Eh, you misinterpret me, friend. Nice misrepresenting me too.
Yo, the cause confusion bit was regarding you asking me to give you a nice, long list of my postulations between the roles and the alignments. To prove your theory of 'roles ≠ alignments'.
Fair enough, I thought you said it about your opinion in general but if it's about just the cards then I guess I did misinterpret that bit.
Anyways so you said this:
I'm still in favour of a mass-claim, but seeing that its not going to happen, why bring it back up again?
So you clearly were in favour of a massclaim. But then now you say this:
Mass-claim would generally be a good thing at the start because I thought Inffy knew what he was doing. Guess I was wrong? Happy now?
You changed your mind? In the last 2 pages? What happened in the last 2 pages that changed your mind?
And honestly this seems like you putting words in his mouth
That was a real question though, not some mocking theoretical question. If we can infer the alignment of people via cards then why wouldn't we claim? Aqua says its because there is likely a third party that would gain advantage of a mass card claim. Then I asked him which card it could be and he said death, so I asked why our best course of action then wouldnt be to mass-claim and lynch death so death can't take advantage of the massclaim. My point being that if cards = alignment we could do that easely but since you can't infer the alignment of people from cards that isn't possible, the notion of cards = alignment is bad and thus his reason for voting me is flawed. That's how I see it anyways.
Notty's card would suggest an anti town alignment just as inf's card would also suggest a 3p role,
But you don't want to give us a list of cards that suggest Mafia alignments which hurts my feelings since if I were heavely invested in some card = alignment theory I would have all kind of concepts and ideas of which card would be Mafia/Third Party and I would most certainly provide the town with a clean cut list of my suspicions so the town can work with that. But I guess the inferring alignment only aplies to mine + 2 other 'bad' card roles, Infs dead role and nobody else. And don't you dare say 'Emperor shows town alignments!1!!!' because with only 3 'bad' cards and assuming 6 Mafia you'd have to argue any of the so called 'good' cards can be Mafia and thus 'good' cards don't infer alignment either since some of them are bad.
