[GAME OVER] Formula Mafia

[Nottykitten]

If it's being immune to specific people, and so far the people who have claimed to be able to hand out penalties are Town... I'm not feeling very trusting of Notty.

However you may feel of me, it would probs be the best to lynch an AFK because if we lynch an active we'll just have less votes to do anything tomorrow. Plus I can block someone tonight and atleast prove I'm a 1-shot blocker via that, which should hopefully make you trust me more.

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

If it's being immune to specific people, and so far the people who have claimed to be able to hand out penalties are Town... I'm not feeling very trusting of Notty.

I agree - that's why I think we should lynch Notty above any of the AFKs. Because Notty is likely scum. The AFKs we have no idea whether or not they're scum.

Besides, I think it'll be far easier to draw conclusions about the AFKs if we wait a night. With two innkeepers and a rolecop, we should be able to force claims/alignments out of the AFKs pretty easily if we're smart about our night actions.

 

[Nottykitten]

I agree - that's why I think we should lynch Notty above any of the AFKs. Because Notty is likely scum. The AFKs we have no idea whether or not they're scum.

Besides, I think it'll be far easier to draw conclusions about the AFKs if we wait a night. With two innkeepers and a rolecop, we should be able to force claims/alignments out of the AFKs pretty easily if we're smart about our night actions.

There is about 0 reason to not wait with lynching me till tomorrow

 

[Duffie]

However you may feel of me, it would probs be the best to lynch an AFK because if we lynch an active we'll just have less votes to do anything tomorrow. Plus I can block someone tonight and atleast prove I'm a 1-shot blocker via that, which should hopefully make you trust me more.

I agree - that's why I think we should lynch Notty above any of the AFKs. Because Notty is likely scum. The AFKs we have no idea whether or not they're scum.

Besides, I think it'll be far easier to draw conclusions about the AFKs if we wait a night. With two innkeepers and a rolecop, we should be able to force claims/alignments out of the AFKs pretty easily if we're smart about our night actions.

Jeez guys, one after another... xD

I definitely agree that Notty is more likely Mafia or evil Third Party now, but I don't particularly like the idea of innkeeping the inactives... Not to mention, you could only get one of them, unless they both come up and vote each other... ^^;

Also, they are inactive, which wouldn't quite guarantee a reply... Well, actually, they are active every other day or so, so maybe I'm wrong.

You also pointed out our alignment cop, so you're right. xD

Okay, Stranger... I'm trusting you here.

vote Nottykitten

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

Jeez guys, one after another... xD

I definitely agree that Notty is more likely Mafia or evil Third Party now, but I don't particularly like the idea of innkeeping the inactives... Not to mention, you could only get one of them, unless they both come up and vote each other... ^^;

Also, they are inactive, which wouldn't quite guarantee a reply... Well, actually, they are active every other day or so, so maybe I'm wrong.

You also pointed out our alignment cop, so you're right. xD

Okay, Stranger... I'm trusting you here.

vote Nottykitten

To clarify, I think a good plan would be to have Booo alignment cop Okx or Skooma, with HK on her as backup.
Moog can roleblock the other AFK as backup.
And then I'll drop Alisha and Skele into the race director chat so we can get a full claim from him, including role name. That way if Alisha or I gets nightkilled someone else can verify Skele's claim.

What do you think? Feel free to make suggestions.

 

[Alisha]

There is about 0 reason to not wait with lynching me till tomorrow

unvote
vote Nottykitten

 

[Mooglie]

To clarify, I think a good plan would be to have Booo alignment cop Okx or Skooma, with HK on her as backup.
Moog can roleblock the other AFK as backup.
And then I'll drop Alisha and Skele into the race director chat so we can get a full claim from him, including role name. That way if Alisha or I gets nightkilled someone else can verify Skele's claim.

What do you think? Feel free to make suggestions.

wouldnt it be better to put okx/skooma + someone else (alisha maybe i guess!) in the race director chat so you can block okx/skooma and also get a claim out of them (assuming they have to be here for night, they should see the night chat and then be forced to claim and if they dont then scum!) and then block them & then i can just block the other one

 

[Alisha]

To clarify, I think a good plan would be to have Booo alignment cop Okx or Skooma, with HK on her as backup.
Moog can roleblock the other AFK as backup.
And then I'll drop Alisha and Skele into the race director chat so we can get a full claim from him, including role name. That way if Alisha or I gets nightkilled someone else can verify Skele's claim.

What do you think? Feel free to make suggestions.

im okay with this since mafia wont kill me and i’ll write the claim as my night action, suckers

and if all else fails just check an alignment so we get something else

 

[Alisha]

hey i can actually give fast updates on claims from race director from my ability

so if anything i should be there as the INTERROGATOR

 

[Mooglie]

but before day ends whoever is gonna be in the nightchat who isnt one of the inactives has to vote for them
im fine with the rest of the plan (sorry notty <3)
+ its probs best to lynch notty today since this blue flag thing, in the world where notty is mafia, is instantly disprovable over night so functions as a way for them to get a single night more being alive meaning that theres probably a decently bad action they can do tonight

 

[Alisha]

unvote
vote good skele
unvote
vote nottykitten

 

[Mooglie]

but before day ends whoever is gonna be in the nightchat who isnt one of the inactives has to vote for them

or good skele if people support that plan more but i think inactive is better in my eyes

 

[Alisha]

or good skele if people support that plan more but i think inactive is better in my eyes

the good skele plan is ok, but an inactive has less to work with so if anything else its an easy alignment check

 

[Alisha]

so idk

unvote
vote Skoomaeater
unvote
vote Okx
unvote
vote Nottykitten

 

[Alisha]

imo an inactive might be better since skele at least has a claim and might talk once a day

the others vanished or something

 

[Nottykitten]

Im confused why am I being lynched today instead of letting me prove myself. There is literally 0 reason to lynch me over an inactive.

 

[Nottykitten]

Why can't Boo just investigate me?¿?¿?

 

[Good Skele]

Do you have any way to prove you are Town? Or perhaps that you are Pro-Town?

In all honesty no, it's not like I can do much anything else. Also - Pro-Town? wha

 

[Ltin]

Votecount
GOO - [1] - BOO
NOT - [3] - STR, DUF, ALI
SKO - [1] - NOT
With 10 players it takes 6 to lynch and 5 to no lynch.

Spoiler: Running Order

_________GAP
| 1. MOO -
| 2. ALI 4
| 3. NOT 3
| 4. DUF 3
| 5. STR 5
| 6. BOO 14
| 7. GOO 0
| 8. HKC 0
| 9. OKX 1
|10. SKO 0
|11. INF
|12. HIP
|13. MAR
|14. TIM

 

[Good Skele]

or good skele if people support that plan more but i think inactive is better in my eyes

Inactive doesn't mean anything, from my experience, but only a willingness of a person to play or their ability to. As far as I've seen, lynching inactive people is almost never a good idea, unless at the beginning of the game.

Im confused why am I being lynched today instead of letting me prove myself. There is literally 0 reason to lynch me over an inactive.

Why can't Boo just investigate me?¿?¿?

I must admit that doesn't sound like something town-ish

 

[Mooglie]

Im confused why am I being lynched today instead of letting me prove myself. There is literally 0 reason to lynch me over an inactive.

Why can't Boo just investigate me?¿?¿?

since youre the only person with actual evidence against you!
being an unbelievable/scummy role + inf saw you and mars being a team and im too lazy to look into that any more but i believe him

lynching someone else is taking a leap in the dark since it truly can be 50/50 and then investigating you either confirms something most people are sure of (youre scum) or exonerates you whereas investigating an inactive gives complete clarity to a 50/50 thing (in my eyes atleast)

aka not lynching you is more likely to be a mislynch and investigating you is less valuable

 

[Mooglie]

Inactive doesn't mean anything, from my experience, but only a willingness of a person to play or their ability to. As far as I've seen, lynching inactive people is almost never a good idea, unless at the beginning of the game.

inactive referring to okx/skooma, not the characteristic that makes them scum
but being inactive is also scummy since youre lurky and noone can actually gather evidence against you and youre stuck in 50/50 land
whats scum is that mostly everyone else has believable claims/just are town-y aka the inactives are probably scum

 

[Nottykitten]

As far as I've seen, lynching inactive people is almost never a good idea, unless at the beginning of the game.

Not lynching them doesn't help town either because they contribute 0 to scum hunting and eventually days take ages because we need their vote in order to actually do something. And even if they do vote they haven't read the thread and just vote for whomever has the most votes. Either way they are 0 help to the town or the fun of the game.

since youre the only person with actual evidence against you!
being an unbelievable/scummy role

I've already proven half of my role I can easely prove the other half tonight. I can be proven 100% if you let Boo investigate me.

lynching someone else is taking a leap in the dark since it truly can be 50/50 and then investigating you either confirms something most people are sure of (youre scum) or exonerates you whereas investigating an inactive gives complete clarity to a 50/50 thing (in my eyes atleast)

It's not even a 50/50, Alisha/Boo/You/Stranger/Duffie are pretty much confirmed not-scum (aside from the odd scenario Boo is scum remember when Mars didn't torpedo them). Assuming 3 scum within the other 5 (me/Skele/Okx/Skooma/Hk) thats atleast a 60% chance to hit right. Make that 75% since I'm innocent. If you townread skele then it's essentially 100% but sure.

The inactives are providing 0 to the town. Exonerating me is worth a thousand times more than exonerating someone who doesn't even play the game.

But sure have fun with your plan that involves having 4/8 people be inactive tomorrow.

 

[Nottykitten]

My only crime is being a 1-shot roleblocker thats immune to penalties this is hibes

 

[Nottykitten]

Stranger from Planet 9 Alisha when I flip town how will this change your perspective of the people alive right now