1) maybe he just has a good memory!!!!!!!!! or is extrapolating from last game
2) idk what this is about (i read your guyses thing about stranger being 3p -> boo is bad for questioning then stranger being town -> boo is good for questioning but idk how this makes him scummy)
3) maybe hes just lazy!
4) i didnt pay attention that on day 0! all i remember is him getting annoyed/frustrated
5) isnt it the same as your argument other than the early reads thing
1) i guess but doubt he has that good a memory and also feels so confident about his reads even though from his pov he knows we've been away from him for ages and thus could easily have changed!
2) 'doubting 3p makes little sense, so boo is susp. oh wow stranger is town, so boo was right, and actually boo's doubting is reasonable and makes sense now.' do you not agree that makes no sense at all = either just logical error or fake read (and i lean fake read cuz i doubt mars would make that logical error tbh, i think he thought he could get away with it)
3) hes clearly not!
4) ok well he was way too eager to accuse people of not contributing properly early on when like nothing was happening. he himself had no reads yet called hk out for not having any for example. and it felt like trying to replicate his town behaviour but accidentally going too extreme to me
5) no?? they said his random vote on hk is sus (why would a random vote be sus to town notty, theyd see it as a reaction test most likely, i dont buy at all notty saw mars vote hk and thought 'wow scummy') and "strange conflicts" which is extremely vague and not like town notty imo!