thats kind of hard to do without bias but
INF: Came into thread thinking alisha claiming to notty + pushing boo to claim = weird. Also thought notty made broadcast. Also didn't want boo to claim. Also thought stranger's role = scum, because it copied two other roles and was anonymous compared to skele's neighbor role. Also thought hk/skooma/okx sent alisha the msg. Also voted skoo a couple times. Also changed mind on oog and townreads him now since he claimed blocker and doubts he'd do that as scum. Didn't want to claim.
HIP: Believed broadcast (didnt think it was 100% real but saw no reason to doubt it either). Was happy to claim. Claimed to intercept msgs from people randomly and can broadcast them if he chooses. Broadcasted msg alisha got '21375'. After a while of discussion of whether this could be from maf chat, revealed he now remembers this happened d0 near end of day. Thought notty and alisha were sus, notty for continueing to push boo after their claim (but since then notty claimed her role and explained why this was, not sure if hip buys this or not??), and alisha for not calling notty out. Then said his alisha read could be just based on what he'd personally do in alisha's shoes in that context and could be unfair to scumread her for it.
STR: Claimed Race Director and outed notty as knowing the broadcast was fake yet still pushing. Didn't out alisha for going along with it. Also said skele neighbor'd her. Said she put a penalty on notty so that they can't vote alisha - this didn't work (but notty claimed to bypass penalties). Also claimed third party and has to penalize three scum (could be the same scum) to win (gets told if she was successful in penalizing scum at the start of each night, if n1 is anything to go by, as didn't get a confirmation msg this morning but got it start of n1 before).
NOT: Acted like broadcast was believable to them. Pushed boo to claim and continued to push even after they claimed cop. Later on admitted to creating the broadcast with alisha and said they did it since they predicted tim would die and wanted to get reactions from boo being framed. Said they still scumread boo as notty is immune to penalties so why would a town cop give out penalties to carry out their role when there's a town role immune to them, so thinks they aren't a town cop. Also didn't believe stranger's claimed wincon as said it would be impossible, but that was before stranger clarified she can penalize the same scum more than once - don't know if notty still doesn't believe it or not. Was agreeing with oog about the msg received by alisha being from scumchat.
MOO: Thought inf made the broadcast at first, later agreed with INF that notty did it. Thinks notty did it as town/3p, thinks alisha town too but that her not outing her msg d0 was weird and that her point about notty/hip being mafia is just panicking. Thinks hk sent the message. Thought the msg alisha reveived was from scum chat at first but doesn't seem to think so anymore, not sure why not though. Thinks most active players are townie so thinks inactives are scum. Still thinks INF is scum.
HKC: Thinks msg alisha received wasn't from scumchat. Denies sending msg.
ALI: Watched silently as notty carried out plan at first, though said she had reason to think boo was town and that she'd elaborate later. Also revealed notty/ali/race director chat at start of day. When boo refused to claim, pushed her to with notty. Thinks notty is scum as finds it too much to be a coincidence that tim died after notty told her to say boo visited tim in the broadcast. Thinks hip sent her the msg to make her look scum and thinks the timing of hip revealing it was too convenient as it was when people were suspicious of alisha. Agreed she was the broadcaster role.
SKE: seems to believe stranger is 3p and seems to confirm that stranger claimed 3p in the night chat.
MARS: Said he'd be inactive a bit. Agreed to massclaiming but only if everyone played ball. Asked people to go back to check d0 info after cop claim. Agreed boo should claim first out of everyone because of 'lingering d0 questions and this current pushback' (INF still waiting on clarification for what this means)
BOO: Claimed cop and that didn't visit anyone n1. Agreed with fact notty was unlikely to be pushing her trying to get her lynched since she'd be making herself obvious.
SKO: nothing
DUF: Catching up. Kept tally of who is in favour of massclaiming (but counted two people twice
Duffie - mars + hip). Agreed broadcast seemed fake.
OKX: nothing
