The Pearled Bridge - Game Complete!

[Guest35486]

no because if matty dies you'll pull exactly what you did already, 'I doused x at night and tonight I'll ignite them and if they're mafia I'm proven town', and people will believe you

isn't it unfortunate how our bodyguard got lynched let's take a moment to think about this hmm

 

[Omni]

matty dying during the night would guarantee her lynch would it not

 

[Nottykitten]

no because if matty dies you'll pull exactly what you did already, 'I doused x at night and tonight I'll ignite them and if they're mafia I'm proven town', and people will believe you

You're right this sounds like a sure way for me to survive tomorrow XD

 

[Guest35486]

matty dying during the night would guarantee her lynch would it not

i mean mafia can just pull the exact ploy then be like look this is what happened notty's evil (maybe they are evil but it's not a guarantee

 

[Infected_alien8_]

isn't it unfortunate how our bodyguard got lynched let's take a moment to think about this hmm

what?

 

[hipmeow]

not been counterclaimed yet should alert you that I may just yet be speaking the truth of being the town vigilante.

i dont even understand this argument. isnt this a closed setup, why would being unCC'd prove you being the town vig

 

[Omni]

if mattys power is the deciding factor in lynching notty or not then yeah i don't see why it wouldn't as her only saving grace is gone

 

[Infected_alien8_]

if mattys power is the deciding factor in lynching notty or not then yeah i don't see why it wouldn't as her only saving grace is gone

because then notty will say 'the mafia killed matty to frame me', and people will believe her

because for some reason some people keep believing everything she says even though in my/hip/oog's (probably the people who know her best by the way) eyes she's very very obviously lying

 

[Infected_alien8_]

like omni she's done this before, me/aqua/oog/hip all were convinced she was mafia but she somehow kept persuading the others to let her live 'just one more day'

she was mafia of course

 

[Nottykitten]

i dont even understand this argument. isnt this a closed setup, why would being unCC'd prove you being the town vig

Maybe because in 83% of the previous games we've played theres been some form of a town-kill, mostly vigilantes. To pretend that most games don't have a vigilante is ignoring pretty good evidence that there is likely a vigilante in this game and that it's me.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Maybe because in 83% of the previous games we've played theres been some form of a town-kill, mostly vigilantes. To pretend that most games don't have a vigilante is ignoring pretty good evidence that there is likely a vigilante in this game and that it's me.

100% of the games before haven't had aqua's role but y'know we should trust the past games to guide us

and there's also the whole argument of 'they may not have cc'd' which has many reasons for it, which me and oog already went over

 

[Nottykitten]

Hi I'm Infected _ alien I am so delighted to be at this cult meeting.

Oh what do I do??? Well.. uuhm.... I am able to JAIL people. Yeah that thing the LAW PEOPLE do except now I work for you guys totally


Flavour arguments aside it still makes no sense for you to have a power that combines both the powers of two existing town members. Thats atleast a tenfold crazier than a town vigilante with prime/ignite

 

[hipmeow]

Maybe because in 83% of the previous games we've played theres been some form of a town-kill, mostly vigilantes. To pretend that most games don't have a vigilante is ignoring pretty good evidence that there is likely a vigilante in this game and that it's me.

using stats is a dumb argument, just because it seems to be common doesnt mean there will be a vig in this game thus we are back to square one

 

[Omni]

how exactly would she claim she was framed? explain me through that please

 

[Nottykitten]

100% of the games before haven't had aqua's role but y'know we should trust the past games to guide us

and there's also the whole argument of 'they may not have cc'd' which has many reasons for it, which me and oog already went over

Arguing we shouldnt use past games to guide us after telling people that in a previous game I 'did this exact same thing ITS HAPPENING AGAIN YOU GUYS #conspiracy'.

And yeah theres a whole argument of 'hey they SHOULD have cc'd' which I already went over ten bazillion times which you're conveniently ignoring because you believe a vigilante would gamethrow but I'm not gonna argue that again

 

[Infected_alien8_]

how exactly would she claim she was framed? explain me through that please

the mafia want notty dead because she's not mafia and mafia will take advantage of every situation they can where they can get a free kill

so they kill matty so that notty can't prove herself, and so everyone lynches notty the next day

^^ that is the exact argument notty will use, and I'm telling you now, people will believe her, and give her 'one more day' to ignite someone else to 'prove her worth'

anyone who played tavarn arcana will know what I'm talking about

we finally have the momentum to lynch her, which is like gold dust, we should use it today

 

[Nottykitten]

using stats is a dumb argument, just because it seems to be common doesnt mean there will be a vig in this game thus we are back to square one

Ok so then we should also not assume the Mafia consists of 4-6 people like normal but instead consists of 1 or maybe 10 people WHO KNOWS maybe THIS GAME is different!!!

Just because every game is different doesn't mean most games have the same element in common

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Ok so then we should also not assume the Mafia consists of 4-6 people like normal but instead consists of 1 or maybe 10 people WHO KNOWS maybe THIS GAME is different!!!

Just because every game is different doesn't mean most games have the same element in common

comparing one town vigilante role to '10 mafia' or whatever isn't even remotely similar

 

[Nottykitten]

the mafia want notty dead because she's not mafia and mafia will take advantage of every situation they can where they can get a free kill

so they kill matty so that notty can't prove herself, and so everyone lynches notty the next day

^^ that is the exact argument notty will use, and I'm telling you now, people will believe her, and give her 'one more day' to ignite someone else to 'prove her worth'

anyone who played tavarn arcana will know what I'm talking about

we finally have the momentum to lynch her, which is like gold dust, we should use it today

You are so deadset on me being third party its so obvious you don't even care I could be town, which is the mark of scum

 

[Infected_alien8_]

You are so deadset on me being third party its so obvious you don't even care I could be town, which is the mark of scum

because I know you well, I've played almost every single mafia game in my life with you, I've talked with you for years, I know what you're like as town and this is not it

oog and hip can both attest to that

 

[Omni]

the mafia want notty dead because she's not mafia and mafia will take advantage of every situation they can where they can get a free kill

so they kill matty so that notty can't prove herself, and so everyone lynches notty the next day

^^ that is the exact argument notty will use, and I'm telling you now, people will believe her, and give her 'one more day' to ignite someone else to 'prove her worth'

anyone who played tavarn arcana will know what I'm talking about

we finally have the momentum to lynch her, which is like gold dust, we should use it today

so like the mafia will use the opportunity to get people to lynch notty... like what you're doing right now?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

like, lynching me is easy, everyone's fine with an inf lynch any day, because I'm not good at appearing townie even when I'm town

lynching notty is probably gonna either happen today, or way too late

 

[Nottykitten]

because I know you well, I've played almost every single mafia game in my life with you, I've talked with you for years, I know what you're like as town and this is not it

oog and hip can both attest to that

You clearly either don't know me well enough or you're extremely biased. I'll take #2 for $500 alex

 

[Infected_alien8_]

so like the mafia will use the opportunity to get people to lynch notty... like what you're doing right now?

and notty will use that argument to worm her way out and survive, like she's doing right now

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Omni if you want you can all lynch me tomorrow, that will be easy, but if you don't lynch notty now she'll survive, I'm telling you now