Okay, first time in a few days that I've got to sit in front of my computer, so hopefully this post will be more concise than my previous ones.
HKCaper and
Unusual_Dood these four links below are from recent mafia games. In each one it takes one less vote to no lynch somebody than to lynch somebody, and as far as I can see(I did not play nor read these games) there is no silencer role of any type. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong about this.
https://escaperestart.com/forum/threads/the-bastard-game-day-5.20963/
https://escaperestart.com/forum/threads/waning-sunset-game-over-mafia-win.20838/
https://escaperestart.com/forum/threads/zuplar-invasion-game-over-town-win.20719/
https://escaperestart.com/forum/threads/lost-in-fog-game-over-town-win.20692/
Jivvi I do not understand why if you do not like HK's claim you would vote for me, the person pressuring him on his claim? I am not keen on outing who his floor member is, I do not care who his floor member is. HK has made a claim that could either easily be proven false or easily be proven true. If it is proven false, more likely than not we have found a bad guy. If it is proven true, than we can definitively know there is a silencer in the game(though I believe every alive player has said something this day, which insinuates this is false). Again, I will lay out a course of actions that could happen:
1.) HKCaper is innocent but does not tell us who his floor member is.
2.) His floor member is a mafia, gets spooked at the idea of HK outing him, and makes sure he night two.
I want to avoid this. (
Comp you said in a post that maybe both HK and his floor member could be mafia, but I think this is a valid option as well).
Ooglie101 as stated earlier in my post, I don't care who HK's room mate is, I care that we could get screwed out of possibly catching a mafia because we have an easily verifiable claim which is not being verified. It is really not good to not act on this lead.
TheWeakGuy48_ I am aggressive towards HK because of reasons stated above(he is refusing to provide proof for his claim)
I don't know what else I can really add. People say I am acting scummy because I am aggressive, but I am acting aggressive towards HKCaper because he has made a claim he refuses to provide concrete proof for(a second confirmation). I simply do not see a situation where not having that second person confirm his claim is advantageous to the town. I don't think it's wise to assume that there is some third party role that has a great advantage by knowing the room names/setups because we can't focus on the big what ifs. At this stage in the game we just have to find mafia members one by one and get them lynched or killed.
HK refuses to tell us who his floor mate is.
His floor mate refuses to step in and confirm the silencer role even though I am giving HKCaper so much shit for it.
In my eyes, one of these two players has to be scum.