[GAME OVER] Formula Mafia

[MarsKid]

Mars lynch good

This low-effort is y i k e s

i disagree, duffie pointed out something that made sense - mars set up the narrative for mislynches depending on if he is lynched today - whether that's a scummy thing he does or he's just bitter is up in the air but im more in favor of him just being bitter

It's not bitterness, it's predicting how this pans out considering voting patterns at the time. Frustrated though, I am.

 

[Duffie]

meanwhile i agree with mars about notty's lack of explaining their reasoning for serious votes; so i think we'd learn more from a notty lynch d0

unvote
vote notty

Notty decided to come on board without any reasoning of their own either, but tbh Notty not making a random claim/power move is more town than scum to me.

Wut

 

[Boooo]

have you read the previous discussion about colors

where he said he had no idea what i was talking about

thats where i said i take back my townread

i was mainly messing with you for a reaction, pretty defensive there

 

[MarsKid]

have you read the previous discussion about colors

where he said he had no idea what i was talking about

thats where i said i take back my townread

FWIW that could just be distancing. But also FWIW Alisha's been jumping through a fair amount of susses already and scum doesn't flop around like that, I buy the confusion as genuine.

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

i thought you were scummy

To be fair last game I was also a class A idiot and probably would've been lynched anyway. But Inffy certainly didn't help things.

 

[Alisha]

i was mainly messing with you for a reaction, pretty defensive there

is that another reaction test

 

[Boooo]

FWIW that could just be distancing. But also FWIW Alisha's been jumping through a fair amount of susses already and scum doesn't flop around like that, I buy the confusion as genuine.

last time she was mafia she acted like this

 

[Boooo]

is that another reaction test

you wouldn't be looking for them so much if you had nothing to hide

 

[Alisha]

everyone is rating my posts in contradictory ways and it's annoying me

boo and stranger referenced duffie's behaivor difference in ratings on my posts and theyve never played with her before

duffie is disagreeing with a post of mine saying no lynch as last resort and no lynch as worse than lynch

 

[Alisha]

you wouldn't be looking for them so much if you had nothing to hide

what

you just said you did a reaction test

 

[Alisha]

last time she was mafia she acted like this

in the spirit of fairness she's right, i was deliberately confused and useless

 

[MarsKid]

you wouldn't be looking for them so much if you had nothing to hide

what

you just said you did a reaction test

This some 4D reaction testing chess.

What was telling about Alisha's reaction?

 

[Boooo]

what

you just said you did a reaction test

i mean yeah but if youre town why would you care

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

everyone is rating my posts in contradictory ways and it's annoying me

boo and stranger referenced duffie's behaivor difference in ratings on my posts and theyve never played with her before

duffie is disagreeing with a post of mine saying no lynch as last resort and no lynch as worse than lynch

As I recall I also asked you to explain why you thought Duffie was playing differently because I had no idea of how to expect her to play?

 

[Nottykitten]

because notty feels like the best bet with the lack of explanations and bandwagoning on you

This vibes

notty was 30 there

Im catfishing inf dont tell him

This low-effort is y i k e s

It's true but that does leave me the question what exactly you think we will gain from any deaths tomorrow. Say Inf flips town tracker how exactly should we vote with this new information? Im just confused how you think one or two deaths will somehow give info that helps us determine a guilty person tomorrow when I dont see it as such.

 

[MarsKid]

i mean yeah but if youre town why would you care

Is town supposed to ignore reaction tests by default? I'm not following you here, give some clarification.

 

[Alisha]

As I recall I also asked you to explain why you thought Duffie was playing differently because I had no idea of how to expect her to play?

yes but you rated the post as if you had firsthand experience there!

okay im getting flashbacks to your mislynch in comedy club so i'll let that one go for you only

 

[Boooo]

Is town supposed to ignore reaction tests by default? I'm not following you here, give some clarification.

no they aren't, my point is, town is less likely to look for them or care as they have nothing to hide, meanwhile mafia does look for them
im simply asking why shes looking for them because i dont think town would care

 

[Boooo]

but me asking was actually for a reaction

 

[Duffie]

You're weird
Wouldn't vote you though love

I feel like duff is trying to softly push Mars without getting flack for it later

This hurts. ?

 

[Alisha]

no they aren't, my point is, town is less likely to look for them or care as they have nothing to hide, meanwhile mafia does look for them
im simply asking why shes looking for them because i dont think town would care

i didn't have to look for one

you told me you did a reaction test

 

[MarsKid]

It's true but that does leave me the question what exactly you think we will gain from any deaths tomorrow. Say Inf flips town tracker how exactly should we vote with this new information? Im just confused how you think one or two deaths will somehow give info that helps us determine a guilty person tomorrow when I dont see it as such.

Fair enough. My counter being that nks illuminate D0/early game behavior and provide insight on how scum operates depending on who is bumped off. Number of kills/lack of kills helps in closed set-up b/c it determines potential 3P elements, power roles, etc. Helps to understand the set-up better.

The caveat I've mentioned is that if a lynch is what is going to happen, it should be directed at wagoners/observers. Hence why poking in HK/Skel/Inf.

 

[Boooo]

This hurts. ?

sorry

 

[Boooo]

i didn't have to look for one

you told me you did a reaction test

nvm this is just getting confusing now

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

yes but you rated the post as if you had firsthand experience there!

okay im getting flashbacks to your mislynch in comedy club so i'll let that one go for you only

Im not sure how rating it as 'Informative' is reacting as if I had firsthand experience there. I usually use the 'informative' rating as a 'thanks for the info' response.