, since he only even spoke when it looked like notty was pretty much done for)
webpaige
K1ngHoward
Arelic
Ooglie101
Mulbery
Enderfive (but he's away so)
Foggy2406
Unusual_Dood
myusername22
Infected_alien8_
Infected_alien8_ (I don't actually know if I'm most active but it feels like I'm active since I'm pretty constantly refreshing forums)/myusername22
Unusual_Dood
Foggy2406
Enderfive
Mulbery
Ooglie101
Arelic
K1ngHoward
webpaige
Jkangaroo
Notme
Ltin (lurkeeeeer)
Bolding mine
Bolding mine
Just very strange how Inf wanted to wait for everyone lurking to voice their thoughts even though he claimed to be ready to vote for Notty
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
webpaige it was very possible that someone else had information to confirm/deny someone's story. E.g. Notme could have been an investigative role also, who found HK to be mafia lawyer. Unlikely but I didn't see the harm in waiting for everyone to speak before making a decision because
Unless it got quiet and we ran out of time to lynch someone, letting a mafia member/mafia members off the hook for the day?webpaige it was very possible that someone else had information to confirm/deny someone's story. E.g. Notme could have been an investigative role also, who found HK to be mafia lawyer. Unlikely but I didn't see the harm in waiting for everyone to speak before making a decision because
On a scale of 1 to 10 how suspicious is myusername22:
7
On a scale of 1 to 10 how suspicious is unusual_dood:
6.95
on a scale of 1 to 10 how suspicious is Infected_alien8_:
8
who else besides these three would you rank as suspicious?
I don't trust Paige or Notme at this moment in time
what things did you find strange about the voting pattern in yesterday's lynch of Notty?
That not everybody voted Notty, even though my report was accurate, also Unu's unvote because of the 'lets see who bandwagons'
why?
because I am entitled to my own opinion
which people are the least suspicious?
I'm suspicious of most people... but I suppose Oog seems alright at the moment and JK in out chat seemed less suspicious than the other two
what do you think the best plans of action are for today?
I honestly think either one of Paige or Inf is mafia due to the fact Inf is still alive.... sooooo investigate them
who do you think we should lynch?
Inf or Paige, unless any other information arises
Who do you think the biggest lurkers are? (please put them in order of biggest lurker to smallest lurker)
I CBA to do a whole post but Oog and Notme lurkin in the shadows
who do you think are the most active right now? (please put in order of most active to people who barely post)
Inf, Myuser, Unu... annoyingly so with posts like 183080228308 words long
7
On a scale of 1 to 10 how suspicious is unusual_dood:
6.95
on a scale of 1 to 10 how suspicious is Infected_alien8_:
8
who else besides these three would you rank as suspicious?
I don't trust Paige or Notme at this moment in time
what things did you find strange about the voting pattern in yesterday's lynch of Notty?
That not everybody voted Notty, even though my report was accurate, also Unu's unvote because of the 'lets see who bandwagons'
why?
because I am entitled to my own opinion
which people are the least suspicious?
I'm suspicious of most people... but I suppose Oog seems alright at the moment and JK in out chat seemed less suspicious than the other two
what do you think the best plans of action are for today?
I honestly think either one of Paige or Inf is mafia due to the fact Inf is still alive.... sooooo investigate them
who do you think we should lynch?
Inf or Paige, unless any other information arises
Who do you think the biggest lurkers are? (please put them in order of biggest lurker to smallest lurker)
I CBA to do a whole post but Oog and Notme lurkin in the shadows
who do you think are the most active right now? (please put in order of most active to people who barely post)
Inf, Myuser, Unu... annoyingly so with posts like 183080228308 words long
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
There was no deadline though was there? And if there was we'd have been warned by Ltin that it was coming up, and then I'd vote to lynch. But I'm pretty sure we had plenty of time.
Yeah but most of your posts are likecan i just say that paige has been lurking more than me imoand i'll do that question thing tomorrow but it's night night for me now!
And you were rather absent when votes started happening, I only see
To which even Inf pointed out:
Why do you keep deflecting to other Moog?
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Well if Notme had confirmed HK was a lawyer then it'd mean foggy and arelic AND notty were telling the truth. It'd turn the situation into lynching HK, I don't see why it wouldn't change anything? And that's just one scenario I thought of, Notme could have said anything and been any role that Ltin made up since this is a closed setup and anything is possible.
If anything I find it a bit weird that some people voted Notty before hearing from everyone that day - the people who gave the final votes at least, such as myuser and jkang. There's no reason to rush a lynch and if there's a chance someone could bring something to the table which is a complete game-changer, then I think it's suspicious that people don't wait for everyone to speak in case something like that happens, unless there's a deadline, which there wasn't.
How likely was it that anyone lurking would have said anything useful though? I had no info, so why would I input other than to vote? Most likely we'd be waiting on nothing and waste time.
I don't see how the lynch was rushed at all honestly. Better to lynch at a reasonable pace rather than drag it out and open it up for mafia to make the situation confusing.
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Likelihood doesn't matter to me, if there's a chance we're all bandwagoning on a town PR then I'd say it's wise to be cautious and at least let everyone alive say something before ending the game.
How could mafia somehow make the situation more confusing just by waiting for more more people to speak? The only way i can think of is that they could claim fake stuff, which we would be able to use against them in the future once notty turned out to be mafia. I don't see why it's unhelpful at all to wait until at least everyone's said something, and the fact you keep pushing on that idea is making me a bit suspicious that you're just trying to get me lynched. Kinda reminds of this moment actually, which I initially just ignored and thought of as nothing, but I'm starting to notice a bit of a pattern:
Seems you like 'deflecting' stuff onto me huh??