Oh fair enough sorryI did say what I meant. If we look back at the original post:
It was the best way I could think of at the time to elaborate. Maybe I couldn't remember the word "subconscious," I don't know
I just don't understand why you had the mindset of 'can I agree with this? nope I can't' rather than 'do I agree with this? no I don't'. Maybe it's just a difference in way of thinking but it gives me the impression you went into that scenario wanting to agree with brian but not being able to, and I attribute that to the fact you're mafia and are planning your actions based on an agenda rather than genuinely being confused and trying to get a feel for everyoneThat was my mindset because I can't support inapplicable reasoning like that. I could sure, but what would the benefit be? Further undermining of Alisha's towniness, at the cost of supporting the scummy behavior of Brian? I think it's entirely reasonable to say I can't do that.
What changed your mind?unvote
I guess that's where you're mistaken because I didn't want to agree with him. If I did, I wouldn't have said anything and just let it happen, because defending Alisha would've been against my hypothetical agenda.I just don't understand why you had the mindset of 'can I agree with this? nope I can't' rather than 'do I agree with this? no I don't'. Maybe it's just a difference in way of thinking but it gives me the impression you went into that scenario wanting to agree with brian but not being able to, and I attribute that to the fact you're mafia and are planning your actions based on an agenda rather than genuinely being confused and trying to get a feel for everyone
I don't know Brian's alignment and after having a little break to review these events I found my vote to be illogicalWhat changed your mind?
This is also trueI guess that's where you're mistaken because I didn't want to agree with him. If I did, I wouldn't have said anything and just let it happen, because defending Alisha would've been against my hypothetical agenda.
Yeah but the words 'have to' suggest to me you did want to side with brian but felt the need to defend alisha ('have to') since she's your teammate is what I'm sayingI guess that's where you're mistaken because I didn't want to agree with him. If I did, I wouldn't have said anything and just let it happen, because defending Alisha would've been against my hypothetical agenda.
I felt the need to defend Alisha (as I would've anyone in the situation) because the argument against her was unfair. That's the whole reasoning: I wouldn't want anyone to be lynched for an unfair reason, even if I was mafia.Yeah but the words 'have to' suggest to me you did want to side with brian but felt the need to defend alisha ('have to') since she's your teammate is what I'm saying
It's just weird to me that you're saying you defended her because you felt the need to and because you had to. If I see someone being accused of something unfairly I want to defend them because I don't want us to mislynch. Your perspective is as if it's something you had to do even if it was an annoyance, and even here you're including the possibility of you being mafia in your reasoning which I find strange as wellI felt the need to defend Alisha (as I would've anyone in the situation) because the argument against her was unfair. That's the whole reasoning: I wouldn't want anyone to be lynched for an unfair reason, even if I was mafia.
What about you?Notme I always see you watching the thread - do you have any opinions?
No idea honestly at the moment, may change later on. just wondering about raxo cus I havent seen him say anythingWhat about you?
It's something that I would be compelled to do regardless of anything else in the game is what I'm saying.It's just weird to me that you're saying you defended her because you felt the need to and because you had to. If I see someone being accused of something unfairly I want to defend them because I don't want us to mislynch. Your perspective is as if it's something you had to do even if it was an annoyance, and even here you're including the possibility of you being mafia in your reasoning which I find strange as well
It's something that I would be compelled to do regardless of anything else in the game is what I'm saying.
See your perspective right now feels so weird and the only way I can think to make sense of it is if you and alisha are teamed and you're doing damage control. Insisting that you'd feel the need to this even if you're mafia, and regardless of anything else in the game - I don't understand why your mind is even in that space right now, unless you predicted you'd be lynched and didn't want us to conclude you were defending a teammate and would do that regardless of alisha's alignment if you were mafia. Trying to convince me you'd do the same thing what you did as mafia doesn't make sense to me otherwise. My point is that the fact you felt like you 'had to' is scummy since I wouldn't feel that way, I wouldn't look at it as 'well I have to do this because I feel compelled to', I'd look at it as 'this isn't right and I want to correct it' because that's what my objective is in the game. The way you talk about it makes it seem like it isn't part of your objective by default but you felt the need to do it. Hopefully this makes sense?I wouldn't want anyone to be lynched for an unfair reason, even if I was mafia.
I never said brian's accusation was unfair, but I said it wasn't solid, and that's because it was using werewolf as meta which didn't seem very reliableI want both Inffy and Timdood to answer the above question.
I just wanted it on the record that you don't see it as unfair, only unreliable. Thanks for answering!I never said brian's accusation was unfair, but I said it wasn't solid, and that's because it was using werewolf as meta which didn't seem very reliable
Why?I just wanted it on the record that you don't see it as unfair, only unreliable. Thanks for answering!
Please, if I was scum I wouldn't need a buddy to bail me out~the only way I can think to make sense of it is if you and alisha are teamed and you're doing damage control
What kind of accusations in Mafia games would you find so egregious and unfair, you would defend the target of them no matter what alignment you may be?Why?
Is that a hint to timPlease, if I was scum I wouldn't need a buddy to bail me out~
I'd rather have them bus me in all honesty since if Timdood is on a scum team with me, we've just made it incredibly obvious through our interactions.