Русская мафия! [Complete]
- Thread starter Prizyms
- Start date
Mooglie
The Local Cow
well pinning it on a dead guy is kinda easy
also is anyone else sensing a theme of like pairs
naoh & hunter as templars
notty & chief as police (then poor lonely tim)
jkangaroo & [someone maybe caff] as telegram people
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
The reason for me not voting is because I have no idea who to vote.
My gut tells me oog is town and I can see how his ability could benefit us. If, for example, he wiretaps someone and figures out they were lying about their role etc. It's just unfortunate that it can hinder Town roles too. But I think he could be very useful so I don't want to vote him.
The 77/myuser thing is 50/50 for me since I kind of want to believe both of them.
Part of me wants to vote to lynch Notme due to his suspicious behaviour but I get the impression he acts like this a lot and I don't think many others would lynch him.
The fact that oog knows caff has watched Over the Garden Wall is interesting. It makes me think caff is perhaps the telegrapher, but then again we don't know if that role is bad or not. I just find it interesting that she denies it too.
But yeah, I'm stumped on what to do.
My gut tells me oog is town and I can see how his ability could benefit us. If, for example, he wiretaps someone and figures out they were lying about their role etc. It's just unfortunate that it can hinder Town roles too. But I think he could be very useful so I don't want to vote him.
The 77/myuser thing is 50/50 for me since I kind of want to believe both of them.
Part of me wants to vote to lynch Notme due to his suspicious behaviour but I get the impression he acts like this a lot and I don't think many others would lynch him.
The fact that oog knows caff has watched Over the Garden Wall is interesting. It makes me think caff is perhaps the telegrapher, but then again we don't know if that role is bad or not. I just find it interesting that she denies it too.
But yeah, I'm stumped on what to do.
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
I don't particularly feel like lynching Oog as I think he's town. And Myuser's words have been pretty desperate which is either an elaborate scheme or genuinly annoyed we might lynch a town doctor. But it has me kind of convinced.
myusername22 I'm might be willing to take your word on the fact that there is only one doctor and that means 77 is lying about stuff, but the "Not Innocent" report me and my partner got is not working much in your favor so I'm not sure what to think. But if what you're telling is true then why are you voting Oog and not 77, if Oog is only a chance to get Mafia and 77 would be confirmed Mafia in your eyes?
myusername22 I'm might be willing to take your word on the fact that there is only one doctor and that means 77 is lying about stuff, but the "Not Innocent" report me and my partner got is not working much in your favor so I'm not sure what to think. But if what you're telling is true then why are you voting Oog and not 77, if Oog is only a chance to get Mafia and 77 would be confirmed Mafia in your eyes?
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
Well it depends on how you view the role I guess. Remember in Bloody Masquerade where I was a lie-detector. I believe I couldn't be roleblocked as it wasn't a visiting action or anything(if I remember right). Maybe the same thing applies to the Telemarketer?
Also no I don't classify Duffie as an "educated doctor" or a "doctor claim", since shes a jailer. So this "only one doctor" thing doesn't apply to her in my opinion.
Mooglie
The Local Cow
yes i agree with this but i still feeeel it
+ a theory that doesn't really make sense but it may explain why
cat targetted duffie on night 2 and from night 1 we can gather that the role has some sort of switchy-ability since a tracking report was received on night 1 instead of a watching report. since duffie is a jailer then what if that traveled over and cat ended up roleblocking *and* protecting duffie. the protection may be why there was such a lack of deaths and the roleblock may be why i got that telegraph if caff is the telegrammer. however, this doesn't make sense since i got the 'was not visited' second half meaning that the watching worked as well, but this might be because there was no report to overrule the watching report.
77 didn't explicitly claim doctor. His role could be part of something else. All I'm certain. Of is that either he or Duffie is lying because I doubt there are 3 protection roles. The odds of the town correctly lynching between us 3 are low, but its doubtful the mafia want all of us alive right up until endgame so its likely they will either kill one of us off or more information will surface in another way. As far as I'm concerned, this is a lynch for another day.
Besides, from my perspective 77 is a better lynch because I know we don't lose the town doctor, but that's not really an option. Let's say we force a lynch between the two of us... Who would you vote for? The one the cop reported as 'not inno' or the one the cop had no report on? Basically, I'd lose and there would still not be enough evidence to lynch 77 tomorrow ( seeing as he didn't explicitly claim doctor) we have no way of knowing this isn't town vs town and I don't want to waste 2 lynches on the bet that one of us is mafia when it could be Duffie.
Its still possible he was role blocked or something, and I find it very weird scum would claim to visit Erik just to kill me unless 77 were a lyncher role or something.
oh, and another thing
ooglie and cat's claims basically rely on each other to be true. correct me if i'm wrong, but nothing outside of the potato inn has been verified by anyone else. all evidence supporting one's claim has been provided by the other, and vice versa.
the potato bag thing might not even be real. it wasn't even mentioned to be a bag until after samlen died, flipping as "potato poisoner"
Also, if ooglie really did interfere with cat's reports, then wouldn't cat, as a town pr, recognize that as antitown and try to get him lynched?
Cat's reaction is too passive from my point of view.
The "cat suddenly turned into a tracker n1!!" claim is unverifiable and frankly sounds ridiculous.
tl;dr neither cat nor ooglie have any evidence to suggest their claim is true that isn't provided by the other.
ooglie and cat's claims basically rely on each other to be true. correct me if i'm wrong, but nothing outside of the potato inn has been verified by anyone else. all evidence supporting one's claim has been provided by the other, and vice versa.
the potato bag thing might not even be real. it wasn't even mentioned to be a bag until after samlen died, flipping as "potato poisoner"
Cat claims to be a simple watcher, but erik's already a watcher and cat would have caught ender's killer if she had watched him.
Also, if ooglie really did interfere with cat's reports, then wouldn't cat, as a town pr, recognize that as antitown and try to get him lynched?
Cat's reaction is too passive from my point of view.
The "cat suddenly turned into a tracker n1!!" claim is unverifiable and frankly sounds ridiculous.
tl;dr neither cat nor ooglie have any evidence to suggest their claim is true that isn't provided by the other.
No, cat claimed to watch ender but get turned into a tracker role. It's possible and more reasonable that jkang and ender were bussed by a driver-type role. Frankly that should have been the first explanation to come to mind.
But myu claims to kill any people visiting his target, and if cat watched jkang, then she'd be dead, according to his claim.
say there's this guy, carl, who has a night action
carl wants to use his action on alice
there is another guy, dave, who has a driver-bus action
he switches the "addresses" of alice and bob
carl tries to use his action on alice, but it is performed on bob instead
likewise, any actions attempted on bob are performed on alice
Interesting theory here: what If Ooglie is a town sided journalist following a mafia sided Journalist (forget the name of the mafia sided journalist role.) She can't claim journalist so she's forced to claim something silly like watcher, but couldn't deny that she had enders tracking report because Ooglie had seen it? Explains why she got no message, as duffie as jailer would probably not receive a message.
where is this duffie was roleblocked thing coming into play again? I must've missed it?
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Hunter But if they were switched wouldn't myuser have protected ender instead, and so he'd be alive? Or did myuser not claim to protect jk? Sorry I'm confused and my internet is too bad to let me look back at what people said right now D;
Mooglie
The Local Cow
um i'm not working with cat or anything
i would say i would use my action on a power role to confirm it but we've all seen how that turns out!
also i feel like everyone just let erik's ghost claim slide or was that a joke
i don't feel like ghosts belong in russian mafia
i would say i would use my action on a power role to confirm it but we've all seen how that turns out!
also i feel like everyone just let erik's ghost claim slide or was that a joke
i don't feel like ghosts belong in russian mafia
