yeah I worded that badly. After Alisha claimed, she was obviously trusted and not gonna be cc, so instead you townread her (which makes sense) but then you shifted it around and went for Stranger, like you almost had to find someone to suspect.
[Game Over] Just Your Average Mafia Game
- Thread starter Ltin
- Start date
- Status
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Okay but I changed back to town reading her shortly after, so if my goal was to find a new suspect I ruined that plan myself right after
Also I already had sessy and tim as suspects by that point too so why would I need to have a third specifically?
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Just my feelings changed after I mulled it over really, my reaction to you being cop was to find her suspicious in spite of how I'd felt she was town earlier, but then after a while the feeling that she was scum if you were town disappeared and the old feelings I had of her being town came back
VOTECOUNT The free lunch is now available. We have cut out the most infested parts of the meat, so that probably won't make you too sick. Strained pineapple is also available for sale, but none of you can actually afford it.
Sessybessy - [1] - {Timdood3};
Timdood3 - [2] - {Infected_alien8_, Stranger from Planet 9};
With 9 players it takes 5 to lynch and 5 to no-lynch.
The deadline is 12:00 Central, 17:00 GMT, on Tuesday, July 16th.
24 hours until deadline.
Sessybessy - [1] - {Timdood3};
Timdood3 - [2] - {Infected_alien8_, Stranger from Planet 9};
With 9 players it takes 5 to lynch and 5 to no-lynch.
The deadline is 12:00 Central, 17:00 GMT, on Tuesday, July 16th.
24 hours until deadline.
yeah that is a good point, I suppose it was the post that caught my attention
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
Well stranger wouldn't have been budding with you since it was you agreeing with her after she'd given those opinions on her own, she didn't agree with you on anything that she hadn't said already
I think initially I thought stranger was scum if you were cop since I thought both of you seemed a bit scummy but stranger also felt townie and you felt more scummy, and I didn't think you were both mafia, so I ended up thinking only one of you was mafia and the other either sk or town. And since I thought you were mafia, and not partnered with stranger, that meant I thought stranger was sk or town, but out of those two options I thought town was much more likely since she didn't seem worried about getting into the spotlight like an sk would, so I town read her
Then when you claimed cop I think my reaction was to think 'okay that leaves stranger open to being mafia now and I bet she is!!' but then I mulled it over and thought 'well actually that conclusion doesn't really have much logic to it, I still feel she felt quite townie before, and yeah it feels right having her as town actually' so changed my mind
I'll pay you 100 Alphacoins for the Python
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
as in I was just responding to your question about whether stranger could've been budding with you here, but I wasn't even thinking about this at the time of me changing my mind on her back then
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
well the whole 'would stranger buddy alisha' had nothing to do with me changing my mind on her, I was just answering your question about if I could see a scenario where she buddied you
I scumread stranger since it was how I felt, I wasn't sure why I felt that way though, but I was trying to mull over it to figure it out
Then I changed my mind since I realized scumreading her didn't have logic to it and my feelings about her being townie before returned
Looking back, I think I originally felt she was scum after you claimed cop because part of why I town read her was because I thought (a) you were mafia and (b) you and stranger aren't likely to both be mafia and (c) stranger isn't sk, so therefore stranger would be town. So then when you turned town, stranger was allowed to be mafia again, and I think that's where my feeling came from
Then I mulled it over to try to understand why I felt that way and realized I couldn't find any logic for it, and as I realized that, my feelings of her being town returned to me
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
(as in, I realized that 'stranger is allowed to be mafia again' wasn't enough to justify actually believing she was mafia, especially considering she did feel townie at some points, so then my town feeling of her returned and kinda took over)
- Status