A unu mislynch would be a lot worse than a sinner mislynch though. I feel like you might be trying to set up a saint mislynch so tomorrow could be a MYLO situation where people are still clueless.
Mafia: Saints & Sinners - GAME OVER MAFIA WIN
- Thread starter Stranger from Myst Island
- Start date
- Status
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
if you believe this then why were you wanting to lynch skele instead of a sinner claim, since a skele mislynch would also be worse than a sinner mislynch
unu can never be proven alignment, so he's going to be a questionmark for the entire game if he's left alive. id rather get rid of a questionmark now, instead of in a mylo situation, which we could easily be in for the rest of the game if we mislynch today, regardless of whether its a sinner or a saint. with the sinners theres at least a chance aqua can prove one of them town so wasting a mislynch on one when they couldve been proven otherwise feels like a waste of what could be our last lynch where it's not mylo
but yeah, like i said earlier, numbers wise if we lynch 2 sinners today the likelihood of us correctly lynching is really in our favour, but im pretty confident 3 of you/unu/beta/twg are scum anyways so regardless of which of you we lynch, as long as we lynch 2 of you we should lynch scum in the next 2 days anyway
Because I am more confident about Skele flipping scum plus if I see him flip scum I am almost sure Aqua is town. Unu flip will give us barely any information about the other people and put us in a very uncomfortable spot tomorrow if he is town. Sure we can be in a MYLO situation for the next days regardless if we mislynch now but if we guarantee a scum lynch tomorrow it will give us at least 2 more days. In those 2 days mafia will have to kill some people off which narrows down the suspects. Starting tomorrow we will have a lot better idea of how the game works based on this lynch and the night kill.
I've been getting pretty suspicious of inffy now, because I feel like there is a good chance only 1 in that list happen to be scum. Regardless I've made up my mind now that I want to focus on sinners today and Weak is IMO the best target though I'm willing to switch to Beta if people prefer that. Tomorrow one of remaining sinners can be cleared.
unvote
vote TheWeakGuy
Votecount 4: Moar Votes
Good Skele - Aqua [L-5]Unusual_Dood - Infected_Alien8_, Alisha [L-4]
Vatumok - Good Skele [L-5]
TheWeakGuy48_ - Vatumok [L-5]
With 10 players alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch and 5 votes to no lynch. If nobody reaches a majority of votes by the end of the day, nobody will be lynched.
Day 2 Deadline
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
guess i was right and you and UNU are scum buddies huh
very convenient how all of a sudden when UNU is up for a lynch, you suddenly have a well thought out argument for why lynching sinners is better than lynching saints (which is the 1 argument you can possibly use to defend UNU), despite wanting to lynch a saint before that
you say skele was an exception because youre more confident in him flipping scum but if you truly believe lynching sinners has a good chance of guaranteeing us a scum lynch and buying us 2 more days, your read on skele shouldn't matter unless you were very vconfident, and you definitely weren't, because you were "worried", remember
sure its possible you just hadnt thought of this line of thought now but the timing is too convenient and i dont buy it
why?
So you suddenly want to lynch people from your townie list. ok
And the same argument can be brought up against Skele, except if hes town we will also learn vats role. So, unless we're in a mylo which i highly doubt we should lynch skele.
vote good skele
now back to studying.
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
turns out your name is in the bible so those townie points are gone again
and i townread skele so it cant be brought up against skele no (and his role claim is that it only works if he's killed at night so we wont learn vat's role)
i didnt say theres no way mafia would have a messenger role, i said a messenger role is useless for both teams, so its not indicative of his alignment
idm switching to vat at this point either, but if im wrong abut vat you can prove it tomorrow so i don't want to be stubborn and ignore that, but like i said if unu cant get the numbers ill vote vat
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
Yeah unproven, and I still trust beta as do a lot of people. I'll flip a coin and pick between TWG and Vat tonight, if they flip poor sinner I guess we lynch the other.
Idk how I feel about the unu lynch, good skele seems to have far less going for there as there is no evidence to support there role existing
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
i dont get why you trust beta and i think you/others are overlooking them/underestimating them
id rather vat than twg considering vat's been scummy this whole game but twg's just a blank slate
still my gut says skele is town
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
vibes, plus their instantaneous reaction to the poor sinner thing without prompting seemed too genuine. Even I wouldn't think to do that in that scenario if I was mafia AND had access to the poor sinner name (which, unless mafia has their own poor sinners, I doubt they do.)
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
so then surely it would be better to visit TWG, and if he flips town, lynch vat?
It's more likely vat is scum when TWG is town than it is for TWG to be scum when vat is town.
...
Infected_alien8_
Garry's Mod Admin
i read it as "oh heres something i can contribute" because that wouldve been one of few pieces of info they felt they could share to be helpful, and i can easily see them doing that as scum
id already called them out on not contributing much
wat
...yes? my personal opinion is people are sussing skele even though hes town but people are ignoring beta when he might be scum
and hk!
Aqua
Does anybody remember laughter?
my person opinion is that you are sussing beta while you're ignoring skele when he might be scum...?
I can't tell if you're joking or you actually can't see the irony
Good Skele
Member
I guess you're really not reading what is being said here.
- Status