Mafia Season 5

[Defiant_Blob]

In fact, Sploorky, you are not confirmed vigilante unless Nottykitten is the cop.
If Nottykitten is the contact, you could simply be working with him right now as a mafia member to make you look clear.

 

[Sploorky]

I've given my reasoning toward believing notty is mafia multiple times. Noone has given reasoning towards oak being the killer besides "he has two hits".

And I'm un cc'd.

 

[nitasu987]

Defiant_Blob yeah..... I see what you're saying. There really isn't any proof that you/notty are power roles.
Sploorky , however, IS confirmed as the Vigilante unless he's being a sneaky Sploorky and lying. The proof, though, that I go off of for Old's Serial Killer Role is that it's merely what has been said by many. I'm not usually one to be the following sheep type, but in this case, that's mainly the reason I vote for Oak. I suggest you fine gentlemen/pigs/blobs/other do the same.

 

[nitasu987]

I've given my reasoning toward believing notty is mafia multiple times. Noone has given reasoning towards oak being the killer besides "he has two hits".

And I'm un cc'd.

That's one reason. Either that or he's the elite civ. I'd say with the way things went on night one, it's more likely he's the SK.

 

[Sploorky]

what happened on night one .-. The killer either tried to attack him or defiant

 

[Defiant_Blob]

And I'm un cc'd.

I wonder who else is unCC'd. Totally not Nottykitten. Oh wait, it IS Nottykitten.

 

[HarmakAnna]

...What's a CC?

 

[Defiant_Blob]

...What's a CC?

Counterclaim.
E.G. someone claims doc. I counterclaim that I am doc.

 

[Sploorky]

He was un cc'd at the point I told the real cop not to claim. But look, the real cop has claimed

I know that I haven't contributed much to this discussion, but believe me when I say that I've read through all the posts and feel like my own personal "detective". Make of that what you will.

 

[Defiant_Blob]

He was un cc'd at the point I told the real cop not to claim. But look, the real cop has claimed

I know that I haven't contributed much to this discussion, but believe me when I say that I've read through all the posts and feel like my own personal "detective". Make of that what you will.

They were joking around. Do you really think that's a real cop claim or are you just grasping at straws?

They never confirmed anything.

If they were really detective, why not claim straight out than use riddles?

 

[nitasu987]

I personally think Defiant is lying. Just a hunch. I believe I remember you saying you were a civilian. Not sure if you said that or not.


Also, Sploorky, that could have been the mafia attacking old and old attacking Defiant.

 

[Nottykitten]

I personally think Defiant is lying. Just a hunch. I believe I remember you saying you were a civilian. Not sure if you said that or not.


Also, Sploorky, that could have been the mafia attacking old and old attacking Defiant.

He was making an example, not saying hes the cop.

 

[nitasu987]

oh. I see

 

[Defiant_Blob]

oh. I see

Hence the E.G, "exempli gratia", for the sake of example literally

 

[77thShad]

Waiting for digitalmez before I vote.

 

[nitasu987]

Well then Sorry Defiant_Blob . it IS the Internet after all.

 

[Vatowski]

Yep just waiting for digital, but she could be lying which is a pain, we will have to ask her who's role did she find out last night of she is

 

[Hockeyfan1852]

Read the last few pages caught up. I will wait for digitalmez as well before changing my vote.

 

[nitasu987]

I may change my vote depending on what digi says.

 

[digi]

Damn the observation skills of Sploorky. Ladies, gents, I imply one thing and you think that maybe I might be the cop?
I simply stated that I was reading through the posts and felt like my own personal sleuth. Trying to find anything that may lead us to the killer and you know what I found-- NOTHING! This is all so frustrating trying to decipher what your messages might have meant. At this point I'm not ready to vote. Just give me a few more hours. But carry on with the voting if you must.

 

[77thShad]

Damn the observation skills of Sploorky. Ladies, gents, I imply one thing and you think that maybe I might be the cop?
I simply stated that I was reading through the posts and felt like my own personal sleuth. Trying to find anything that may lead us to the killer and you know what I found-- NOTHING! This is all so frustrating trying to decipher what your messages might have meant. At this point I'm not ready to vote. Just give me a few more hours. But carry on with the voting if you must.

Seeing this the I vote for Nitasu mainly because how he has been playing and this post below.

Also, I Once Again Retract my vote for Defiant_Blob and now, seeing as he is getting lots of votes for lynching, I once again revert to my old vote of Old_Man_Oak_63. The road to ruin

 

[HarmakAnna]

Okay then

I retract my vote on notty after what dig said

 

[nitasu987]

77_is_the_best Why must I be suspicious because I'm trying to keep you all from voting off the Cop. Why?!?!?!

Lol I don't blame ya, but I voted for oak because he could also be the serial killer. Why do you nubs all think I voted for him for any other reason than:

a. Break the tie and kill the serial killer
b. He had the most votes
c. I didn't want to vote for notty.

 

[Vatowski]

So what's up guys

 

[Oak Milk]

So what's up guys

Not much really, how are you?