EscapeRemastered Mafia: Economy of Madness [Day 3]

[Nottykitten]

but why is that a good thing

So they murder possible suspects from the non-CC pool which makes our job as town easier

 

[Mooglie]

So they murder possible suspects from the non-CC pool which makes our job as town easier

but theyre doing that regardless

 

[Stranger from Myst Island]

I can only use it once

That really doesn't change my opinion that this sounds overall scummy. Plus, if you have to get a bunch of money in order to even use this in the first place (which I doubt tbh, an item that only one role can purchase doesn't make a lot of sense imo) that gives people plenty of time to prepare in a smaller setup like this, especially if we're operating under the assumption that at least one of my tonics is an antidote.

what do you mean youve seen strangers things

It's ok Inffy, I already searched for fingerprints on my things and found your fingerprints all over them.

 

[Timdood3]

I hopped on to do a votecount but the votes haven't changed. Weird.
Deadline in about 21 hours.

 

[Nottykitten]

but theyre doing that regardless

They're not? We can say with almost certainty that 2/3 of the CC people are town. Can you grab 3 any random people from the non-CC pool and say the same thing?

 

[Mooglie]

They're not? We can say with almost certainty that 2/3 of the CC people are town. Can you grab 3 any random people from the non-CC pool and say the same thing?

failed change of subject
so if we lynch a CC, who are the mafia killing tonight?

 

[Nottykitten]

failed change of subject

its the same subject?

failed change of subject
so if we lynch a CC, who are the mafia killing tonight?

Well if they were scum then they murder a CC since they can't just leave 2 proven people alive and otherwise they murder from the non-CC pool

 

[Mooglie]

Well if they were scum then they murder a CC since they can't just leave 2 proven people alive and otherwise they murder from the non-CC pool

see this is a good point that youve quite literally never once said before in this entire argument

 

[Nottykitten]

see this is a good point that youve quite literally never once said before in this entire argument

I'm sorry I have to tell you that 2+2 = 4

 

[Mooglie]

I'm sorry I have to tell you that 2+2 = 4

except youve been driving this entire argument on the basis of 33/66 -> 50/50 therefore limiting the scope of the conversation

 

[Nottykitten]

except youve been driving this entire argument on the basis of 33/66 -> 50/50 therefore limiting the scope of the conversation

I've been driving this argument on the basis that lynching from the non-CC pool is obviously better

 

[Nottykitten]

I've been driving this argument on the basis that lynching from the non-CC pool is obviously better

And Inf's been driving it on the basis that he can't read

 

[Mooglie]

I've been driving this argument on the basis that lynching from the non-CC pool is obviously better

And Inf's been driving it on the basis that he can't read

on the contrary you expected us to be smart people and use our brains instead of easily laying out your entire argument!

 

[Alisha]

im interested in your read of stranger

a bit more serious than usual so she’s adjusting her playstyle compared to previous games. I think she’s evolving how she plays but I can’t tell if that’s in a town or scum way right now.

 

[Nottykitten]

on the contrary you expected us to be smart people and use our brains instead of easily laying out your entire argument!

I expect nothing less from the best Mafia player in the world and felt it was obvious that lynching from a pool of essentially 2/3 confirmed innocent people is bad

 

[Infected_alien8_]

You're mistaking a descriptive for a prescriptive here inf.

Looking at the quotes without really giving a shit about the bickering but knowing full well notty's scum, it definitely reads as if she's just saying 'this is the case' rather than 'we should do x because this is the case'

no because notty saying those things was in response to me asking 'why'

 

[Mooglie]

I expect nothing less from the best Mafia player in the world

on a completely unrelated note, ive decided that notty is confirmed innocent :)

 

[Unusual_Dood]

unvote

vote notty

 

[Nottykitten]

unvote

vote notty

Thanks I really do want to die after 3 pages of nonsense

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I expect nothing less from the best Mafia player in the world and felt it was obvious that lynching from a pool of essentially 2/3 confirmed innocent people is bad

wow its almost like me and oog disagreeing meant that it wasnt obvious to us and that you shouldve explained your point instead of literally not saying it ever!!

 

[Nottykitten]

wow its almost like me and oog disagreeing meant that it wasnt obvious to us and that you shouldve explained your point instead of literally not saying it ever!!

I felt I did say it and you just pulled the wrong conclusion from it

Anyways do you agree now that lynching from the CC pool is bad and if so are you gonna murder me

 

[Infected_alien8_]

btw Unusual_Dood you rated my post agree where i said i didnt wanna lynch twg, why dont you?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

I felt I did say it and you just pulled the wrong conclusion from it

you very much didnt say that you just said 'the cc people wont die at night' without elaborating on why that was good for town

and then denying you said it even when i showed you saying it

Anyways do you agree now that lynching from the CC pool is bad and if so are you gonna murder me

i mean i always agreed lynching between item people wasnt the best course of action since we can see what their items do

idk who i want to lynch

i find your defence of sessy extremely weird though

 

[Nottykitten]

you very much didnt say that you just said 'the cc people wont die at night' without elaborating on why that was good for town

and then denying you said it even when i showed you saying it


i mean i always agreed lynching between item people wasnt the best course of action since we can see what their items do

idk who i want to lynch

i find your defence of sessy extremely weird though

It's not a defense, more just me not really caring to lynch them. What can we gain from lynching Sessy vs lynching me/Weak?

 

[Infected_alien8_]

It's not a defense, more just me not really caring to lynch them. What can we gain from lynching Sessy vs lynching me/Weak?

what do we gain if youre innocent besides knowing that the black market exists (which doesnt prove twg lying since he couldve easily not been told its called 'The Black Market' as a townie cuz i dont see why he wouldnt confirm its existance as a scum since its not in character for him to lie for no reason as scum imo!)

if twg is innocent once again we dont gain anything other than knowing either his role was relying on oog's or theres more ways to get coins which we'll know anyway soon

i dont think lynching between you/twg gets us much if youre town anyway so then it becomes just 'whos more likely to be scum'