Anvil Base [GAME OVER]

[Nottykitten]

I propose a lynching of Nottykitten. Any objections, concerns, or alternative courses of action?

How about we don't lynch the one claimed person.

 

[Hunter]

CaffeinatedKitty sup

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

??

Only comment: pls pls pls refer to Notty as Notty and not kitty because then I think you're talking about me and I just get confused ;-;

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

Or kitten or let's establish me as Caff or something I just want us to be referred to by different names ;-;

 

[Hunter]

ah okay i was wondering what you'd do
if notty were to be lynched would you endorse it or no

i dont like when d0 drags out for days on end

 

[MarsKid]

Look, so what if I was overzealous. I was just trying to get stuff started.

If you feel so threatened by me and getting so defensive then maybe you're mafia not wanting to be pointed out.

If you're all so infuriated with me than deal with it.

 

[Hunter]

marskid no
calm down

please don't do what i did last game on d0 and maybe take a few deep breaths

tbh none of us are mad (at least im not)

 

[MarsKid]

It seemed like you guys were and I was honestly sorry for pushing too hard :/

 

[The Road to Ruin]

Going to try and post my opinion as I read along (just finished page 11 and probably going to not read page 12 right away). I don't find anyone particularly suspicious right now. Hunter is really pushing a notty lynch but I don't think that really deviates from usual behavior from him, and to be fair I killed him (when he was a mafia) when I kamakized him by pushing without end and ended up being right. Notty's claim is unusual this early in the game, the reason for claiming makes sense on paper but rule #13 of mafia is never trust Notty. I cannot remember who exactly but I think it was Notty who claimed to be a soldier who had a one shot ability and I don't think anyone other than another soldier could know that right off the bat so I'm not too suspicious. The claim was a bad move and Hunter is a bad target though IMHO.

 

[Samlen]

Hmmm Notty, why again did you claim? You say that it was to prevent your lynching if you claim a kill later, but would you really have been in a different position then than now? If anything, you'd have a more viable chance to prove what you did, and maybe even the pirate would be dead by then (eliminating that as one of our suspicions of your role and making it more likely for us to believe you). And hey, if you killed an anti-town person, it would have been that much better and easier to believe you. BUT, claiming now has put some suspicion on you, and the terrorists now know of you, and if you really are what you say you are, then they could easily kill/roleblock you, making your role completely useless. Maybe it's just me, but I feel like it was not best idea to claim. I don't know yet if that actually makes me suspicious of you yet, but I do believe that the claim would have been better if it had not been made today.

 

[Hunter]

i was going to post a post but meh

anyone who uses wifom to justify a fake claim (or any action, really) should be lynched

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

Ugh apparently I accidentally unwatched the thread?? Idk

I'm kind of indifferent about whether or not to lynch Notty, but I'd honestly rather we all just keep talking and not end the day this soon. It's basically a free day to get information from everyone, and the only one we'll actually have. We might as well make it last.

 

[Hunter]

Ugh apparently I accidentally unwatched the thread?? Idk

I'm kind of indifferent about whether or not to lynch Notty, but I'd honestly rather we all just keep talking and not end the day this soon. It's basically a free day to get information from everyone, and the only one we'll actually have. We might as well make it last.

while i understand where you're coming from, generally the mafia benefit if this happens

because, unlike us, they can actually talk about the stuff and reach conclusions

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

Sooooo you're saying we aren't currently talking about stuff and reaching conclusions. Okay.

 

[Hunter]

no, i'm saying mafia have a night chat.
we don't

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

But we're more numerous and should technically be. able to come to our own conclusions without a night chat. Hell, we might actually have inns. Who knows.

 

[Hunter]

actually we don't have inns and this chat also includes mafia members

the only thing remotely close to an inn would be the commander council thing

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

How do you know? As far as I see the signup thread says nothing about them, and in the past we haven't known they existed until it reaches the night phase and WHOOPS HEY LOOK AN INN.

 

[Hunter]

Ltin are there inns? y/n/maybe

unless it's part of someone's hidden secondary role features, this is an openish setup

it's safe to assume there aren't any

but why are we even discussing inns the point is the more we talk the easier it is for maf to analyze posts to find out who's doc/cop/whatever

 

[Ltin]

Ltin are there inns? y/n/maybe

I very much dislike inns, so no.

 

[Hunter]

plus long day zeros suck because we got no info to share besides counterproductive roleclaims

aaaaaaaaaaand told you so caff, toooooold you there weren't any inns >:D

 

[CaffeinatedKitty]

Eh.
So you suggest we stop talking so mafia finds out jack shit at the consequence of the town also finding out jack shit.

 

[Timdood3]

I very much dislike inns, so no.

It's because of the strained pineapple, isn't it?

 

[Ltin]

It's because of the strained pineapple, isn't it?

no......
I just find them annoying and overused, atleast here.

 

[Hunter]

nah its just that town knows jack shit

anything we're able to share is in the role list.