Tavern Arcana - Mafia Win

[HKCaper]

no offense hip, but in that case i rlly hope fog is the empress
<333

 

[Fog]

i'd claim the role for either hip, aqua, or fog so tell me if you want that.

So one of us three is the Empress if i am understanding you correctly?

 

[HKCaper]

So one of us three is the Empress if i am understanding you correctly?

welllll aqua claimed something else already

so it is you or hip

 

[Fog]

Well I guess hipman500 has been outed?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

So hk, since you think roles and cards are so linked, and notty is a tower that destructively changes events



via Imgflip Meme Generator

 

[Mooglie]

so the emperor can force the empress to vote for someone against her will and she just has to take it

THIS IS SEXISM

 

[HKCaper]

ALSO I KNOW I WAS AGAINST CLAIMING, SO THIS ISNT WHAT I WANTED

but i also couldnt be bothered to come up with a weird cover story to explain the double vote

 

[Aqua]

also it's 100% not me HKCaper cus I voted inf with you before and you only had 1 vote

and

So hk, since you think roles and cards are so linked, and notty is a tower that destructively changes events



via Imgflip Meme Generator

inf please stop.

 

[HKCaper]

So hk, since you think roles and cards are so linked, and notty is a tower that destructively changes events

roles and cards, not allignment and cards are we still having this same discussion?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

roles and cards, not allignment and cards are we still having this same discussion?

so tell me how a town role would destructively change an event and still be considered pro-town

 

[HKCaper]

so tell me how a town role would destructively change an event and still be considered pro-town

PLEAAAASE you had this convo with notty, she disagreed

then i found those bits that in my eyes back up notty, at least in the way I interpreted it

 

[Nottykitten]

From what I'm understanding, Hk is saying he gets an extra vote if the empress is also voting said person.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

PLEAAAASE you had this convo with notty, she disagreed

then i found those bits that in my eyes back up notty, at least in the way I interpreted it

and what about all the many, many bits that went against notty

 

[Fog]

so tell me how a town role would destructively change an event and still be considered pro-town

From this reading:
The Tower
Upright: Disaster, upheaval, sudden change, revelation
Reversed: Avoidance of disaster, fear of change

it is possible bby boy <3 you just need to look round at all of them possibilities

 

[HKCaper]

extra vote

well it counts double (just putting it here incase anyone will missunderstand)

 

[Infected_alien8_]

From this reading:
The Tower
Upright: Disaster, upheaval, sudden change, revelation
Reversed: Avoidance of disaster, fear of change

it is possible bby boy <3 you just need to look round at all of them possibilities

Anything is possible, the idea is that we lynch the most likely suspect

It seems everyone;s trying to stretch their reasoning to find an excuse to save notty which makes 0 sense at all

 

[Nottykitten]

Also can I just mention the real possiblity of Inf claiming something once he gets more votes, people backing off and voting me instead, then me claiming my role and then people realizing not to vote me and then we vote no lynch and my role is outed

 

[HKCaper]

and what about all the many, many bits that went against notty

yes i am aware, but havent we established that making 'bad' cards being scum would be unfair for scum

 

[Nottykitten]

Anything is possible, the idea is that we lynch the most likely suspect

It seems everyone;s trying to stretch their reasoning to find an excuse to save notty which makes 0 sense at all

We are lynching the most likely suspect though. Based on logic and suspicious behaviour, not on your conservative idea of what my card is supposted to be

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Also can I just mention the real possiblity of Inf claiming something once he gets more votes, people backing off and voting me instead, then me claiming my role and then people realizing not to vote me and then we vote no lynch and my role is outed

how interesting that you're assuming my claim is legit

it's almost as if you're mafia and know i'm not

yes i am aware, but havent we established that making 'bad' cards being scum would be unfair for scum

"unfair" for scum

this is mafia, we literally lynched off a list last game

 

[Infected_alien8_]

We are lynching the most likely suspect though. Based on logic and suspicious behaviour, not on your conservative idea of what my card is supposted to be

and what logic is that

 

[erik5456]

(On mobile so)

(bolded) vote Infy (bolded)

Trying to push a Massclaim, the tunneling on Notty after they'e one of the two people who proves massclaiming is a bad idea, and just for the sake of general clarity in the thread where I don' have to wake up to 7 pages of just inf posts, voting for Infy

 

[HKCaper]

this is mafia, we literally lynched off a list last game

and yet town still didnt win

mafia can be unpredictable at times, it's not always the obvious, which is why i choose to believe notty when she says it will make sense when she claims/her role gets revealed later on

 

[Infected_alien8_]

(On mobile so)

(bolded) vote Infy (bolded)

Trying to push a Massclaim, the tunneling on Notty after they'e one of the two people who proves massclaiming is a bad idea, and just for the sake of general clarity in the thread where I don' have to wake up to 7 pages of just inf posts, voting for Infy

"push a massclaim" quote me doing that

gee im pushing on a DESTRUCTIVE TOWER CARD WHEN CARDS ARE LINKED TO ROLES, WHO'D HAVE THOUGHT

IM HONESTLY SO BAFFLED AS TO WHAT THE HECK IS GOING ON

 

[Aqua]

We are lynching the most likely suspect though. Based on logic and suspicious behaviour, not on your conservative idea of what my card is supposted to be

Disagree.

I'm voting inf cus he's more likely to get lynched but you're clearly the more logical target. For the reasons I listed before, a lynch on you would help the even ifyou do flip innocent, if inf flips innocent the only benefit is we can actually have reasonable discussions again