Mafia: Saints & Sinners - GAME OVER MAFIA WIN

Status
Not open for further replies.

HKCaper

Almighty Goat
Joined
Oct 21, 2014
Messages
110
Reaction score
1,197
i'm sorry, i should have said some more.

so ye, as said, i claimed doc, was on aqua n1 (no nightkill n1), sessy n2 (f blocked), aqua n3 (f blocked).

i already said yesterday 'IF IF IF vat flips town, maf is inf, twg, skele'. why? i already trusted aqua 100% and consequently tim and alisha, since aqua is basically a poor sinner cop role. now aqua flipped town that has only been confirmed. I trust beta, for the same reason aqua trusts beta, the way they claimed things about poor sinner day 0 (day 0 is important here, because mafia team couldnt have helped beta yet). that leaves unu,twg,skele,and inf for maf. of these i already think unu is more likely town.

that leaves the options (not considering i think unu is town)
-unu,skele,inf
-unu,skele,twg
these options dont look promising. the first means 3/5 saint claims were false, and only 2 saints in the game. the second one i dont trust because (sorry) i dont believe skele could have come up with that claim without either inf of vat on his team.

-unu, inf, twg
-inf,skele,twg
these could both be options, but as i said i trust unu over skele for 1) his role is confirmed, even tho a messenger role is weak eitherway. 2) i didnt trust skele's claim from the start, since it cannot be confirmed, and conveniently doesnt work with lynches. so this deduction leads me to believe inf and twg are scum 100%, and likely skele is the third.

ofcourse this all assumes im town, and i can only hope you see that even tho i was a strong advocate in both the fog and vat lynch (both deserved it ngl, aqua agrees). the strongest thing i have going for me is that there was no nightkill n1, which is explained by my protect on aqua n1. there are other options, but even inf agrees they are unlikely.

anyway ye we should just lynch inf. i wanted to do it at day start, but waited for tim to reveal his info, since it seemed he had something brewing.
 

BetaPanda

Member
Joined
Apr 21, 2014
Messages
29
Reaction score
171
ah deadline is soon-ish already it seems

1 day 13 hours from now. please dont wait too long with deciding who to vote, im not looking forward to last minute chaos.
i just realized that there are 8 players left
there’s 3-4 mafias and 4-5 townies, if we mislynch - the mafia will get an advantage via vote in the next day
 

TheWeakGuy48_

Geezuslike
Donor
Mafia Host
Joined
Dec 31, 2012
Messages
218
Reaction score
785
I'm more inclined to believe HKC over Inffy, simply because HKC actually has an explanation as to why there were no deaths during the first night. The only ways I see HKC lying is if 1. Mafia didn't kill anyone (which in 99% of cases isn't worth it, esp in a small closed setup), or 2. there are some other role that prevented a mafia kill, like a town roleblocker or a bulletproof (which nobody has claimed). I doesn't make any sense for me that the mafia would intentionally choose to not kill, hence I trust HKC more.

Besides, I don't believe that Inffy has actually confirmed his ability (can someone confirm this)?
I've been wrong many many times before this about lynching, but idk it feels like there's only a really slim possibility that Inf is town when you think about it (His and Aqua's role coexisting, HKC lying etc, his action not being provable(again is this correct?)).
 

Timdood3

Member
Mafia Host
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
2,339
Reaction score
2,824
I'm more inclined to believe HKC over Inffy, simply because HKC actually has an explanation as to why there were no deaths during the first night. The only ways I see HKC lying is if 1. Mafia didn't kill anyone (which in 99% of cases isn't worth it, esp in a small closed setup), or 2. there are some other role that prevented a mafia kill, like a town roleblocker or a bulletproof (which nobody has claimed). I doesn't make any sense for me that the mafia would intentionally choose to not kill, hence I trust HKC more.

Besides, I don't believe that Inffy has actually confirmed his ability (can someone confirm this)?
I've been wrong many many times before this about lynching, but idk it feels like there's only a really slim possibility that Inf is town when you think about it (His and Aqua's role coexisting, HKC lying etc, his action not being provable(again is this correct?)).
It is correct that his ability is unproven.
 

Infected_alien8_

Garry's Mod Admin
Mafia Host
Joined
Jul 29, 2012
Messages
1,760
Reaction score
6,243
I trust beta, for the same reason aqua trusts beta, the way they claimed things about poor sinner day 0 (day 0 is important here, because mafia team couldnt have helped beta yet).
people seriously need to stop underestimating beta

I trust HK over inf ngl. They can't have blocked both and it makes much more sense for them to have blocked a doctor.

Who was a better choice then?
we cant be both blocked but you couldve been driven/your track interfered with, and then i couldve been blocked instead of hk

or there could be a driver 1-shot who redirected me onto someone else, and a block who blocked hk

goodbye inf, im certainly not lynching the person who protected a confirmed town

vote Infected_Alien8_
it doesnt have to be me or hk

It is correct that his ability is unproven.
yes ive been framed and why would i claim i could undo your deal if i was maf and knew i couldnt do it rather than something else
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top