The Pearled Bridge - Game Complete!

[Infected_alien8_]

TheWeakGuy48_ you also now have incentive to vote for notty because if you don't she's going to set you on fire instead of omni, because omni is immune and you're the next suspect once I die

omni is definitely immune too since there's 0 reason he'd lie if he wasn't, regardless of his alignment/role, if he wasn't immune he'd be voting notty and ensuring his survival

in fact let me organize my arguments into one clear post on:


Why you should vote notty

1) all three of me, moog and hip, are convinced she's scum - I'm pretty sure we're the three people closest to her in this game and know her well, so the fact all three of us agree that notty isn't town should hopefully be a somewhat convincing argument on its own

2) she can no longer kill omni tonight. omni lying about being immune would be suicide, so regardless of his win condition, he wouldn't do it - so there's a massive reason to believe that he won't die. most of you are wanting to let notty live so that she can be useful to you tonight by killing one of your suspects, but this can no longer happen. the only way this can happen now is if she douses TWG and sets him on fire instead 2 days from now

3) she can't be proven town. if notty survives today, matty will die tonight. the mafia will kill matty because, if notty is town, it stops matty from being able to confirm it so gives the mafia a mislynch on notty, and if notty isn't town, getting rid of matty makes us still focus our attention on whether we believe notty or not, meaning mafia get less attention, which is also good for them. so there's no reason at all that the mafia won't kill matty tonight if notty lives

4) the other likely candidate is me, so if you think I'm probably town then you'll also want to vote notty to save me

Why you should vote me

1) if you think I'm more scummy than notty, then you should vote for me

--


and that's my argument for why you should vote for notty.

and this is for everyone by the way, not just TWG

 

[Infected_alien8_]

so there's no reason at all that the mafia won't kill matty tonight if notty lives

and well to be fair it is possible they'd be blocked by me/shadow or some other reason but I'd say it's extremely likely the mafia will kill matty tonight

 

[Infected_alien8_]

and well to be fair it is possible they'd be blocked by me/shadow or some other reason but I'd say it's extremely likely the mafia will kill matty tonight

if notty lives*, that is

if notty dies today then matty would probably live

 

[Guest35486]

this is a callout post of inf manipulating what people say with actual quotes because i didn't want to bother with my previous arguments

1) wise words from omni

you're awfully desperate to try and convince me to lynch notty - plus aqua said he wanted you OR notty dead tomorrow and yet you quoted the message where only notty is mentioned, at this point you're only digging your grave

2)

1) all three of me, moog and hip, are convinced she's scum - I'm pretty sure we're the three people closest to her in this game and know her well, so the fact all three of us agree that notty isn't town should hopefully be a somewhat convincing argument on its own

inf is mafia 100%
most other people share this opinion

however, without a notty lynch today i think most traction will be gone tomorrow (especially with inf dead today instead which admittedly isnt a bad option either since he is 100% mafia) and the rest of the game and so yeah das no good

i'd be willing to lynch inf without hesitation if i actually got my 50% players signed document to lynch notty regardless of anything tomorrow but i feel like i'm not gonna get that

while oog does want to lynch notty, he also thinks you're mafia.

so really it's just you and hip, and of course you'd be defending yourself so really really it's just hip. and hip's honestly really susp rn

 

[Infected_alien8_]

this is a callout post of inf manipulating what people say with actual quotes because i didn't want to bother with my previous arguments

1) wise words from omni

okay? and how in any way does what omni said relate to me being mafia? yes I was doing exactly what omni said I was doing, so what?

2)



while oog does want to lynch notty, he also thinks you're mafia.

so really it's just you and hip, and of course you'd be defending yourself so really really it's just hip. and hip's honestly really susp rn

okay? my point is that all three of me, oog and hip are convinced notty is mafia. what you're saying here has nothing to do with that?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

me, oog and hip are convinced notty is mafia. what you're saying here has nothing to do with that?

third party*

 

[Guest35486]

okay? and how in any way does what omni said relate to me being mafia? yes I was doing exactly what omni said I was doing, so what?

what do you mean so what, that's suspicious as hell did you just admit to manipulative writing? why would town manipulate other players like that

okay? my point is that all three of me, oog and hip are convinced notty is mafia. what you're saying here has nothing to do with that?

because you just took out the parts that support your points even though the original post states otherwise. oog's point was more about the traction of the game than notty being suspicious (even though he does include that they are susp) since the very first thing he says in that post is that you're 100% mafia and that most people agree.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

what do you mean so what, that's suspicious as hell did you just admit to manipulative writing? why would town manipulate other players like that

how is what I did manipulative posting? I acknowledged that aqua asked for me to be lynched, but was telling omni that he also asked for notty to be, quoted it, and said that he should consider notty as well. why is that manipulative writing?

because you just took out the parts that support your points even though the original post states otherwise. oog's point was more about the traction of the game than notty being suspicious (even though he does include that they are susp) since the very first thing he says in that post is that you're 100% mafia and that most people agree.

no I didn't? hip, oog and me are all convinced notty is not town, they can confirm that to you. whether they want to lynch me or not is entirely irrelevant to my point, my point is, "the three people who are probably closest to notty and know her best are all certain she's scum". doesn't matter what their opinion of me is

 

[Infected_alien8_]

also arelic why are you suspicious of hip now?

 

[Omni]

inf mdude leaving out the parts of the quotes that might influence people to vote you instead of notty sounds pretty manipulative to me regardless of any claimed intent :)

 

[Infected_alien8_]

inf mdude leaving out the parts of the quotes that might influence people to vote you instead of notty sounds pretty manipulative to me regardless of any claimed intent :)

but aqua saying to lynch me wasn't relevant to my point

I'd already acknowledged that aqua wanted me lynched by assuming that that was the reason you voted for me

my point then was to say "but hey look, he also wanted notty dead - and not only that, but notty's a better choice"

and then I quoted him saying that as proof

Omni you do realize aqua said to lynch notty right, I quoted him saying it a couple pages ago

so if this is about fulfilling aqua's last request, you'd be doing it either way - but at least with voting notty you're more helpful to your team

look:

I even said "you'd be doing it either way", meaning "yes aqua did want me lynched so you would be fulfilling his wishes by lynching me"

 

[Omni]

but aqua saying to lynch me wasn't relevant to my point

I'd already acknowledged that aqua wanted me lynched by assuming that that was the reason you voted for me

my point then was to say "but hey look, he also wanted notty dead - and not only that, but notty's a better choice"

and then I quoted him saying that as proof


I even said "you'd be doing it either way", meaning "yes aqua did want me lynched so you would be fulfilling his wishes by lynching me"

except i can do both, just in an order that's sensible (and you did more than one quote not just the obe directed at me)

 

[Infected_alien8_]

except i can do both, just in an order that's sensible

you can do both if you want yeah, but at the time I didn't know you were immune from the flames, so I was under the impression you'd die tonight and so had to pick between us

(and you did more than one quote not just the obe directed at me)

what do you mean by this sorry?

 

[Omni]

actually no, you did know about that, why are you lying at such a critical moment? And I meant the quotes about moog and whatnot

 

[Infected_alien8_]

actually no, you did know about that, why are you lying at such a critical moment?

I'm not lying, I didn't know about it. I was still catching up, as can be more or less proven by the fact I did this, in this order:

Omni you do realize aqua said to lynch notty right, I quoted him saying it a couple pages ago

so if this is about fulfilling aqua's last request, you'd be doing it either way - but at least with voting notty you're more helpful to your team

look:

if you're not gonna die tonight then all the more reason to lynch notty today, the only reason anyone's willing to wait til tomorrow is so she can kill you

if she's never gonna kill you, she's always gonna die

so why not lynch her today instead of tomorrow

And I meant the quotes about moog and whatnot

what quotes?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

oh my quotes don't show it but I quoted you twice basically, showing I was still catching up, otherwise I'd have done it on the same post

 

[Omni]

I'm not lying, I didn't know about it. I was still catching up, as can be more or less proven by the fact I did this, in this order:




what quotes?

on p80 you quoted my post where I said im immortal so yes u did know

 

[Infected_alien8_]

on p80 you quoted my post where I said im immortal so yes u did know

yes, after

 

[Omni]

and after said quote you went on to say i can fulfill aquas wishes by lynching notty... ???

 

[Infected_alien8_]

and after said quote you went on to say i can fulfill aquas wishes by lynching notty... ???

no, other way round

I said you you'd be fulfilling aqua's wishes either way regardless of if you kill me or notty, but that notty was better for your team since you'd be lynching an enemy to your faction before you died, and possibly securing your survival, which was also good for your team

I then quoted you saying you're immortal (since I read it) and said you should still lynch notty, but not because of aqua's wishes or anyting

 

[Infected_alien8_]

okay? and how in any way does what omni said relate to me being mafia? yes I was doing exactly what omni said I was doing, so what?


okay? my point is that all three of me, oog and hip are convinced notty is mafia. what you're saying here has nothing to do with that?

also reading back this feels really like, bitchy, so sorry if it came off like that to you as well

 

[Matty]

Eh, if Omni says he can't die tonight to Notty, no reason to risk her being an aggressive 3rd party
Vote Notty
But I would like you to claim your attribute/power that will prevent that please Omni

 

[Matty]

Don't thank my post boy, i'm still suspicious of you.

 

[Matty]

This is harassment, reported.

 

[TheWeakGuy48_]

1) all three of me, moog and hip, are convinced she's scum - I'm pretty sure we're the three people closest to her in this game and know her well, so the fact all three of us agree that notty isn't town should hopefully be a somewhat convincing argument on its own

This is a faulty argument, arguably you three + Notty probably knew Aqua best, and we both know how that ended.

2) she can no longer kill omni tonight. omni lying about being immune would be suicide, so regardless of his win condition, he wouldn't do it - so there's a massive reason to believe that he won't die. most of you are wanting to let notty live so that she can be useful to you tonight by killing one of your suspects, but this can no longer happen. the only way this can happen now is if she douses TWG and sets him on fire instead 2 days from now

She claimed she could only douse someone once, so she can't select me now.

3) she can't be proven town. if notty survives today, matty will die tonight. the mafia will kill matty because, if notty is town, it stops matty from being able to confirm it so gives the mafia a mislynch on notty, and if notty isn't town, getting rid of matty makes us still focus our attention on whether we believe notty or not, meaning mafia get less attention, which is also good for them. so there's no reason at all that the mafia won't kill matty tonight if notty lives

Sure, except nobody can actually be proven town. Not me, not you, not notty. We shouldn't lynch based on the argument that they can't ever be proven town - I believe I have already covered this in an earlier post.

Honestly for me it feels like an 80% chance that Inffy is mafia. Notty is about 70%, but the main reason for letting Notty live is that she'll either kill or prove Omni. (Although I'd rather lynch someone else, like Roob)