They Are Among Us [Game Complete!]

[Infected_alien8_]

Check Stranger's count. My vote put it to L-2.

Methinks Unu slippin'

stranger's count didn't include unu's vote

 

[TheWeakGuy48_]

unvote

spicy last few minutes...

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Don't like this claim.
Gut reaction, I don't see stealing all of someone's stuff as being town sided.

Yeah, I predicted that. If I was fake claiming I'd make it much more convincingly town, but you know, wifom and all

 

[Timdood3]

If you think I play sloppily as mafia then idk what to tell you, as maf my #1 goal is to be as air-tight and bullet-proof as possible

I never understood arguments like this and "town shouldn't care about appearances."
I know this is a little bit of a tangent but I'm always concerned about appearances regardless of alignment. If as a townie I get perceived as mafia, then I've hurt the town by getting mislynched.

 

[Fog]

Infected_alien8_ GIVE US A SURNAME

 

[Timdood3]

Check Stranger's count. My vote put it to L-2.

Methinks Unu slippin'

Stranger missed UNU's vote (but it didn't matter because he subsequently unvoted)

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I never understood arguments like this and "town shouldn't care about appearances."
I know this is a little bit of a tangent but I'm always concerned about appearances regardless of alignment. If as a townie I get perceived as mafia, then I've hurt the town by getting mislynched.

As town most of my mental energy is on trying to feel other people, so whilst I do still care about not looking suspicious, it's nowhere near to the same degree as when I'm scum. Hence why my plays as town tend to be more chaotic than as scum. As scum I do my best to make everything I say air-tight. I don't give my posts the same amount of attention as that when I'm town

 

[MarsKid]

My role flavor has a last name, and both the cop claims had last names, for what it's worth.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Infected_alien8_ GIVE US A SURNAME

I don't have one

I'm Charlie, simply Charlie

 

[Infected_alien8_]

nvm stranger apparently made a mistake and I'm Charlie the Hobo

 

[Fog]

I don't have one

I'm Charlie, simply Charlie

Why don't I buy this... but also why is this the most honest I feel you have been.

 

[erik5456]

What do you mean you can see if someone has killed someone before? Why would they lose their items?

They mean that if they stole all of someones items and they had more than 2, its sus because they mustve gotten those items from killing someone else.

Seems more like a mafia or 3rd party side role though imo. Tim ninja'd me on this though.

Do you not have a title even Inf?

 

[Fog]

nvm stranger apparently made a mistake and I'm Charlie the Hobo

Now this I believe less

 

[Infected_alien8_]

What do you mean you can see if someone has killed someone before? Why would they lose their items?

Woops missed this

because if someone said they started with 2 items then suddenly have 4 it's likely they murdered someone the night before

 

[MarsKid]

But they can also visit the graveyard

 

[Infected_alien8_]

(killing people takes all their items - why would maf have a second role to take items when they can do it by killing?)

 

[Fog]

Woops missed this

because if someone said they started with 2 items then suddenly have 4 it's likely they murdered someone the night before

Or 2 people gave them items? Or they looted items from the lyched body?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

But they can also visit the graveyard

1 item can be taken at a time

killing = 2

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Or 2 people gave them items? Or they looted items from the lyched body?

if 2 people gave them items they can claim it during chat to defend them

if they looted items theyd have [night we're on + 1] at most

 

[Infected_alien8_]

but again why would maf have a thief role when they get items by killing people anyways

town probably needs a thief as well to stop mafia building harmful things since town has 0 other method of doing that

 

[Infected_alien8_]

(and im assuming thats like the main purpose of my role)

 

[Timdood3]

nvm stranger apparently made a mistake and I'm Charlie the Hobo

Mhmm now we're blaming the host?
I don't like that I can't reasonably use that against you because I mean...We've all been there.

But from a setup perspective I'd see your ability as more 3rd party than anything.
Because you raise a good point, why would mafia need a role to do that.
But I could absolutely see a third party trying to assemble some number of items together as their wincon, and not wanting to accelerate deaths in such a small game.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

so Fog willing to claim?

 

[Fog]

(killing people takes all their items - why would maf have a second role to take items when they can do it by killing?)

Can I just take a moment to say, I feel this is like Inffy came up with a random Role and Name and then was like lets make it look kinda scummy. Then he realised this could be his out. He is also getting more stressed as his text is in bold...

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Mhmm now we're blaming the host?
I don't like that I can't reasonably use that against you because I mean...We've all been there.

But from a setup perspective I'd see your ability as more 3rd party than anything.
Because you raise a good point, why would mafia need a role to do that.
But I could absolutely see a third party trying to assemble some number of items together as their wincon, and not wanting to accelerate deaths in such a small game.

3rd party with 11 players seems unlikely to me, it'd be hard to balance, so I don't think we actually have a third party in general