Mafia Season 5
- Thread starter The Road to Ruin
- Start date
- Status
Old_Man_Oak_63 endersteve5 Why? I get yer suspicious and all, but we all are suspicious of everyone.
Look. I had a relevation. Defiant Probably isn't the godfather (Or maybe he is) <--- That's why I wanted to vote for Def.
Also, I wanted to vote Oak because HE seemed the most suspicious besides Dess, Notty, and Defiant. (and cuz most everyone was voting for him, so I just decided to switch because I realized that Oak prolly is hiding something. NOT JUST to vote for the sake of voting.)
Look. I had a relevation. Defiant Probably isn't the godfather (Or maybe he is) <--- That's why I wanted to vote for Def.
Also, I wanted to vote Oak because HE seemed the most suspicious besides Dess, Notty, and Defiant. (and cuz most everyone was voting for him, so I just decided to switch because I realized that Oak prolly is hiding something. NOT JUST to vote for the sake of voting.)
Enderfive
sarcasm incarnate
And about that "I could be a cop as well"... anyone could. It's just not likely. If you were the cop, why didn't you say anything when Defiant claimed he's the cop. Or when Notty claimed he's the cop? I'll tell you why. Because you're not the cop.
Sploorky
Member
Um
Why has noone paid attention to this?I know that I haven't contributed much to this discussion, but believe me when I say that I've read through all the posts and feel like my own personal "detective". Make of that what you will.
I don't think Digi would do that. She put it in quotes, therefore meaning she's not. She's just trying to play detective on her own. Although I find her more suspicious because she'd have claimed cop and notty has as well.
Road's bookmark
Nottykitten - 3 (Sploorky, HarmakPaul, zezmi)
Old_Man_Oak_63 - 4 (Nitasu, Nottykitten, Defiant_blob, Hockeyfan)
Abstain - 2 (pryzims, mariosatr)
Nitasu - 4 (Endersteve 5,Dessern, Old_Man_Oak_63, balloon98)
Nottykitten - 3 (Sploorky, HarmakPaul, zezmi)
Old_Man_Oak_63 - 4 (Nitasu, Nottykitten, Defiant_blob, Hockeyfan)
Abstain - 2 (pryzims, mariosatr)
Nitasu - 4 (Endersteve 5,Dessern, Old_Man_Oak_63, balloon98)
zezmi
The noob himself
Reading all the new posts I see that some pretty strange logic has been implemented.
as I see it:
Notty is still contact.
Defiant is still godfather.
I change my mind about Old and now think he is serial killer.
So the events of the day should be: the town lynches notty (the contact). In the night the vigilante (sploorky) kills Oak. The doctor saves sploorky. The next day the town lynches Defiant.
This is how I am afraid it will turn out: In the day we lynch non Mafia. In the night the vigilante attacks notty. In the night the doctor saves the vigilante. In the day we lynch non Mafia
(I will be gone today mostly)
as I see it:
Notty is still contact.
Defiant is still godfather.
I change my mind about Old and now think he is serial killer.
So the events of the day should be: the town lynches notty (the contact). In the night the vigilante (sploorky) kills Oak. The doctor saves sploorky. The next day the town lynches Defiant.
This is how I am afraid it will turn out: In the day we lynch non Mafia. In the night the vigilante attacks notty. In the night the doctor saves the vigilante. In the day we lynch non Mafia
(I will be gone today mostly)
Nottykitten
Nomnomnom kitteh!
While for you that might seem ok. It is not. At all.
If oak gets killed at night he can still kill 1 other person. While if he dies today he can't kill another person.
And if sploor kills me tonight then he pretty much killed an ally. Which I hope he won't.
That's what I've been saying the whole time. Spare the night another death by lyncing oak now.
Guys, Look at what Zezmi said. The way we're doing it, we're going to let the mafia win. There's a lot of doubt on either side that Notty is mafia/cop, but it seems to me that we are all sure that Old_Man is the Serial Killer, so If we lynch him, then that's one less thing we need to worry about, right?
- Status