Mafia Season 5

[77thShad]

Lets look at everyone so far shall we?

Nitasu987 Suspected Mafia- Fairly active, some believe he is a mafia
77_is_the_best Unconfirmed- You guys are the judge of that
Hockeyfan1852 Unconfirmed- Hasn't really been discussing, just been helping other with understanding (if you look over the last few pages). He is voting Oak since he would rather lose a bullet proof civ than a cop.
Defiant_blob Suspicions of mafia however Notty says he is civilian- Very cpnfusing, climed cop day 1 and then the next day said he wasn't the cop.
zezmi- Unconfirmed- Being very logical, suspicious of the Notty, Defiant duo.
Dessern5 Claimed Civilian- Wants to lynch notty and work out to lynch from there (Defiant/Sploorky)
prizyms Unconfirmed- Way inactive/quiet. cant really say anything about you.
Sploorky Confirmed Vigilante- Super suspicious of the notty, defiant duo. Pretty much leading the lynch on notty.
Mariosatr Unconfirmed- Changing votes a lot between Abstain and Oak. Hasn't really been discussing othger than his votes.
Digitalmez Unconfirmed- Quieter player, cant really base much on you either.
Old_man_oak_63 Bulletproof civ/skeleton- Much discussion on whether he is a skeleton or bulletproof civilian since he was hit last night and he survived.
HarmakPaul Unconfirmed- Putting his opinions in here and there, could be any role at this stage.
Endersteve5 Confirmed Lyncher- Just really part of the crowd right now, cant win.
Kraby1 Unconfirmed- Another quiet player, cant really say much.
Nottykitten Claimed cop but may still be Contact- Defending defiant before but claimed cop when he was near being lynched, defiant has been defending him since.
Balloon98 Unconfirmed- Will find more out when he posts his opinion when he wakes up.
Vati180 Unconfirmed- Hasn't really contributed much recently that I have taken note of, made a flawed plan a couple of posts ago or something xP

 

[mariosatr]

Vote count

Nottykitten - 6 (Dessern, Old_Man_Oak_63, Sploorky, Endersteve 5, 77_Is_the_best, zezmi)
Old_Man_Oak_63 - 4 (Nottykitten, Defiant_blob, mariosatr, Hockeyfan)
Abstain - 1 ( Nitasu)

Havent voted
vati180
HarmakPaul
Prizyms
digitalmez
kraby1
balloon98

Wow, I AM bad at making decisions... I abstain.

Just something you missed nothing much though, another abstain doesn't actually make a huge difference at this point to either side.

 

[Dess]

I'm the vigilante...

I know you claim that but I am still suspicious

 

[77thShad]

I know you claim that but I am still suspicious

Notty has also confirmed, who I believe is a definite cop/contact.

 

[Enderfive]

Whoa whoa whoa! 8 pages while I'm gone? *sigh*

Some serious twists here. I'm too sick to think straight right now, but I won't withdraw my vote for Notty.
Also, vati could've been right if he said I sided with the mafia (not saying I did though =P), since I have already lost anyway and could just be fooling you all.

 

[Nottykitten]

Whoa whoa whoa! 8 pages while I'm gone? *sigh*

Some serious twists here. I'm too sick to think straight right now, but I won't withdraw my vote for Notty.
Also, vati could've been right if he said I sided with the mafia (not saying I did though =P), since I have already lost anyway and could just be fooling you all.

If you vote for the cop you are always helping the mafia ^_^

But as said. The votes now rely on what the inactive and non-voters will vote. I guess its just waiting.

 

[Prizyms]

77_is_the_best I usually don't post much D1-D2 because anything one says can and will be used against them, especially right at the beginning of a game.

 

[Oak Milk]

If you vote for the cop you are always helping the mafia ^_^

But as said. The votes now rely on what the inactive and non-voters will vote. I guess its just waiting.

Hmmm, notty your claim as either the cop or the contact is undisputeble at this point, however something has come to my attention though that makes me doubt my own opinion on the subject, so I'd like to draw your attention to this.

Ok heres a scenario: If we lynch old_man_oak and he turns out to be the elite civilian, what will we do, Nottykitten who will you investigate tonight?

I have a feeling dess iss a power role. Either good or bad. So him. [Unless I suddenly get a better feeling]

Whoa what, first off I am a civilian. Secondly if we lynch notty and are wrong lets lynch sploorky since he seems the main person pushing notty. If right lynch defiant.

Now I want to see what you make of it.

 

[Nottykitten]

Hmmm, notty your claim as either the cop or the contact is undisputeble at this point, however something has come to my attention though that makes me doubt my own opinion on the subject, so I'd like to draw your attention to this.



Now I want to see what you make of it.

What I make of it is that dess could be a mafia. Which is why I want to investigate him tonight.

 

[Oak Milk]

What I make of it is that dess could be a mafia. Which is why I want to investigate him tonight.

True, but why does Dess want to lynch Sploorky next if you turn out to be the cop when its quite clear it was my idea in the first place AND that Sploorky's role has already been determined as the Vigalante?

 

[Dess]

Investigate me you gain nothing.

 

[Oak Milk]

Investigate me you gain nothing.

So then what's the problem, your role is verified, end of story.

 

[Sploorky]

I know you claim that but I am still suspicious

Notty confirmed my role, and I'm un cc'd.

Also, to everyone....why let notty live? Sorry, but a lot of evidence points to him being mafia, you can't deny that. Also if notty is the contact, why would he cooperate with the town? This, and if we give him another night to look, that means I(the confirmed vigilante) die next night.

 

[HarmakAnna]

How about this.

If notty is the contact, then we would have him reveal the roles of the people that he checks at night in order to pose as the cop.. While he would still be helping the mafia, assuming that he is one, he could still be telling us who's not mafia from who he investigates so it would narrow it down.

 

[Sploorky]

How about this.

If notty is the contact, then we would have him reveal the roles of the people that he checks at night in order to pose as the cop.. While he would still be helping the mafia, assuming that he is one, he could still be telling us who's not mafia from who he investigates so it would narrow it down.

he can lie, say his mafia friends are safe. He's not to be trusted

 

[Vatowski]

How about this.

If notty is the contact, then we would have him reveal the roles of the people that he checks at night in order to pose as the cop.. While he would still be helping the mafia, assuming that he is one, he could still be telling us who's not mafia from who he investigates so it would narrow it down.

he could also lie about his fellow mafia members roles if he is he contact by saying that they are civilians

 

[HarmakAnna]

Eh, now I'm stumped. :/

I'm not gonna vote for notty because my hunch is somewhat strong that he's the actual cop and because of our history of lynching the cop. I'm not gonna defend him anymore either because I don't have anything else to say.

 

[Nottykitten]

Notty confirmed my role, and I'm un cc'd.

Also, to everyone....why let notty live? Sorry, but a lot of evidence points to him being mafia, you can't deny that. Also if notty is the contact, why would he cooperate with the town? This, and if we give him another night to look, that means I(the confirmed vigilante) die next night.

Why not let me live. Could you tell me the evidence? Maybe it will light things up for people. Or atleast me.

 

[Sploorky]

I haaave. You, defiant, and nitasu all protecting each other(before you claimed cop, at that). You not taking into account that defiant could be the godfather when he claimed cop, and vice versa of him not thinking you could be contact. You not wanting to out my role to the town. Etc etc.


Also Road to ruin, prizyms voted abstain.

I will abstain, due to the fact that I don't really know who to vote for.

 

[Nottykitten]

I haaave. You, defiant, and nitasu all protecting each other(before you claimed cop, at that). You not taking into account that defiant could be the godfather when he claimed cop, and vice versa of him not thinking you could be contact. You not wanting to out my role to the town. Etc etc.


Also Road to ruin, prizyms voted abstain.

Not wanting to out my role was to help the town. Revealing the vig was a bad idea if I didnt have to. Because the mafia would know who the vig is.

 

[kraby1]

I sort of re-read the last 10 or so pages of this thread, and came to the conclusion that:

1. I'm too inactive ._.
2. I am not sure if I should vote notty since I don't find him really that suspicious, yyyyes there is a few mysteries he/she (damn i still dont know what gender notty is) holds behind her/his back. I realize the voting counts are quite mixed, with few people voting for abstaining, few for notty and a few (if im not wrong) for oak. I really don't want to do this, but I think I will have to Abstain since I have mixed feelings about lynching both notty and oak.

Abstaining

 

[Nottykitten]

I sort of re-read the last 10 or so pages of this thread, and came to the conclusion that:

1. I'm too inactive ._.
2. I am not sure if I should vote notty since I don't find him really that suspicious, yyyyes there is a few mysteries he/she (damn i still dont know what gender notty is) holds behind her/his back. I realize the voting counts are quite mixed, with few people voting for abstaining, few for notty and a few (if im not wrong) for oak. I really don't want to do this, but I think I will have to Abstain since I have mixed feelings about lynching both notty and oak.

Abstaining

Just know that by abstaining you are raising the chance that I will be lynched. And you are abstaining because you are not sure yet. Dont abstain! =3

 

[zezmi]

I sort of re-read the last 10 or so pages of this thread, and came to the conclusion that:

1. I'm too inactive ._.
2. I am not sure if I should vote notty since I don't find him really that suspicious, yyyyes there is a few mysteries he/she (damn i still dont know what gender notty is) holds behind her/his back. I realize the voting counts are quite mixed, with few people voting for abstaining, few for notty and a few (if im not wrong) for oak. I really don't want to do this, but I think I will have to Abstain since I have mixed feelings about lynching both notty and oak.

Abstaining

Does that mean notty is lynched? 17 players: 9 = majority, so 6 votes for notty and 3 abstains, that means 9 votes for notty. Also doesn't the mayor have 2 votes?

Sorry I have been gone, (I have to sleep some time).

So this is how I see things unraveling:

We lynch the contact today (notty)
In the night the doctor saves the vigilante (sploorky)
In the night the viligante kills Oak who may be the serial killer.
---other unknown events of the night---
Day 3 we lynch either Defiant, nitasu, or another suspect.

 

[The Road to Ruin]

Does that mean notty is lynched? 17 players: 9 = majority, so 6 votes for notty and 3 abstains, that means 9 votes for notty. Also doesn't the mayor have 2 votes?

Sorry I have been gone, (I have to sleep some time).

So this is how I see things unraveling:

We lynch the contact today (notty)
In the night the doctor saves the vigilante (sploorky)
In the night the viligante kills Oak who may be the serial killer.
---other unknown events of the night---
Day 3 we lynch either Defiant, nitasu, or another suspect.

Abstain removes someone from the equation, with three abstains there are fourteen players voting which requires eight players to lynch, and yes the mayor has two votes

 

[HarmakAnna]

I just thought of something that can't be undone.

If notty knew the vig was you, Sploor, and he never said it, then couldn't we have used that as a test regarding if he was cop or contact, since the vig is a role we want protected?

I'm just speaking with hindsight now, though.