Mafia Season 6

Status
Not open for further replies.

Alisha

Member
Mafia Host
Mafia Mod
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
805
Reaction score
2,829
Shit, I didn't see that post. ALright I take back what I said for question 1 dessern. I understand your suspicions of me but I merely want the game to continue. I've made my accusations during times where people were hardly posting in this thread.
 

balloon98

The balloon that never pops
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
825
Reaction score
559
Alpha what I want to know is why you are so POSITIVE that defiant is lyncher I know he has been silly at times but still how can you be that sure he isnt possibly mafia trying to gain our trust by acting weird to make us like "oh a mafia wouldnt do that he is obviously inno"
 

Alisha

Member
Mafia Host
Mafia Mod
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
805
Reaction score
2,829
Want to know why I stopped posting during the end of Day 1? Because I knew it would be harder for the mafia, serial killer, and vigilante to find my name when they decided who to target on night one.

And why I never seemed to put too much logic so far and remain neutral on day one, not making a single vote. All plays by me to stay invisible. And it worked, as I am still alive on Day 2.

Or on one of my posts I said that other people will have to do questions when I die. That's actually a stealth joke; my role never seems to make it past day 2.

Come Day 2, huge amounts of inactivity. So I decide to take a different route, mentioning several different people's names so I could figure out who would be a good choice to investigate during Night 2. As put by Dessern5 and Defiant_Blob, reaction tests.

Then the inactivity really steps up, and I have to make a sacrifice. I sacrificed my invisibility to attempt to revive this game by asking inactive members to start talking again.

Now I'm being called on why I am so determined to prove that Defiant_Blob is the lyncher. I know the contact is out there, but I don't know where. I mentioned the contact twice, emphasizing how I want the contact out as soon as possible.
--
I investigated HarmakPaul on Night 1, and found out that he is a civilian. It's possible that he is the godfather as the godfather is immune to cop investigations, but that put him off my immediate red flag list.

Come night 2, I decide to investigate Hockeyfan as he got a lot of flak for the events of Day 1. I counted on him being mafia, which would make it less likely for him to get killed during the night and I could prove to you guys that I am the cop by naming him as mafia.

But of course, I find out he's a civilian. But I also found out that he was the lyncher's target. So when Defiant_Blob immediately says that HockeyFan1852 was his target and that he's the lyncher, I'm inclined to believe him. Especially since he NAMED HockeyFan1852 continually during Day 1.

Here's my concern: That you guys fear another NottyKitten incident and vote me out immediately.

I do not know who the contact is. I have several guesses but I'm afraid to name anyone since making enemies would not benefit me right now.

But here's the thing. The contact can't identify people as civilians, as that would make it EASIER for us to vote off their mafia buddies. They can SAY their mafia buddies are civilians, but that would be short lived because the contact would be killed during the night, exposing their mafia buddies.

I named HarmakPaul as a civilian, proving that I can't be the contact. The contact can't name civilians because in the long run it would expose them even more.

The reason I was okay with voting Kylie is because of my reasoning that she's not the doctor. Now why would I specificially mention that she is not the doctor?

I am the cop.
 

HarmakAnna

Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2011
Messages
739
Reaction score
944
1. Who is the most suspicious to you and why?
Defiant. Primarily due to the contradicting claims and something else I'll bring up after the questions.
2. Do you believe the role claims?
Nope.
3. STATE YOUR FREAKING OPINION ON WHAT IS GOING ON!
We need more conversation.

When he claimed to be lyncher originally, I didn't really question much. Later, I thought of the alternate idea that he claimed lyncher since it would be easy to make that claim. There wouldn't be much reason for someone to counterclaim as lyncher anyway.
 

MustabearXD

Member
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
170
Reaction score
310
Hmm well after reading Alpha's statement his explanation seems legitimate, I am still a bit worried of another notty incident happening. Defiant seems a bit unstable as he seems he want to get lynched as if its him master scheme. Still watching you Alpha >.< (Don't want another notty)
 

Defiant_Blob

( ̄^ ̄)ゞ
Donor
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
2,631
Reaction score
2,051
I understand your skepticism, I explained as in-depth as I could. Now it's up to you guys to believe me.
If Hockey was my target, why would I deny it?
Nice WIFOM guess, but Hockey really isn't my target lol
Want to guess again Alpha? If the cop really IS revealed the target upon investigating them?
 

gay vampire

Little Miss Organs
Joined
Sep 24, 2011
Messages
848
Reaction score
1,634
1. Hmm, not sure at the current moment. Most likely Alpha, but I'm not suspicious enough to be voting him down yet.

2. Nope, unless there's lots of evidence and clear opinions that the person is the role. I generally just get a little more suspicious at role claims unless there's evidence occupying it.

3. Discussion! Finally!

(Sorry I'm a little late, I was sleeping :3)

The reason I was okay with voting Kylie is because of my reasoning that she's not the doctor. Now why would I specificially mention that she is not the doctor?
This sentence massively confuses me. I stated I wasn't the doctor. I never stated I was the doctor in the first place, so are you implying that I'm an anti-town role and that you've investigated me (which I doubt, since night 3 hasn't arrived yet)? I'm a little confused here, can you clarify?
 

mariosatr

Imperator Romanus Sacer
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
643
Reaction score
1,058
1. Who is the most suspicious to you and why? Not really sure... it could be anyone. We need a couple more leads.
2. Do you believe the role claims? Well, yes. It's really the only thing we've got going for us.
3.STATE YOUR FREAKING OPINION ON WHAT IS GOING ON! We need to move forward, look at what leads we have, and use them to lynch.
 

JKangaroo

Your Local, Neighborhood Marsupial
Joined
Dec 25, 2011
Messages
610
Reaction score
2,132
Wait what, I'm even more confused o.o
Well, day 1, to my knowledge, SHOULD have been yesterday.
From what I remember...
  • Night 1 (Game beings):
    • Marnnixxie (Mafia) dies
    • Digi survives due to anonymous reasoning
    • 77_is_the_best (Fool) dies
  • Day 1 (Yesterday):
    • Nottykitten is lynched
  • Night 2: (The Night we just had)
    • Old_man_Oak (Fanboy) dies
    • Sjaakieto (Civilian) Dies
    • Hockeyfan (Civilian) Dies
  • Day 2: (The present):
    • STILL UNDERWAY
Those SHOULD be the events that have conspired thus far.
So today should be Day 2.
Unless, that is merely just my definition of day 2 and others have a different idea of it.

(I'm sick, and have a couple of school band concerts I have to play in. I really want to post, because I've been able to read during brief moments but I can't do anything in-depth, hopefully I get a chance over the weekend.)
 

Alisha

Member
Mafia Host
Mafia Mod
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
805
Reaction score
2,829
Kylie, my initial argument that made me okay with putting your name down is BECAUSE I am certain you're not the doctor. I never accused you of being the doctor.

As said before, my priorities are keeping the doctor alive, and getting rid of the contact.

I did not get lucky and find any anti-town members. So either we vote someone out or we don't, which since I'm already revealed I would rather just get to night 3, do an investigation, and hopefully the doctor trusts me enough to save me from the night attacks.


Also, the fun that I usually have with mafia has gone down considerably. Probably because of all this inactivity, and reluctance.
 

balloon98

The balloon that never pops
Joined
Aug 6, 2011
Messages
825
Reaction score
559
Ok Alpha so you have made your point and your investigations have checked out since Harmak and Hockey both were innocent so what do you suggest we do? And when you say Kylie is definitely not doctor is it because you have investigated the doctor or her since I don't know why you know that, just to clarify in case I missed something.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top