Mafia: Saints & Sinners - GAME OVER MAFIA WIN

[Alisha]

and the person who has a made up gay baby name.

see also: UNU

 

[Alisha]

mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

 

[Infected_alien8_]

If they don't have a hypnotist a messenger could be a less effective means to coax people into making deals.

how

he visits people during the night, after theyve already decided to deal or not

and the next day any townie would reveal the convo

 

[Aqua]

how

he visits people during the night, after theyve already decided to deal or not

and the next day any townie would reveal the convo

Yeah that's fair, but at the same time in this set-up I can't see the point of having a townsided messenger, for filler roles it's one of the worst IMO and can frequently get people lynched. (I.E Unu last game and also possibly this game if we didn't already distrust fog)

 

[Alisha]

how the turns have tabled im a swing vote

if aqua is scum, it's an interesting decision to move to clear me and tim...

 

[Aqua]

see also: UNU

a) could possssibly be scum I could go eitherway tbh - neither side would benefit much if it's at night I suppose
b) Didn't he say his name was Jean, googling it Jean is a saint but ok "Patron Saint of Canada"

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Yeah that's fair, but at the same time in this set-up I can't see the point of having a townsided messenger, for filler roles it's one of the worst IMO and can frequently get people lynched. (I.E Unu last game and also possibly this game if we didn't already distrust fog)

i agree but i dont see the point in a mafia one either so his claim is basically null for me

all i know is he claimed jean and that gives him townie points

if aqua is scum, it's an interesting decision to move to clear me and tim...

i mean, he said he thinks maf have "Poor Sinner" roles so he hasnt cleared you from his pov

 

[Aqua]

how the turns have tabled im a swing vote

if aqua is scum, it's an interesting decision to move to clear me and tim...

If inf is right and there are only town poor sinners then I could see both our roles co-existing altho I'm still pretty susp of the playstyle thing.

However if there are mafia poor sinners I can't see a way both our roles would exist.

 

[Alisha]

mean, he said he thinks maf have "Poor Sinner" roles so he hasnt cleared you from his pov

he explicitly said he thinks tim and i are inno

 

[Aqua]

he explicitly said he thinks tim and i are inno

I didn't but ok

 

[Infected_alien8_]

If inf is right and there are only town poor sinners then I could see both our roles co-existing altho I'm still pretty susp of the playstyle thing.

what playstyle thing

or are you still talking about how i didnt ask sinners to make a deal even though i already explained that

However if there are mafia poor sinners I can't see a way both our roles would exist.

i highly doubt stranger would write the flavour she has if that were the case

 

[Aqua]

but I will say that I can now confirm Alisha and Tim are poor sinners so unless there's a core game mechanic we're missing they are confirmed town

Alisha

 

[Alisha]

I didn't but ok

i kinda assumed that but you're somewhat right

though i have noticed this weird thing

you mentioned i am not lying about my role name

where previously you indicated i probably copied poor sinner from beta, so okay there

but unlike inf who acknowledged maybe his read on me is incorrect, you don't have a reason to not push me today considering you haven't acknowledged my scumminess yet and i was one of your top suspects for the longest time

why aren't you pushing for me harder?

 

[Aqua]

or are you still talking about how i didnt ask sinners to make a deal even though i already explained that

I mean if you were lying it doesn't explain anything?

Just because you could jump through a hoop and explain something away doesn't mean it can't be suspicious

 

[Aqua]

i kinda assumed that but you're somewhat right

though i have noticed this weird thing

you mentioned i am not lying about my role name

where previously you indicated i probably copied poor sinner from beta, so okay there

but unlike inf who acknowledged maybe his read on me is incorrect, you don't have a reason to not push me today considering you haven't acknowledged my scumminess yet and i was one of your top suspects for the longest time

why aren't you pushing for me harder?

Because I don't know whether mafia has poor sinners or not and until I have evidence to suggest they do you're proven...?

I didn't say you're 100% innocent I said unless there are more mechanics we're unaware of you're confirmed town... so until anything changes I'm not going to lynch you.

 

[Alisha]

Because I don't know whether mafia has poor sinners or not and until I have evidence to suggest they do you're proven...?

I didn't say you're 100% innocent I said unless there are more mechanics we're unaware of you're confirmed town... so until anything changes I'm not going to lynch you.

so i am inno'd with a * behind it

 

[Aqua]

so i am inno'd with a * behind it

Sure, go nuts.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I mean if you were lying it doesn't explain anything?

Just because you could jump through a hoop and explain something away doesn't mean it can't be suspicious

but i said in my initial claim that it cancels the deal and undos the consequences of it

why would it cancel a deal yet the townie gets to keep their part of it, that doesnt make any sense

 

[Aqua]

but i said in my initial claim that it cancels the deal and undos the consequences of it

why would it cancel a deal yet the townie gets to keep their part of it, that doesnt make any sense

to stop the devil from winning...?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

to stop the devil from winning...?

no i mean, flavour wise

bearing in mind i said i cancel/undo a deal, it wouldnt make sense for my initial claim to be that i only revoke the scum side of it

in which case you have no reason to think that my playstyle doesnt fit with my claim

 

[Aqua]

no i mean, flavour wise

bearing in mind i said i cancel/undo a deal, it wouldnt make sense for my initial claim to be that i only revoke the scum side of it

in which case you have no reason to think that my playstyle doesnt fit with my claim

I think your phrasing is too ambiguous to go in a certain direction - I'm not voting you for it but just because it can be read in a certain way doesn't inherently mean it was intended too.

 

[Infected_alien8_]

Aqua can your ability be blocked?

 

[Aqua]

Aqua can your ability be blocked?

I literally said earlier I don't know because and this is the forth time I've written this sentence so listen up:

"it happens at the BEGINNING of the night"

So, would you like me to ask stranger in my dm good sir? :)

 

[Aqua]

Infected_alien8_ I cannot be blocked :)

 

[Aqua]

Alisha just to clarify is there a scenario IYO that both mine and inf's claims could co-exist or nah?